earth ship landing on atlantis proof?

[apollo22]

i was watching the episode "Pegasus project" of sg1 season 10 and i noticed something right after the opening credits. its a bulge on the right side of the city that doesnt really corrolate with other pictures of the city. u decide. here r two pics, one far off and the other has the area is circled. what do u think?

[Sirick]

Yes... Earth Ships can land on Atlantis... I really don't understand what your getting at.

[Switch42]

They've shown the Daedalus up close landing on Atlantis. I don't recall the episode at the moment. But, Atlantis would have to be able to land ships on it. The Ancients had warships. Where else would they park them?

[Jackie]

i was watching the episode "Pegasus project" of sg1 season 10 and i noticed something right after the opening credits. its a bulge on the right side of the city that doesnt really corrolate with other pictures of the city. u decide. here r two pics, one far off and the other has the area is circled. what do u think?

*squinting**removing very thick prescription glasses**rubbing eyes**squinting again**

I think you have the eye sight of an eagle--I can't make out a thing.

However, I do recall the Deadelus landed on the south or east pier of Atlantis a number of times.

[PG15]

Just looks like a lump to me.

The Daedalus lands in the water beside a pier until we get a CLEAR screencap that tells us differently.

[Semmer]

That has to be the bow of Odyssey. Of course it has to be confirmed by someone with season 10 HD-DVD package.

[mlarke]

Just looks like a lump to me.

The Daedalus lands in the water beside a pier until we get a CLEAR screencap that tells us differently.

watch the siege part 3 again. i'm possitive they land ON atlantis. It's after they go nuke 2 or 3 hives and get beat up on.

[zoislk]

watch the siege part 3 again. i'm possitive they land ON atlantis. It's after they go nuke 2 or 3 hives and get beat up on.

Absolutely, I remember that clearly. Daedalus lands on the east pier. And I think others are right in that that isn't the only time it's happened.

No, it isn't landing in the water, it's clearly on the pier. I don't know where to get shots from that episode so I can't help proof it to those that don't remember ... but watch the episode again if you really don't think it does.

[Almighty_Wookie]

It definitely does land on the pier, I remember seeing it a few times throughout the series, plus it has been mentioned quite a few times as well. And I do recall seeing a wallpaper someone had made that was a shot of the Daedalus physically on the pier.
I can't make too much out on that picture myself but it will be either the Daedalus or the Odyssey. But my money is on the former as they were flying in on the Odyssey at the time. But then again it could be another CG goof.

[jenks]

[Inty]

And like the CGI people don't make mistakes. They SAY that they grant them permission to land ON the east pier not besides it. I don't tend to believe that that "spray" of water is proof of it landing in the water. I'm sure it could but why should it? Ok to tell you the truth i would like it better if they landed in the water but hey the pier sounds nice too.

[Team SG-1*save the show*]

watch the siege part 3 again. i'm possitive they land ON atlantis. It's after they go nuke 2 or 3 hives and get beat up on.

They do land on the pier. i remember it too and i am sure i have seen ships land on the pier in other episodes of Atlantis. i cant make out the pics though. that bulge could be anything

[Wraith_Boy]

High quality landing pic

[apollo22]

Yes... Earth Ships can land on Atlantis... I really don't understand what your getting at.

i am getting at that it shows the bow of the ship extending out the side of atlantis. this view of it has never been showing before.

and to both jenks and wraith_boy' pics it is definetly over water. u must be blind if u cant see that

[PG15]

Here we go again.

I really don't give a damn what the dialogue says, because we SEE that the Deady lands on the WATER. How do you know if it's not the actor who made the mistake of saying "on" instead of "beside"? The CGI is approved by TPTB directly, so they'll know if something this wrong is indeed something they don't want.

Also, note the tiny poles ("streetlights") sticking out of the edge of the pier. They show us where the edge of the pier is, there is no going around that one. The Deady lands in the water, END OF STORY.

Once more, I put out my challenge: if anyone thinks the Deady still lands on the pier, do provide visual evidence instead of just saying "I remember" or "I recall".