Season Five : Compliments and Praise Thread

[CazzBlade]

An excellent review of The Prodigal

[Linda06]

An excellent review of The Prodigal

Already read it like I said earlier

Spoiler:

One part of it....Can we keep Banks

[Guest]

An excellent review of The Prodigal :

Excellent my tail.

Keller is far more interesting than Banks and serves a greater purpose on the show, 'Gate tech takes on a hybrid and what, she could also fill in for CMO now? Talk about delusional.

Already read it like I said earlier

Spoiler:

One part of it....Can we keep Banks

Not at the expense of Keller.

[jelgate]

Excellent my tail. Keller is far more interesting than Banks and serves a greater purpose on the show, 'Gate tech takes on a hybrid and what, she could also fill in for CMO now? Talk about delusional.Not at the expense of Keller.

The amount of Keller hate never ceases to amaze me.

[Briangate78]

Spoiler:

I just don't get some of the negatives towards this season, the show is just as good as it was in Season one. Eps like "The Prodigal" are just an example. Prodigal had "The Eye" written all over it and it had the same dramatic effect for me.I hope GW rates Prodigal at least 3 stars because this episode belongs in the "DV" and "Gitm" catergory. It was not just a regular episode, it ended a story arc and enemy introduced 3 years ago.

[Linda06]

Excellent my tail.

Keller is far more interesting than Banks and serves a greater purpose on the show, 'Gate tech takes on a hybrid and what, she could also fill in for CMO now? Talk about delusional.

Just like the delusion of

Spoiler:

wraith fighting gun totting super doc!

The amount of Keller hate never ceases to amaze me.

Well believe it or not some of us don't like getting things we don't like rammed down our throats

[jelgate]

Well I know a lot people were sad to see Michael die. I think you all know my opinion on that

[Guest]

The amount of Keller hate never ceases to amaze me.

I know what you mean, I'm getting tired of it, one reason I really enjoy coming to this thread is it doesn't devolve into a 'hate Keller' or anti something else discussion unlike most of the rest of the forum where such topics are fair game.

[Atlantis15]

Loving Season 5 so far. Prodigal was awesome and I loved the fights scenes. I also don't get what people have against Keller personally I love her and don't find her at all whiny ( maybe I just have a high tolerence for whining) also I like the Mckeller ship.

Can't wait for the next ep.

[Pandora's_Box]

Excellent my tail.

Keller is far more interesting than Banks and serves a greater purpose on the show, 'Gate tech takes on a hybrid and what, she could also fill in for CMO now? Talk about delusional.

Thank you, Foxz. I'd green you if I could.

Just like the delusion of

Spoiler:

wraith fighting gun totting super doc!

For Pete's sake! She defended herself for all of 5 seconds with a stick. She was clumsy and slow and had she been forced to do it any longer she would have wound up that Wraith's lunch.

[Guest]

Just like the delusion of

Spoiler:

wraith fighting gun totting super doc!

Well Keller developed into that,

Spoiler:

'Tracker' she reveals that she'd been taking sparring lessons and in 'The Lost Tribe' it's revealed that she'd been practice firing but never fired a P90 outside of the range. I don't see how that is the same. Can Banks study to be an MD on Atlantis then rise to CMO in a matter or months? Impossible.

[Linda06]

For Pete's sake! She defended herself for all of 5 seconds with a stick. She was clumsy and slow and had she been forced to do it any longer she would have wound up that Wraith's lunch.

Round about the same amount of time Banks was fighting a mere hybrid so why is it delusional for one person to fight but it's perfectly fine for another?

[Linda06]

Well Keller developed into that,

Spoiler:

'Tracker' she reveals that she'd been taking sparring lessons and in 'The Lost Tribe' it's revealed that she'd been practice firing but never fired a P90 outside of the range. I don't see how that is the same. Can Banks study to be an MD on Atlantis then rise to CMO in a matter or months? Impossible.

And Banks

Spoiler:

is a kick boxer so why is it so unbelievable for her to fight a mere hybrid?

And no one said anything about her being the CMO!

[Guest]

Loving Season 5 so far. Prodigal was awesome and I loved the fights scenes. I also don't get what people have against Keller personally I love her and don't find her at all whiny ( maybe I just have a high tolerence for whining) also I like the Mckeller ship.

Can't wait for the next ep.

Yeah 'The Prodigal' was awesome.

Thank you, Foxz. I'd green you if I could.

No problem, it's the thought that counts.

[Pandora's_Box]

Round about the same amount of time Banks was fighting a mere hybrid so why is it delusional for one person to fight but it's perfectly fine for another?

Because after Tracker aired it seemed the forum was abuzz with shouts and claims of ,"OMG! KingFu!Keller will take over the show! She's taking Ronon's place!" When those claims were absolutely absurd because her technique was horrible and she would have accomplished nothing more than fending off her inevitable painful death for 5 seconds had Rodney not intervened with a gun. She was hardly KungFu!-anything.

I never claimed it was "delusional" for Banks to be a capable of fighter, only that it came out of nowhere and that I was surprised. I don't much care either way.

I'm just not happy with the claim that she can now take Keller's place. What is she, Super!Banks?