s5 keller for ronan or mckay

[Falcon Horus]

And what has Keller done exactly that has ever depicted her as a bad doctor?

I'm not suggesting she's a bad doctor... Only counting experience...

Yes, Carson obviously has had more experience as he's obviously older, but that doesn't necessarily make him the better doctor.

True.

[Pandora's_Box]

Well, all her patients do seem to die.

And Carson helped create a serum that wiped out half a population.

They are doctors. Sometimes doctors have patients that DIE. It comes with the territory.

And to say that all her patients die is just plain wrong.

:: sigh :: Weir :: sigh ::
She also found the similarities between the Kirsan Fever bacterium and the one ravaging Atlantis in 'Tabula Rasa' thus saving all their lives.

Honestly, a pretty, young, genius, with insecurity issues, possibly virginal...

Virginal?! Seriously? Where do you get that impression?

...needs a good man to make her whole, um, it just feels like she belongs on a show like "90210" or "The OC" instead of an adventure scifi show.

Just my opinion.

And you're entitled to it, but when was it ever claimed she needed a man to make her feel whole? Just because she enjoys male company and flirts? That's reaching.

[GateLadyM]

And to say that all her patients die is just plain wrong.

I said "they all seem to die" and I feel that way. The gal can't even do CPR right!

Anyway, there IS a hate Keller Anti-Keller thread already, and this has turned into another one. I don't like her for many reasons and I don't want to see Rodney or Ronon drooling around her at all. She irritates me enough as it is.

[Blencathra]

I said "they all seem to die" and I feel that way. The gal can't even do CPR right!

And you know this how????

Anyway, there IS a hate Keller Anti-Keller thread already, and this has turned into another one. I don't like her for many reasons and I don't want to see Rodney or Ronon drooling around her at all. She irritates me enough as it is.

Agreed. Can we leave the hate for the other thread please. This is getting seriously off topic.

Shall we start doing the thread this way?

Keller for Ronon(1)
Keller for Rodney (0)

[Reiko]

Honestly, a pretty, young, genius, with insecurity issues, possibly virginal, needs a good man to make her whole, um, it just feels like she belongs on a show like "90210" or "The OC" instead of an adventure scifi show.

.: Don't even mention the OC! I never want to hear of that show again It was just teen whinings in a sunny bourgeoisie setting, slathered over with bad "emo" ...

.: I also misread "virginal" as something else ... but I shall leave that to your speculation.

.: Though I, too, wonder where did you get "virginal" from? Keller is anything BUT virginal

[Falcon Horus]

You should have a "neither" and a "don't care" in your options.

[Pandora's_Box]

I said "they all seem to die" and I feel that way. The gal can't even do CPR right!

No one on TV does CPR right. It's hardly 'her' and more the lax specialists SGA employs.

Anyway, there IS a hate Keller Anti-Keller thread already, and this has turned into another one.

It's more of a discussion thread, IMO.

I don't like her for many reasons and I don't want to see Rodney or Ronon drooling around her at all. She irritates me enough as it is.

I hate the very prospect of drool as well. Too messy. And I dislike the idea of ships making their way onto SGA. I just don't think that's what the show is about.
However, I wouldn't consider it unrealistic if a couple of characters gave in to their more basic instincts and got together off camera. Namely, Keller and McKay. But that's just me. Evidently.

[Pandora's_Box]

And you know this how????



Agreed. Can we leave the hate for the other thread please. This is getting seriously off topic.

Shall we start doing the thread this way?

Keller for Ronon(1)
Keller for Rodney (0)

Keller for Ronon(1)
Keller for Rodney(1)
Neither(0) (Just for you Falcon)
Don't Care(0)

Personally I don't mind they way this thread has headed. I much prefer it to your traditional Anti or Pro threads where all opinions are one-sided and no discussion or rebuttals are allowed.

It's refreshing.

[Reiko]

.: Then here you go plus my votes

Neither (1)
Don't Care (1) I feel apathy for SGA lately...
Rodney for Ronon FTW. Leave Keller out in the cold (1) even though I am not a slasher, what the hell...
Keller for Ronon (1)
Keller for Rodney (0)
OT3, baby! (0)

[Falcon Horus]

Keller for Ronon(1)
Keller for Rodney(1)
Neither(0) (Just for you Falcon)
Don't Care(0)

Thanks... I shall fill it out now too.

Keller for Ronon(1)
Keller for Rodney(1)
Neither(1)
Don't Care(0)

Personally I don't mind they way this thread has headed. I much prefer it to your traditional Anti or Pro threads where all opinions are one-sided and no discussion or rebuttals are allowed.

Don't know about the positive thread, but the anti's discuss... we sorta think along the same line but we do occasionally butt heads.

It's refreshing.

Well, there's that...

[KindlyKeller]

.: Don't even mention the OC! I never want to hear of that show again It was just teen whinings in a sunny bourgeoisie setting, slathered over with bad "emo" ...

.: I also misread "virginal" as something else ... but I shall leave that to your speculation.

.: Though I, too, wonder where did you get "virginal" from? Keller is anything BUT virginal

This, AGAIN?

Come on, people. Can we at least cover new ground with the insults?

[KindlyKeller]

I'll just say that while I strongly disagree with the assertions that she is incompetent or whiney or too insecure to carry out her duties, there's at least some vague starting point for such discussions.

The CONSTANT assertions that she's a "whore" because of -- let's say it again because people seem to have trouble with this -- one NEAR-kiss (she didn't even ACTUALLY DO IT!) and one relationship... I mean, WOW.

[aquagirl]

Keller for Ronon(2)
Keller for Rodney(1)
Neither(1)
Don't Care(0)

[KindlyKeller]

And as long as we're doing this...

Keller for Ronon(2)
Keller for Rodney(2)
Neither(1)
Don't Care(0)

[Reiko]

.: No one likes my polling sheet?

.: And it was not meant to be an insult ... I was an interpretive observation.