Season Five : Compliments and Praise Thread

[Jumper_One]

I gotta say this. Whispers was not that good at all, lol. There I said it.

LOL yeah Whispers was ok

Outsiders made Carson look great, Whispers totally misused or under-used (Um is that a word? )his character and what he is all about. Outsiders showed what the character Dr. Carson Beckett is all about.

I'd say it under-used Carson

Yep Classic stargate...I miss these kinda eps I'd have given it 10 if it wasn't for the bit at the end

huh?

[Linda06]

huh?

The bit when

Spoiler:

Carson and Rodney were walking out of the lab and Carson said somthing about if Rodney was seeing someone or something like that

[Jumper_One]

The bit when

Spoiler:

Carson and Rodney were walking out of the lab and Carson said somthing about if Rodney was seeing someone or something like that

that's it? come on that was funny

[Linda06]

that's it? come on that was funny

Not when you can't stand a certain ship

[Briangate78]

Keller is my least favorite character but I don't hate her, far from it. I think with Carson around this season it has been good, well 2 out of 3 eps so far, lol. With Outsiders it makes me wish Carson was still the CMO.

[Jumper_One]

Not when you can't stand a certain ship

true but Carson wasn't asking about Keller

Keller is my least favorite character but I don't hate her, far from it. I think with Carson around this season it has been good, well 2 out of 3 eps so far, lol. With Outsiders it makes me wish Carson was still the CMO.

3/3

[Linda06]

Keller is my least favorite character but I don't hate her, far from it. I think with Carson around this season it has been good, well 2 out of 3 eps so far, lol. With Outsiders it makes me wish Carson was still the CMO.

Yeah I want my Carson back *sniff*

[Linda06]

true but Carson wasn't asking about Keller



3/3

Yeah maybe he wasn't but we know about it so no doubt McKay will spill to Carson....I don't understand why they have to bring it up in almost every ep!

[Arica15]

Not when you can't stand a certain ship

Hon it's me, you know how much I hate Keller, but tonight was so awesome that I can honestly say they could have had her on at the end dancing the can can and frankly it wouldn't have made a blind bit of difference. It was that good!

[Linda06]

Hon it's me, you know how much I hate Keller, but tonight was so awesome that I can honestly say they could have had her on at the end dancing the can can and frankly it wouldn't have made a blind bit of difference. It was that good!

Yes it was that

[Guest]

Keller is my least favorite character but I don't hate her, far from it. I think with Carson around this season it has been good, well 2 out of 3 eps so far, lol. With Outsiders it makes me wish Carson was still the CMO.

I prefer Keller as CMO, Clone-Carson is far better working on the plague as he had a hand in it's creation and that's what was good about 'Outsiders', he was given something good to work with.

[GoSpikey]

Brian admits it! Whispers wasn't good!

[Jumper_One]

Yeah maybe he wasn't but we know about it so no doubt McKay will spill to Carson....I don't understand why they have to bring it up in almost every ep!

of course it's supposed to remind us of their relationship (or lack thereof) but come on you said it yourself, this was a great team ep + Carson. the end aka 3 seconds shouldn't bother you

Brian admits it! Whispers wasn't good!

you should...

Spoiler:

[Linda06]

of course it's supposed to remind us of their relationship (or lack thereof) but come on you said it yourself, this was a great team ep + Carson. the end aka 3 seconds shouldn't bother you

I took 1 point off for that bit Now that I know it's there I can just press stop before that bit comes on

And yes it was a great ep so I can forgive a slip up and the end scene

[GoSpikey]

Cos it's a story, Linda...

It actually moves forward.