Since the McKay/Keller pairing has the unique distinction of being the only long standing canon relationship between series regulars on SGA, and as such played a larger role in the overall series (as opposed to canon relationships between recurring characters), it's impact on the show as a whole, is a valid topic for discussion.
This thread therefore will be a General Discussion thread, open to ALL POVs, and will include aspects such as the writing, development and overall execution of the ship. The relationship's impact on the tone of the series, as well as its impact on the other characters, are also a point for discussion.
This thread will NOT include bashing of either character just for the sake of bashing. It will also NOTinclude squeeing over, or pic spamming of, the pairing. It is a given that some folks just do not like one or the other character, and that some do like one or both, they just don’t like them together. And then some adore both of the characters and the idea that they are together. So all members are asked to be mindful of each other's personal preferences in that respect.
This will NOT be a *Ship or Anti-Ship* thread and if it begins to read like one, the thread will retire for a break for clean up. It is a discussion thread of ALL opinions. That means that there will be those posting who feel that McKay/Keller added to Season 5, as well as those who feel that McKay/Keller detracted from Season 5. The purpose here is to share points of view, not to convert the masses. Not everyone will share your opinion, please DO NOT take it personally if they don't.
Just to reiterate, this is a General Discussion thread open to ALL POVs. This means there will be opinions that you will agree with and there will be opinions you will not agree with. As long as either one is stated respectfully, and meets the guidelines above, it will be allowed.
If you don't agree with a poster's opinion and can't discuss it in a respectful manner, use the scroll bar and move past it, or if you simply cannot tolerate it, use the ignore feature provided by the forum. However, we hope that you will try to find a way to express your opinion in a way that invites others to discuss it with you and that you in turn will try to find a way to discuss another's opinion that may be different from yours.
This thread therefore will be a General Discussion thread, open to ALL POVs, and will include aspects such as the writing, development and overall execution of the ship. The relationship's impact on the tone of the series, as well as its impact on the other characters, are also a point for discussion.
This thread will NOT include bashing of either character just for the sake of bashing. It will also NOTinclude squeeing over, or pic spamming of, the pairing. It is a given that some folks just do not like one or the other character, and that some do like one or both, they just don’t like them together. And then some adore both of the characters and the idea that they are together. So all members are asked to be mindful of each other's personal preferences in that respect.
This will NOT be a *Ship or Anti-Ship* thread and if it begins to read like one, the thread will retire for a break for clean up. It is a discussion thread of ALL opinions. That means that there will be those posting who feel that McKay/Keller added to Season 5, as well as those who feel that McKay/Keller detracted from Season 5. The purpose here is to share points of view, not to convert the masses. Not everyone will share your opinion, please DO NOT take it personally if they don't.
Just to reiterate, this is a General Discussion thread open to ALL POVs. This means there will be opinions that you will agree with and there will be opinions you will not agree with. As long as either one is stated respectfully, and meets the guidelines above, it will be allowed.
If you don't agree with a poster's opinion and can't discuss it in a respectful manner, use the scroll bar and move past it, or if you simply cannot tolerate it, use the ignore feature provided by the forum. However, we hope that you will try to find a way to express your opinion in a way that invites others to discuss it with you and that you in turn will try to find a way to discuss another's opinion that may be different from yours.
Comment