Megathread - Versus battles

[Ouroboros]

A T-800 vs. a Cylon centerion

The Terminator without a sweat, especially after seeing Salvation.

[Daryl Froggy]

well, since the hebridan society is similar to earth, i guess they've had their share of wars, which would give them at least some competent commanders. and the travelers have been at war wich the wraith for a long time. i think it's pretty even, actually.

I know that they are a fairly even match that is why I chose the two of them. I figured that it would be an interesting and highly debatable subject. Assuming no one brings in any outside help for their side.

As much as I love the idea of living in space for generations I am going to have to say the Hebridians are going to win. I cannot pin it down exactly but that is what I think.

[tjoflojt]

I know that they are a fairly even match that is why I chose the two of them. I figured that it would be an interesting and highly debatable subject. Assuming no one brings in any outside help for their side.

As much as I love the idea of living in space for generations I am going to have to say the Hebridians are going to win. I cannot pin it down exactly but that is what I think.

well, since they have at least one planet, they have the upper hand on production. but i don't know about the travelers... i guess it comes down to who has better weapons and shields, as usual.

[General_Finley]

A T-1000 versus Replicarter

Human form, Asuran, or bug. if it were against a Human form or an Asuran the t-1000 would loose, against the bugs it stands a good chace of wining, ofcourse there is still the matter of there acid which could probably do some damage to the 1000

[Daryl Froggy]

well, since they have at least one planet, they have the upper hand on production. but i don't know about the travelers... i guess it comes down to who has better weapons and shields, as usual.

Hm. Well the Travelers could probably mine some asteroid belts in uninhabited systems.

But who does have better weapons and shields? With the Hebridians there is not a whole lot to go by.

[tjoflojt]

Hm. Well the Travelers could probably mine some asteroid belts in uninhabited systems.

But who does have better weapons and shields? With the Hebridians there is not a whole lot to go by.

no... there's were minor displays in the space race, but those were racing ships. we know their rifles are decent weapons, but shields, i have no clue...

[Daryl Froggy]

Actually do they not mention going really close to their sun in that race ostensibly to test their shields? Also their tech would have to be better in some respects than the Goa'ulds technology since they drove them off of the planet.

That would be the pre-first episode Goa'uld technology not the post Anubis tech.

[tjoflojt]

Actually do they not mention going really close to their sun in that race ostensibly to test their shields? Also their tech would have to be better in some respects than the Goa'ulds technology since they drove them off of the planet.

That would be the pre-first episode Goa'uld technology not the post Anubis tech.

hm... I guess you're right, haven't seen the ep in nearly two years I still think it's pretty even, though...

[Daryl Froggy]

True I was just trying to quantify a general area of advancement where the Hebridian's technology would be.

[tjoflojt]

yeah... you would't happen to remember how close for how long it was? could help determine sheildstrenght.

[Daryl Froggy]

In the episode the hero ship was sabotaged and ended up hanging around the corona of their star for several minutes while they did a quick fix bypass of the sabotaged system. Most of the other ships only spent, at most, a minute in the corona of their sun and had no problems with it.

Of course the rather silly news broadcast mentioned that what they were referring to as the corona was little more than a translucent layer of super heated plasma. And that without shields "you would be instantly vaporized." How accurate that is I do not know however it is the closest thing I can think of to an explanation of how close to their sun they went.

My best guess would be that they can stay there for probably an hour or two before major problems arise. I could be largely wrong in my estimation either on the high end or the low end.

[Stewart5]

I know that they are a fairly even match that is why I chose the two of them. I figured that it would be an interesting and highly debatable subject. Assuming no one brings in any outside help for their side.

As much as I love the idea of living in space for generations I am going to have to say the Hebridians are going to win. I cannot pin it down exactly but that is what I think.

I would say the travellers may have it in the bag.

They can fight the perfect guerrilla war. The Hebrideans wouldn't be able to pin them down in the one place, and of course they'd have to find them first! THe Hebrideans would have static, planetary positions that the Travellers could raid at a whim before vanishing again.

Travellers would wear down the Hebrideans, no matter the military power.

[General_Finley]

Four borg cubes against the Daedalus, Odyssey, Apallo, and Hammond.

Oh and the Travelers would beat the Hebrideanians.

[Buba uognarf]

Four borg cubes against the Daedalus, Odyssey, Apallo, and Hammond.

Oh and the Travelers would beat the Hebrideanians.

Hmm...Depends how long it takes the Borg to adapt.

[General_Finley]

Hmm...Depends how long it takes the Borg to adapt.

how would they adapt to beeing hit by super heated negatively ionized gas? I mean I understand how they adapt to phasers as phasers are a form of energy but plasma is matter that is just very very very hot, and likely has been negativly ionized.