Stargate Atlantis Sucks!

[Major Fischer]

*sigh* Who brought this thread back to life?

I think the producers might ignore the title because it seems slightly immature and they probably wouldn't expect much from the actual post.

The same loud troll keeps bringing it back to life. I think this is a case where his reputation speaks for itself.

[Wass]

There is nothing wrong with criticism as long as it’s constructive but from what I’ve read there no constructive criticism in this thread.

[NightGloom]

There never was, and probably never will be. The word selection in the title speaks for itself.

[Osiris-RA]

in less words ...

exactly! thank you for voicing an informed opinion.

[Osiris-RA]

by the way, for anyone who read the how can you stay interested forum, many asked what epe i watched.

hey, a writer knows when a show needs help.

i watched the first five epes from Rising(s) to Suspicion. i think after the first five hours (counting the time of the shows combined ), one should have made a decision as to the worth of the show.

StarGate (the movie, in case noone noticed) brought an interesting premise which formed into one of the best hit sci fi programs since Star Trek. it combined Star Trek and many other shows including a somewhat informed basis on the Egyptian Legend. Atlantis is very loosly based on something, from what i got, ancient fish people? dunno. anyway. as a television critique, Atlantis needs work on diolougue, character foundation and plot twist.
i for one, couldnt care if the entire 'team' such as it is got sucked into a black hole on the way back to waterworld in a 'puddle jumper'.

make me wonder! make me care!

[Gothann]

The same loud troll keeps bringing it back to life. I think this is a case where his reputation speaks for itself.

Considering his only two posts are in this thread, it's not surprising...

He's gloating at the fact that ONE producer mentions Star Trek Voyager in an interview. Thing is, this isn't the only thread in the world with that information. The SciFi board has two threads about the parallel, far too many TV Critics did the comparison.. You get the point. He was mentioning ST:V simply because he wanted to dissuade people from thinking that SG:A is a ripoff of that show.

[Buggy542]

I can't say I'm a fan of SG:Atlantis, but I LOVE SG1. I want Atlantis to continue because if it was cancelled, it would affect SG1.

Oh, and ST:Voyager wasn't bad, I liked it. Infact, Star Trek was the thing that got me into scifi in the first place, and I've seen every episode of Voyager.

The same thing goes with Enterprise. I really don't think its that good, but its Star Trek, and I feel like I have to be loyal to it because of that.

[Ugly Pig]

*sigh* Who brought this thread back to life?

Why, the same poster who originally started it, of course. I guess he just couldn't bear to see it die.

May I ask, why haven't this thread been closed already? There's no real discussion here, it's being kept alive by a single troll (and by now it should be painfully obvious to everyone that he really is just a troll) reviving it from time to time when it's slipped "too far" away from the first page, with nothing new to add... Why should he be allowed to do that?

[Madeleine]

This thread is now closed. It is duplicated by How can you stay interested? so if anyone really wants to they can continue this discussion in that thread.