I love the last one it is one of my faves
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Dr Jennifer Keller/ Jewel Staite Appreciation/Discussion
Collapse
X
-
I just re-watched The Broca Divide today. 5th episode, season 1 SG-1. It's the episode that Janet is introduced to us as SGC's CMO.
I'm thinking I'll go back and refresh myself on Keller's introduction. It seems that most of the detractors feel that she's immature or non-professional in her approach and they've felt that from the start. I'm trying to figure this out.
Janet was clearly facing an unknown pathogen and even complained that she couldn't call on assistance due to the need-to-know security surrounding the SGC. She was also quite informal with other officers.
Keller was facing dire circumstances as well when we first met her.
Has anyone done a comparison in which they've watched the two episodes somewhat near each other?
I don't mean to turn this into a Janet-bash (please, no!) as I love Janet. I'm just trying to see if it can somehow bolster more support for Keller as CMO.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Pic-CollSwan View PostI just re-watched The Broca Divide today. 5th episode, season 1 SG-1. It's the episode that Janet is introduced to us as SGC's CMO.
I'm thinking I'll go back and refresh myself on Keller's introduction. It seems that most of the detractors feel that she's immature or non-professional in her approach and they've felt that from the start. I'm trying to figure this out.
Janet was clearly facing an unknown pathogen and even complained that she couldn't call on assistance due to the need-to-know security surrounding the SGC. She was also quite informal with other officers.
Keller was facing dire circumstances as well when we first met her.
Has anyone done a comparison in which they've watched the two episodes somewhat near each other?
I don't mean to turn this into a Janet-bash (please, no!) as I love Janet. I'm just trying to see if it can somehow bolster more support for Keller as CMO.sigpic
Comment
-
Originally posted by Pic-CollSwan View PostI just re-watched The Broca Divide today. 5th episode, season 1 SG-1. It's the episode that Janet is introduced to us as SGC's CMO.
I'm thinking I'll go back and refresh myself on Keller's introduction. It seems that most of the detractors feel that she's immature or non-professional in her approach and they've felt that from the start. I'm trying to figure this out.
Janet was clearly facing an unknown pathogen and even complained that she couldn't call on assistance due to the need-to-know security surrounding the SGC. She was also quite informal with other officers.
Keller was facing dire circumstances as well when we first met her.
Has anyone done a comparison in which they've watched the two episodes somewhat near each other?
I don't mean to turn this into a Janet-bash (please, no!) as I love Janet. I'm just trying to see if it can somehow bolster more support for Keller as CMO.
I think I am going to watch Broca Divide and compare. Also, Janet wasn't replacing another character who had a fanbase, Jennifer was.
Comment
Comment