Season Five : Compliments and Praise Thread

[Briangate78]

Jennifer and Carson get on quite well IMO, he's accepted her as the CMO of Atlantis now and with the plague to deal with Carson has other stuff to do, I wonder if that'll get a mention in this episode.

Yeah it was a smooth transition as far as Carson showing up on the scene. The two of them hit if off pretty well. It was not like "Hey, B**** what are you doing with my job"

[GoSpikey]

Brian was snipped!

[ed263]

Yeah it was a smooth transition as far as Carson showing up on the scene. The two of them hit if off pretty well.

I agree, I thought they got along very well. I really enjoyed seeing them in the same scene. I think Carson accepting that Keller is now the CMO is keeping within his character, I could not really see Carson getting mad at Keller and resenting her for it.

It was not like "Hey, <mod snip>what are you doing with my job"

Wow! The moderators actually monitor! Sorry Brian about getting snipped! Hope it didn't hurt to much!

[Guest]

Yeah it was a smooth transition as far as Carson showing up on the scene. The two of them hit if off pretty well. It was not like "Hey, ***** what are you doing with my job"

Yeah, in 'The Kindred' Carson had a lot to take in involving the revelation that he was not forgotten because he was a clone and really I think seeing a replacement as CMO wouldn't have been the biggest thing on his mind.

It would be great if Carson and Jennifer get a scene together, discussing the plague or wraith treatment perhaps, it would be good continuity anyway.

[Briangate78]

Brian was snipped!

Spoiler:

That was a little too much I think. The B word is not like a really bad word. It is used on TV all the time.

Oh and Season 5 rocks! Carson is going to rock in "Identity".

[Pandora's_Box]

That was a little too much I think. The B word is not like a really bad word. It is used on TV all the time.

No offense, Brian, but I really have no problem with that word being censored out. If this is a PG forum and certain other words aren't allowed then that one shouldn't be either.

As for it being used all the time on TV, SGA included, frankly I find that more than a little offensive. That a word degrading women (yes, I know that it actually means) is about the only profanity allowed and allowed quite often.

Oh and Season 5 rocks! Carson is going to rock in "Identity".

Not a fan of his, but I hope so.

[Guest]

Oh and Season 5 rocks! Carson is going to rock in "Identity".

Jennifer will rock as well.

[Mitchell82]

I agree, this could've been handled differently and better but the overall storyline was ok imo. again, Joe admitted that this wasn't the perfect solution

Agreed. It could have been handled better but it wasn't that bad.

yeah the kid was annoying. the pic's awesome

Spoiler:

Yeah she was but she was a typical 13 year old and it was kinda a fun ep.

I think Joe's a great showrunner but his eps are...

Some of them are a bit meh others are great. A good example is this one.

Spoiler:

As well as Kindred, Suspicion are a few more good examples.

nah I don't think so. do you remember Quarantine?

Spoiler:

True I wonder who it could be. Between Lorne and Chuck I'd have to say Chuck is more likely.

[Linda06]

My doctor baby is back in the next ep

[jelgate]

My doctor baby is back in the next ep

Keller was awesome

[Linda06]

Keller was awesome

*whacks Jel over the head with tuna*

[jelgate]

*whacks Jel over the head with tuna*

Well my cat is hungry

[Guest]

Keller was awesome

Indeed.

[Linda06]

Well my cat is hungry

I love cats

[jelgate]

I love cats

Technically its the family cat. I'm more of a dog person.

Like a dog, Keller is reliable to make an episode good.