Good reasoning, but I'd go with #1 myself. So we have:
#1 - 1
#6 - 1
#7 - 2
The Supernatural Survivor Game, 3rd Edition
The Best Bobby Singer Episode (by starg8fans)
Remember, vote for your LEAST FAVORITE scene, and no more than one vote per round.
Rounds take appr. 24 hours. This round ends at 6 am GMT+1/midnight Eastern tomorrow.
S1, Devil's Trap, The boys meet Bobby
"You get a demon in - they’re trapped. Powerless. It’s like a Satanic roach motel."
S2, Tall Tales, Bobby solves the mystery
"And if you two bothered to pull your heads out of your asses, it all would have been pretty clear. [...] You got a Trickster on your hands."
#3, All Hell Breaks Loose Part 2 - eliminated in Round 1
#4, Dream a Little Dream of Me - eliminated in Round 2
S3, No Rest for the Wicked, Bobby won't let the boys go off to fight Lilith on their own
"Do I look like a ditchable prom-date to you? [...] Family don't end with blood, boy. Besides, you need me."
S4, Lazarus Rising, Bobby goes with Dean to find Sam
"It's him. It's him. I've been through this already, it's really him."
#7 Yellow Fever - eliminated in Round 6
S4, Sex and Violence, Bobby impersonates an FBI chief
"Last time I checked, son, D.C. has jurisdiction. Or am I wrong? "
#9 When the Levee Breaks - eliminated in Round 5
S4, Lucifer Rising, Bobby sets Dean straight when he wants to give up on Sam
"You stupid, stupid, son of a *****. Well boo-hooo I am so sorry your feelings are hurt – Princess."
S5, Sympathy for the Devil, Possessed Bobby stabs himself to save Dean's life
#12, The Curious Case of Dean Winchester - eliminated in Round 3
#13, Two Minutes to Midnight - eliminated in Round 4
S6, Weekend at Bobby's, Bobby speaks his mind about always being there for the boys
"Sam, Dean, I love you like my own. I do. But sometimes you two are the whiniest, most self-absorbed sons of *****es I ever met."
S6, My Heart Will Go On, In this AU Bobby is happily married to Ellen
"We need you. Especially me."