Well, that was the first romance scene we've seen in a while in stargate. Personally, I think it was next to unnessecary and overly graphic and the grunting was, well over the top. They didn't actually have to be doing it, it would be the same effect if they were kissing, and then we wouldn't have to put up with the moaning and grunting. So what did you guys think of it.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
What did you guys think of "The Scene"
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by Azriel View PostNot too fussed, I would even say it's realistic so long as it doesn't become a case of 'sex scene of the week'.
I'm interested to see where Scott's character goes from here
Comment
-
It's something everyone does. Seriously, why is everyone so uptight about a sex scene? And not even a graphic one at that. Their shirts weren't even off!
And don't even get me started about the "family-ness" of it.
Really? You would let your children see a man get the life sucked out of him by a wraith... but god forbid if they see how they were pro-created.These are the wrong people... in the wrong place.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Coronach View PostI agree, though I doubt very highly that SGU would ever become such a thing. To be honest, though, I actually felt the scene was not unnecessary. It added something to his character which was hinted at in his later scene with James, as well as through subtleties throughout the episode.
I'm interested to see where Scott's character goes from here
Originally posted by dosed150 View Postdidn't bother me at all really, the over reaction is like how people made out sheppard was some kind of slut, but over 5 years i mean there weren't really that many women~*+*~nEvEr ArGuE WiTh aN iDiOt - ThEy WiLL jUsT dRaG yOu DoWn To ThEiR LeVeL aNd BeAt YoU WiTh ExPeRiEnCe~*+*~
Comment
-
Originally posted by Detox View PostIt's something everyone does. Seriously, why is everyone so uptight about a sex scene? And not even a graphic one at that. Their shirts weren't even off!
And don't even get me started about the "family-ness" of it.
Really? You would let your children see a man get the life sucked out of him by a wraith... but god forbid if they see how they were pro-created.
I don't get it either, but far be it for me to question other people's reasoning behind it. There is very little that would ever offend me, and sex is certainly not one of them.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Azriel View PostYep, it adds to the concept of the characters being human, flawed and not the pretty stereotypical heroes. Don't get me wrong, I loved the characters of SG-1 and Atlantis, this however is a nice refreshing change. While I think stories can often be executed without a sex scene, I do agree that this one was kinda needed to develop Scott's character more.
Lol, I was actually listening to the audio commentary on the S4 boxset the other day, and I can't remember who but one of the producers commented on how he found it amusing how people seemed fine with the whole Sheppard/ Kirk thing but were really annoyed when it was revealed that Keller was interested in Ronan AND McKay xD
actually cant remember her name at all but the woman with scott later i thought i heard her call scott Lieutenant but using the british pronounciation, or do canadians say it properly as well i mean they get z right
Comment
-
Originally posted by dosed150 View Postactually cant remember her name at all but the woman with scott later i thought i heard her call scott Lieutenant but using the british pronounciation, or do canadians say it properly as well i mean they get z right
Comment
-
Originally posted by Detox View PostIt's something everyone does. Seriously, why is everyone so uptight about a sex scene? And not even a graphic one at that. Their shirts weren't even off!
And don't even get me started about the "family-ness" of it.
Really? You would let your children see a man get the life sucked out of him by a wraith... but god forbid if they see how they were pro-created.Originally posted by Coronach View PostAnd there was much worse than that in SGA. I'm thinking of one quite gory-looking scene in particular that involved Teyla.
I don't get it either, but far be it for me to question other people's reasoning behind it. There is very little that would ever offend me, and sex is certainly not one of them.
Comment
Comment