Originally posted by Peterking72
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
ID4 #2 does poorly.. will that impact the SG reboot films?
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
Originally posted by thekillman View PostNope. "daedalus variations" is just one example.
All other variations they pop into are very closely resemble their original. They even found an alternate versions of their team, dead. McKay even comments on that how are they going to get out of the situation if their alter egos failed.
Besides all alternative universes ever explored on any SG TV shows was mostly identical and had these similar traits I was talking about.
My best example would be the episode called Ripple Effect. In that episode the gate "malfunctions" and different versions of SG-1 gate into the SGC from alternate universes. Everyone starts talking with each other about their experiences and the differences between their universes. I'm sure if there were any more significant differences than SG-1 consisting of different people in some cases, that the show runners would have made sure we noticed those. For example if in an alternate universe the Goa'uld were not snake-like parasites, but looked like the alien Ra we saw in the original Stargate film. OR if there were no Goa'ulds at all. Nothing like that happened, so we can safely conclude that all alternate universes have something that constant in all of them and makes no room for an alternate universe like the universe from the original film among them.
I hope that puts it right for you.sigpicHallowed are the Ori.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Gifford2006 View PostThere won't be any ideas taken from the stargate we love. RE and DD have said in interviews that they despise everything about the series. They don't consider anything about it to be real Stargate
Back to the topic: I seriously doubt that we would see an original masterpiece from these two bozos.sigpicHallowed are the Ori.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Peterking72 View PostIt actually isn't.
Originally posted by Peterking72 View PostNothing like that happened, so we can safely conclude that all alternate universes have something that constant in all of them and makes no room for an alternate universe like the universe from the original film among them.
In stead, it suggests that meetings with Alternate Universes are inherently biased: only a universe reasonably close to ours would meet the specifications to suffer the Ripple Effect: Any universe in which the Goa'uld won, there would be no SG team out adventuring. So they wouldn't know our code. Any universe in which the code is different, they wouldn't be coming through. Any universe that is totally alien to us might not even have Stargates.
I think it's fairly clear that the Multiverse is massive and that we simply never ventured that far from our probability space.
Comment
-
OK, seems like I have to use my Trump Card. (No.It's not THAT Trump)
The original Stargate film took place in a different Galaxy,... far far away from ours. The planet Abydos in the TV franchise was in the Milky Way, but in the film it was in an unknown, distant galaxy.
I leave some space blank for that piece of information to settle in.
...
...
OK. So how would a thing like a planet and entire species relocating from a "trillion light year" away galaxy into ours fits into an alternate universe.
I'll tell you: It won't. Not in an infinity.
Anyway Devlin and Emmerich hate the TV shows, so they will probably distance the new films (if there will be any) from the them. If a new TV show gets made after those films: It won't use an alternate universe explanation for the differences it will have from the original TV shows. That would be just impractical: 1)New audience: A lot of fans, who grew up on the old TV shows probably wouldn't bother, so an explanation to the new generations would be kind of pointless.
2)I bet that if a new TV show is made after the films than DD and RE would be in the helm. Even they are not that stupid to sell a good franchise twice.
BUT, who knows, who knows.....sigpicHallowed are the Ori.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Peterking72 View PostOK, seems like I have to use my Trump Card. (No.It's not THAT Trump)
The original Stargate film took place in a different Galaxy,... far far away from ours. The planet Abydos in the TV franchise was in the Milky Way, but in the film it was in an unknown, distant galaxy.
I leave some space blank for that piece of information to settle in.
.
Comment
-
Every time on the TV show they were able to trace the traveler, M.A.L.P. I mean if the distance calculation, measurement was wrong in the original film you'd bet your ass that Carter would've noticed that in the series and would have said something like: "General Hammond, I noticed an error in the distance calculation concerning the 1994 Abydos mission. It appears that after recalculation, the location of the planet Abydos is inside of our Galaxy, the Milky Way, Sir."
After all a mistake like that would stick out like a fly in a tomato soup.
Any way why on Earth you want it so bad for the universe of the original film to fit in the universe of the TV show. It's not like it would broke the continuity if they were to stay separate. Devlin and Emmerich will probably make a more complete separation if they continue the story from the ending of the original film, which would be the most logic decision concerning the franchise.
If a new TV show is to be made I'd like it to be different as well if Devlin and Emmerich directed it. That way they wouldn't mock the "sanctity" or bring shame on the old TV show.sigpicHallowed are the Ori.
Comment
-
Well, that's that then... But I do love his reasonings, and he does have a point that it's all about numbers these days and not so much the content, which is sad.Heightmeyer's Lemming -- still the coolest Lemming of the forum
Proper Stargate Rewatch -- season 10 of SG-1
Comment
-
Originally posted by Peterking72 View PostEvery time on the TV show they were able to trace the traveler, M.A.L.P. I mean if the distance calculation, measurement was wrong in the original film you'd bet your ass that Carter would've noticed that in the series and would have said something like: "General Hammond, I noticed an error in the distance calculation concerning the 1994 Abydos mission. It appears that after recalculation, the location of the planet Abydos is inside of our Galaxy, the Milky Way, Sir."
After all a mistake like that would stick out like a fly in a tomato soup.
Originally posted by Elite Anubis Guard View Post
Oh well. Can't feel sad for something we knew nothing about.
Comment
Comment