Season Five : Compliments and Praise Thread

[g.o.d]

LOL, there is hope for you.

I doubt that

[Briangate78]

I doubt that

Oh well, can't save them all. BTW, I don't think you are going to like SGU. The same exact writing team for SGA is going there. However, It raised the optimistic bar for myself, even if it is replacing my current favorite show.

BTW, do you watch Family Guy?

[jelgate]

I don't understand it, TPTB are capable of writing great episode such as "Remnats" but also they can create crap like Irr, Trio and Harmony

Quality is subjective

[Briangate78]

Quality is subjective

Well M&M redeemed themselves from "Whispers" and "Irresponsible"

[Linda06]

So you're going to watch 'Brain Storm' then?

Yes If only to slate it

You never know, you might get a good few scenes in upcoming episodes, 'Infection' for one.

Na, I won't hold my breath...We've had our token Teyla eps for the season!

Even with episode like 'The Queen' and 'The Prodigal'?

They are few and fa between i'm afraid....Which makes it worse because we know they are capable of so much better than they give us most of the time!

So far, The Shrine has been the only episode to feature McKeller in any way and I think that the general consensus is that that episode was pretty stellar.

I refuse to judge future "McKeller-centric" episodes before they air.

The shrine sucked so badly I had no interest in seeing Rodney

Spoiler:

dying...Yet again

[jelgate]

We need a Teyla dying episode

[Jumper_One]

We need a Teyla dying episode

Teyla whump?

btw Remnants was awesome imo

[jelgate]

Teyla whump?

btw Remnants was awesome imo

It would most likely please the goldfish

below average to mediocre being closer to mediocre

[Linda06]

We need a Teyla dying episode

I would be happy if they just changed it around a bit...You know

Spoiler:

instead of having Rodney dying all the time or John getting whumped all the time or Teyla dealing with the wraith almost all the time in their centric eps....Why not have John or Ronon be the one's in mortal peril for a change and have Rodney or Teyla be the one's to get whumped!

[Jumper_One]

It would most likely please the goldfish

below average to mediocre being closer to mediocre

Spoiler:

[jelgate]

I didn't know Jumper_One has been in Scottland

[Linda06]

I didn't know Jumper_One has been in Scottland

hmm, where's Scottland?

[Briangate78]

Remnants was excellent, but "The Prodgial" was better and more dramatic. ,imho

[Infinatus]

Remnants was a solid, well written episode. There weren't any plot holes that I was aware of. Although I knew how the episode was going to end from the beginning, I enjoyed the ride, and a certain something about Zelenka was an interesting surprise.

[Infinatus]

Remnants was excellent, but "The Prodgial" was better and more dramatic. ,imho

I actually didn't like the really cliche showdown scene. It made the episode seem like a Batman wannabee.