Last edited by Darren; April 10th, 2011 at 04:00 PM.
Overall quite a good episode i think
Only saw the 2nd half because my Virgin Box was playing up, so watched it live on iplayer
Not much character development in this 1, but i think thats because they wanted to set up the story for next week
The Doctor seems very committed to getting people back from enemy hands
A certain comedy element was present as usual, which helped the episode i think because its nice to get a few laughs in
Rorys definately growing on me as a character, glad hes stayed around
Also nice to see an old species being used, seem to hate the human race, hopefully we learn a little bit more about them next week, but they seem like an interesting species which is good (dunno if they are portrayed as well in the old series because i havent seen the old Whos)
This episode was definately a setup for nwxt week, but it was a very good setup for next week and the conclusion to the episode was good with the Doctor finding out that the the tribe is actually a whole civilization underground
Next week looks quite good, very interesting to see how this pans out and is resolved
Last edited by Teddybrown; May 22nd, 2010 at 10:17 AM.
I know next to nothing about the Silurians and sea devils as a classic series enemy so it's hard for me to judge how they were portrayed here. But it was a good episode. I liked the intereaction between the Doctor and Rory mostly plus Rory is beginning to grow on me a fair bit.
It's clearly more of a set up for the next episode. Much like the classic series eps where often very little happend in the initial episode of a story.
I think I've been playing too much Gears of War - I went through the whole episode going "that's an emergence hole...that's the Hollow...".
Quite enjoyed it. Nice to see another old Who foe return, and I loved Amy giving the Silurian lip despite being trapped in a glass coffin ("Did you just 'Shh' me?!").
The Doctor overshooting Rio was amusing. The "I'm the last of my species" dialogue was good.
Wow! Great start to this 2-parter! It was very tense and moody! Marvellous to see a new tribe of Silurians! Having them in this story makes things quite personal for the Doctor. Twice before he tried to make peace between the Silurians and Humans and when he didn't succeed on both occasions there was blood shed on both sides and it hit him hard. Will he fail again? I look forward to seeing Part 2 to find out!
And on a personal note...my first memory of watching Doctor Who was seeing Warriors of the Deep (which was the second story to feature Silurianss for those of you new fans) as a 3-year old in 1984. Seeing Part 1 of The Hungry Earth this evening just feels very significant. Sort of a coming full circle in a way for me.
This one was pretty good, not nailbiting but enough to keep me watching, much looking forward to next week
Mo had Red Shirt written all over him
Ambrose is annoying
I've seen that kid before I'm sure of it, was he in Torchwood?
Rory is growing so much as a character, I do hope they keep him
So, Rory seems to be a full companion now - and he's quite likeable, too. Hope he sticks around for the rest of the series...and maybe the next one.
I can't say I found the episode to be particularly special, but it was certainly enjoyable enough.
Ya I was pretty pleased with it... very pleased in fact... I really like that woman thats heading up the drill project.. she seems like she's companion material... what was her name again... hmm
I dunno what to put in here now..
Now, I dont' want to knock this too much because it was actualyl quite a good episode , bu I do have one small gripe...
Does the Doctor Who team find it impossible to portray a humanoid monster without a human face?
I don't know why, maybe because this is a returning creature from Classic Who, but I felt that the Silurians had been redeisgned to the point they weren't' silurians anymore. If I had to decide which classic series monster they were purely on appearance then I would have gone for Draconians rather than what they were meant to be.
I know we can do so much more now but do all non-human looking monsters have to be CGI? Right up until the Doctor took the mask off I thought it was a good-looking monster. Soon as it was off, it lost something Just makes me feel a bit disappointed, that's all.
Next week looks good good though.
I write articles/features/reviews for I'm With Geek.com now. Check out our stuff if you get a minute!
Click on sig to check out my fanfic gallery too!
what about the ood
Lool, just rewatched the episode
My favourite quote has got to be Rory: Cant you sonic it?
Doctor: It doesnt do wood
Rory: Well thats rubbish
Doctor: Oii, dont diss the sonic!!
I dont have any problem with the aliens that have been on the show so far
So, the green stuff on Tony's neck...is he becoming a Silurian, or is it just a slow acting venom? Will he kill Alaya in some kind of attempt to get the cure or out of revenge?
Also, the trailer for next week...looks good. Who saves Amy, and how, and just what are they doing to the Doctor?
As for the humanoid aliens thing, I totally agree that they look too human, but I expect it's expensive and difficult to make something properly alien that can also elicit positive emotions (since Silurians aren't evil, they're just acting in perceived self-defence), and ultimately much easier to just stick a bit of latex and face paint on and call it non-human.
An enjoyable episode, with some briliant bits. One problem is that I expected Rory to kick up big time over the Doctor losing Amy, he just seemed to roll over.
"Oddly, this is familiar to you, as if it were from an old dream, but you can't exactly remember..."
And the way he said it I think spoke alot more to how he feels about Rory and Amy than is immediately obvious. It seems to me that he wasn't just saying that he needed Rory to help him, but that he generally needed them both in his life.
I'm wondering if this episode is completely standalone, or if there are one or two subtle references to the series arc...I can't help but think that the Doctor seeing the Rory and Amy from the future may end up having some significance...especially since only the Doctor saw them in close up.