Long ago in the great and loved Golden Age of Sg-1 seasons 5,6,7,8 my opinion, ships stayed about the same size as they had throughout the series. Why is it that in seasons 9 and 10 the ratio in size between Allied ships and the Ori ships are off. e.g. in the final battle of season 9 the Ha'taks look tiny, like a 50th the size of an Ori ship. We all know Hataks are pretty big ships and if so why do the combat fighters coming out of the Ori ship over Chulak look to be the size of Al'kesh when they are supposed to be no bigger than a deathglider.
Plus in season 3 finale Nemesis, at a Guess the Asgard mothership looked to be about 2k in length and I guess the O'Neill is the same size if not bigger. So again in season 9 the O'Neill class ship model appears in the battle but is shorter than the Odyssey, no way is that 2k+ in length.
Super Weapon Ship Anubis Flagship first appeared in season six finale
Full Circle and it engaged a fleet of Ha'taks, in that battle those Hataks were about a 10th the size of Anubis Flagship.
Yet in the Season 7 opener with Daniels return and Carters brilliant but whacky plan to destroy Anubis Superweapon, in their attack run Carter noted they were 400 km out and looking at it from their it was still phenomenal in size.
The ship that held position over Kelowna could not have been the same ship they engaged in the first part because it was to big. Additionally in the Season 7 finale when Anubis fleet drops out of hyperspace the flagship their was the single largest ship to have ever appeared on Stargate possibly hundreds of times bigger than a Ha'tak.
If you doubt any of this thats your choice but watch it and try to prove me wrong.
Plus in season 3 finale Nemesis, at a Guess the Asgard mothership looked to be about 2k in length and I guess the O'Neill is the same size if not bigger. So again in season 9 the O'Neill class ship model appears in the battle but is shorter than the Odyssey, no way is that 2k+ in length.
Super Weapon Ship Anubis Flagship first appeared in season six finale
Full Circle and it engaged a fleet of Ha'taks, in that battle those Hataks were about a 10th the size of Anubis Flagship.
Yet in the Season 7 opener with Daniels return and Carters brilliant but whacky plan to destroy Anubis Superweapon, in their attack run Carter noted they were 400 km out and looking at it from their it was still phenomenal in size.
The ship that held position over Kelowna could not have been the same ship they engaged in the first part because it was to big. Additionally in the Season 7 finale when Anubis fleet drops out of hyperspace the flagship their was the single largest ship to have ever appeared on Stargate possibly hundreds of times bigger than a Ha'tak.
If you doubt any of this thats your choice but watch it and try to prove me wrong.
. Scaling issues really aren't stargates strong point, I remember one of TPTB said they don't keep a bible with all the facts about the series etc etc and so they constantly change things, very lazy on their part imo. Look at hives, officially quoted as 11km long, yet no way appear that big, the deadalus looks 1/11th as long as one yet that would make the deddy 1km long which it so obviously isn't. Ori ships look massive, much bigger than ha'taks and the next moment only a few times bigger. People will argue it's perspective because space isn't 2d yet imo it's just the cgi people suiting the size to their needs (making earth ships look bigger because we're number 1 sort of thing).
:
Comment