I have to agree with Kindy. Their wasn't much whinning in this episode.
-
Originally posted by aretood2 -
Yep Rodney is just AWFUL in this episode!!
He stays up ALL NIGHT long trying to figure out how to help Ronon!!!!!!
Sits with RONON while he goes through detox.
What is Everyone's definition of Whining??
Maybe the people who Don't LIKE Rodney feel that every time Rodney opens his mouth he whines, or says more than three sentences it somehow becomes a Rodney Episode.
So maybe the people who like I said, hate Rodney are the weakest link?? hmmmWhy did you do such a thing, you mediocre dunces?Comment
-
Yeah, it's a bit much for people to be upset with him in this episode, especially big Ronon fans...
Rodney worked his tail off to find him, sat by the guy's bed when he was sleeping, and when he had the opportunity to be snarky to him (after Ronon made a comment upon waking up that he was going to punch him), he instead excitedly went to share the news that Ronon had woken up.Theoretically spoilerish:
Spoiler:Comment
-
Well i went from thinking he was ok to can't stand him in S4 to hmm maybe there's hope for him in in S5.....Did that make sense....Originally posted by fumblesmcstupid View Post
I thought there may have been a little bit of whining but not much...I mean let's face it,he wouldn't be Rodney if he didn't whine a little bit but it got really ridiculous in S4 with the whining but in S5 it's so far so good so maybe there's hope for him yet
I'm just so glad they've toned down the whining in S5,i just hope for the rest of the season they don't resort back to S4 Rodney!sigpic
Comment
-
I admit to having a "Zero Whine Tolerance"... I hear that tone of voice and my skin crawls! Rodney seems to excell at it and for unknown reasons some people think it is funny to hear a grown man whine! I am not one of those. I actually didn't mind rodney in the first two eps, but then he began whining again! IF they go back to no whine I will be thrilled!Originally posted by Linda06 View PostWell i went from thinking he was ok to can't stand him in S4 to hmm maybe there's hope for him in in S5.....Did that make sense....
I thought there may have been a little bit of whining but not much...I mean let's face it,he wouldn't be Rodney if he didn't whine a little bit but it got really ridiculous in S4 with the whining but in S5 it's so far so good so maybe there's hope for him yet
I'm just so glad they've toned down the whining in S5,i just hope for the rest of the season they don't resort back to S4 Rodney!
Last edited by Rac80; 26 July 2008, 11:54 AM.Comment
-
i love rodney whining. no whine, then whe have to check whether its not a shapeshifting alienComment
-
Oh i don't find whining funny either....But a very small bit i can handleOriginally posted by Rac80 View PostI admit to having a "Zero Whine Tolerance"... I hear that tone of voice and my skin crawls! Rodney seems to excell at it and for unknon reasons some people think it is funny to hear a grown man whine! I am not one of those. I actually didn't mind rodney in the first two eps, but then he began whining again! IF they go back to no whine I will be thrilled!
sigpic
Comment
-
without rodney, and some carter type of replacement, it would become too much like SG1Comment
-
you are a better woman than I am... no whine...all the time!Originally posted by Linda06 View PostOh i don't find whining funny either....But a very small bit i can handle
Comment
-
Well then...That's when the mute button comes in handyOriginally posted by Rac80 View Postyou are a better woman than I am... no whine...all the time!
sigpic
Comment
-
See, I hear people say the same thing about Keller. In both cases I don't mind them. Like them both because they seem like real people with fears and foibles. (Of course every once in awhile I want to give McKay a swift kick to the rear.)Originally posted by Rac80 View PostI admit to having a "Zero Whine Tolerance"... I hear that tone of voice and my skin crawls! Rodney seems to excell at it and for unknown reasons some people think it is funny to hear a grown man whine! I am not one of those. I actually didn't mind rodney in the first two eps, but then he began whining again! IF they go back to no whine I will be thrilled!
He wasn't whiny this week though, I thought.My Livejournal
I watched all of the first four seasons of SGA last May. Here are my newbie impressions.Comment
-
Exactly, miniglik. Keller whines too, in a similar tone of voice. I find it charming from both of them, in moderation, which I think both achieve.
I still think it's pretty unfair that McKay can't whine because he's a guy and Keller gets a free pass because she's a girl.Theoretically spoilerish:
Spoiler:Comment
-
and my mute button activates the closed captioning so I don't miss any of the storyline.Originally posted by Linda06 View PostWell then...That's when the mute button comes in handy Hopefully next week will have less whining and a more enjoyable ep! 
(ok I admit I inhabit a fantasy world on that topic... but let me have my delusions! )
Sorry Kindly but I see a world of difference between a young woman (in her 20's) and a (supposedly 40 ish) adult male whining!
some things are just different! "time passages" you know! What is cute at one age is simply annoying (or disgusting as the case may be) at another. Ever seen a gal or guy in their 50's dressing like they are 25? yeeech! Atleast IMHO!
Comment
-
Originally posted by Rac80 View Postand my mute button activates the closed captioning so I don't miss any of the storyline. Hopefully next week will have less whining and a more enjoyable ep!
(ok I admit I inhabit a fantasy world on that topic... but let me have my delusions! )
Oh that is cool...
Ok fantasy world activated!sigpic
Comment
-
Comment