Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 28
  1. #1
    Brigadier General FallenAngelII's Avatar
    Member Since
    Dec 2005
    Location
    Lemming Prophet/Lemming Slasher
    Posts
    8,147

    Default Showing vs. Telling

    Regardless of how you feel about shipping or the current/past ships in Stargateverse, what do you guys think about how the McKeller ship has unfolded?

    Now, correct me if I'm wrong and I've missed certain key-parts in the McKeller storylines, but this is how I remember it:
    * Rodney and Jennifer fall down a hole (with Sam)
    * They kill time discussing what men they'd rather sleep with (with Rodney eventually joining in, hi hi, ho, ho, ha, ha)
    * Rodney and Jennifer have a drink together
    * A lot of nothing
    * Rodney starts to lose his mind and randomly blurts out "I love you" in a video diary

    (There was also the alternate future BS in "The Last Man", but in that one, Rodney specifically said that they got together because they bonded over grief, loss and other BS things and, hello, alternate future)

    Wait... what?

    Now, I might not like the ship and I might have preferred to not see it at all, but if they're gonna make it overt and canon, they better show us the buildup!

    As it stands, it's pretty friggin' random! I mean, yes, there was the alternate timeline thing, but, hey, Sam married that negotiator guy in that alternate timeline and then he died.

    This romance had pretty much zero buildup. They had a drink, then John saw an alternate timeline that will not come to pass and wham, Rodney's so much in love he's ready to declare his love for Jennifer and wants to give us his spare time going off-world with her to visit sick people or whatever. Even with the alternate timeline, that's not enough to have Rodney go from a drink to "I love you".

    Ummm... OK. So what do you guys think? I think I'd prefer to actually see more of this than have it randomly pop up. As it stands, IMO, this is a pretty random ship that progressed way, way, way too far off-screen.

  2. #2

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    That's true. The relationship between McKay and Keller started in one timeline, and leaped to another without explanation. Therefore, I expect the writers to kill Keller just like in the original timeline (The Last Man). Sheppard is half expecting it already.

  3. #3
    Chief Master Sergeant Ackeb's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    216

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Killing her mey be a little severe, just let Ronon have her instead.

  4. #4
    General Jumper_One's Avatar
    Member Since
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Milkyway, fishing
    Posts
    26,347

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Quote Originally Posted by sblade View Post
    That's true. The relationship between McKay and Keller started in one timeline, and leaped to another without explanation. Therefore, I expect the writers to kill Keller just like in the original timeline (The Last Man).
    LOL

    Quote Originally Posted by sblade View Post
    Sheppard is half expecting it already.
    how so?

  5. #5
    First Lieutenant mellow yellow's Avatar
    Member Since
    Aug 2008
    Posts
    789

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Disclaimer-I ship for ther other team Ronon/Jenn but I do understand what you are saying about showing vs. telling.

    I don't think McKay is in Love with Keller. I think McKay likes her and we now know he wants a relationship with her.

    I think some (for or against ship) are taking things out of context. Just because they went out for a drink doesn't mean Keller wanted to go because she liked McKay in that way.

    I'm assuming Trio was the first time they got to spend time with each other and Keller probably realized that McKay wasn't so bad and wouldn't mind hanging out with him. Just like in real life you work with someone and one day you get to talking and you realize this person is cool and you end up going out after work for a drink.

    In The Shrine, McKay was out of his mind and I'm thinking he probably wanted to say he liked her but love came out instead. People loose touch with reality sometimes..like being drunk..you may confess to someone that you love them but what you were really trying to say was I like you..I have a crush on you.

  6. #6
    Brigadier General FallenAngelII's Avatar
    Member Since
    Dec 2005
    Location
    Lemming Prophet/Lemming Slasher
    Posts
    8,147

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Quote Originally Posted by sblade View Post
    That's true. The relationship between McKay and Keller started in one timeline, and leaped to another without explanation. Therefore, I expect the writers to kill Keller just like in the original timeline (The Last Man). Sheppard is half expecting it already.
    I like (love) that theory! It's as logical as the current situation, if not moreso!

    Quote Originally Posted by mellow yellow View Post
    In The Shrine, McKay was out of his mind and I'm thinking he probably wanted to say he liked her but love came out instead. People loose touch with reality sometimes..like being drunk..you may confess to someone that you love them but what you were really trying to say was I like you..I have a crush on you.
    But Rodney is a man of a lot of thinking and contemplation. Just take a look at his relationship with Katie. I don't think he'd ever say "love" without really meaning it. And I don't think the writers would let Rodney say it without meaning it either.

    For Rodney, the person that he is, with problems expression emotions, over-thinker to the extreme and past 40, to have him just declare his love without meaning it would set a bad example for the younger crowd which is already doing it willy nilly.

    And I think that was one of those moments of clarity, when his mind wasn't completely fried. He sounded normal, after all. But maybe he'd forgotten a few things and gotten "like" mixed up with "love", dunno.

    I think he meant it (and as such, it made no sense).

    Also, if he just "liked" her, then it'd make no sense to tell her before he lost his mind completely. Why would he tell her this? "Oh, and BTW, I like you." ... um... OK? "Wow, Rodney, you like me! Yay!"

    And why would Jennifer sit teary-eyed and rewatch that segment if she didn't have feelings for him back? I don't think we're merely talking about a little "like" here. It's either love or a very strong sense of "like".

  7. #7
    Lieutenant Colonel Pandora's_Box's Avatar
    Member Since
    Feb 2008
    Location
    The Evil League of Evil
    Posts
    4,626

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Would I have preferred TPTB to have shown more detail in the progression of the McKeller storyline? I think any shipper (I can't believe I just called myself that) wishes and hopes to get a fully fleshed out relationship between two particular characters.

    Sure I would have liked to see Jennifer running into Rodney while he spoke to stasis!Carson (that's something you missed, FA. The Seed is particularly rife with McKeller subtext) or see Rodney mumble and flirt clumsily while fixing her laptop or something (something he could have had someone else do).

    But I'm also conscious of the fact that SGA has never been about 'ships. Certainly not serious sexual relationships. Unless, of course, either of the party are going to die.

    SGA is an SF show replete with action, aliens, spaceships, team-building, and "the best man-on-man friendships you'll ever see!!!" and developing a real, meaningful relationship between two people takes more than a bit of time and writing. And that means taking away from what people have grown accustomed to seeing on SGA and certainly from what Stargate has ben marketed as for the past 13 years.

    As it stands, I like that TPTB are finally coming to the conclusion that 13 years and 300 episodes later, some main characters are bound to fall in love, get married, and make babies. But I don't really need to see all the nitty, gritty details.

    There's so much about SGA that I suspend my disbelief for in order to watch it without cringing that I can do it just a little bit longer so as to get some enjoyment out of McKeller.

    If the only things that ever happened to these characters was what we see on screen, then I would never believe that Rodney could fall in love or anyone else for that matter. But it takes some imagination and, I guess, a will to want to make sense of the realtionship to imagine the inbetween stuff we didn't see.

    Show vs. Tell? Obviously showing would be wonderful, but this isn't the show for that. I'll watch BSG for spacesex and overly deep storylines. SGA I'll watch for the humourous characters and relatively compelling storylines.

  8. #8
    Staff Sergeant
    Member Since
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    97

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    I really dont think the relationship is anywhere yet, keep in mind Rodney's poor state of mind when he said 'i love you', he is not at that stage now. I'm just expecting there to be an episode which is centered around the relationship, episode starts with "previously on..." and a quick montage of those key moments and then an episode where Rodney wins the girl

    I really dont think anything has happened yet. I would say the relationship is the equivalent of both of them being in high school. Keller likes mckay and mckay likes keller. but mckay is trying to see if keller likes him back before he does anything. The writers arent idiots, if something is going to happen, they will make it overt. Its not like the next episode is going to open with Keller in having a baby

  9. #9
    Lieutenant Colonel Pandora's_Box's Avatar
    Member Since
    Feb 2008
    Location
    The Evil League of Evil
    Posts
    4,626

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    It wouldn't be the first time a show suddenly decided to pull a "X years later" scenario.

    Alias I'm looking at you. :: grumble grumble grumble ::

    Although, if anymore people have babies on SGA (granted that'll be hard seeing as how the last season is practically half over) I'm officially giving up.

  10. #10
    Staff Sergeant Lianne's Avatar
    Member Since
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Behind the Iron Curtain
    Posts
    97

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Dude, you really like starting new topics, donĀ“t you?

    I agree, but this is Atlantis we are talking about - this show has erased "buildup" from its production dictionary a loong time ago...

  11. #11
    Chief Master Sergeant Showfan's Avatar
    Member Since
    May 2008
    Location
    Out west.
    Posts
    146

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    I agree. It's almost laughable what the writers expect us to swallow.

    I mean, come on, seriously? Only last season, episode 13, Quarantine, McKay was ready to pop the question to Katie Brown. Two episodes later he has a beer with Keller. Cut to this season, episode 6, The Shrine, and he's "...been in love with her for a very long time."

    I realize that there are always time differences from ep to ep, things we might not see, but honestly Trio was episode 16 of the season and after that things moved pretty quickly. Also, no time stretch between Kindred one and two and between The Last Man and Search and Rescue.

    I swear if it wasn't for The Last Man's brainwashing attempt to make fans believe in a relationship that never, ever happened, more fans would be questioning this quickie romance too.

    Telling rather than showing is a great big writing no-no. Therefore McKeller is the result of some very bad writing. If McKay never announced his LOVE to Keller in that video in The Shrine, I would never have seen anything on screen to support it.

    IMO, the fans had to be told McKay loved Keller..because there was nothing there for them to see.
    Last edited by Showfan; September 24th, 2008 at 10:27 AM.

  12. #12
    Chief Master Sergeant Showfan's Avatar
    Member Since
    May 2008
    Location
    Out west.
    Posts
    146

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Quote Originally Posted by sblade View Post
    That's true. The relationship between McKay and Keller started in one timeline, and leaped to another without explanation. Therefore, I expect the writers to kill Keller just like in the original timeline (The Last Man). Sheppard is half expecting it already.

    Yes, totally. That's exactly what happened.

    Thank god the show ended before we were forced to see the episode next season where Keller becomes ill, McKay emotes and declares his love at her deathbed, Sheppard feels guilty for not telling McKay the love of his life died in the alternate timeline, Carson races against the clock to save Keller's life and Ronon and Teyla...have nothing to do.



  13. #13
    Brigadier General FallenAngelII's Avatar
    Member Since
    Dec 2005
    Location
    Lemming Prophet/Lemming Slasher
    Posts
    8,147

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Quote Originally Posted by Showfan View Post
    Yes, totally. That's exactly what happened.

    Thank god the show ended before we were forced to see the episode next season where Keller becomes ill, McKay emotes and declares his love at her deathbed, Sheppard feels guilty for not telling McKay the love of his life died in the alternate timeline, Carson races against the clock to save Keller's life and Ronon and Teyla...have nothing to do.


    Hush. Don't give them ideas for the movie!

  14. #14
    Major General bluealien's Avatar
    Member Since
    May 2006
    Posts
    14,807

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Quote Originally Posted by Showfan View Post
    Yes, totally. That's exactly what happened.

    Thank god the show ended before we were forced to see the episode next season where Keller becomes ill, McKay emotes and declares his love at her deathbed, Sheppard feels guilty for not telling McKay the love of his life died in the alternate timeline, Carson races against the clock to save Keller's life and Ronon and Teyla...have nothing to do.



  15. #15
    General Linda06's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Scotland, the best Country in the world
    Posts
    26,721

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Quote Originally Posted by Showfan View Post
    Yes, totally. That's exactly what happened.

    Thank god the show ended before we were forced to see the episode next season where Keller becomes ill, McKay emotes and declares his love at her deathbed, Sheppard feels guilty for not telling McKay the love of his life died in the alternate timeline, Carson races against the clock to save Keller's life and Ronon and Teyla...have nothing to do.


    This would be so funny.....If it wasn't so true


  16. #16
    Brigadier General FallenAngelII's Avatar
    Member Since
    Dec 2005
    Location
    Lemming Prophet/Lemming Slasher
    Posts
    8,147

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Quote Originally Posted by Linda06 View Post
    This would be so funny.....If it wasn't so true
    If the movie come even close to being like that, I'm holding Showfan personally responsible. There will be cats!

  17. #17
    Chief Master Sergeant Showfan's Avatar
    Member Since
    May 2008
    Location
    Out west.
    Posts
    146

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Quote Originally Posted by FallenAngelII View Post
    If the movie come even close to being like that, I'm holding Showfan personally responsible. There will be cats!
    Cats! OMG...anything but cats!

    Seriously? I don't put it past them! Keller is pretty much the writer's darling...much to my chagrin. The entire season already revolves around her, why not the movie?


  18. #18
    Second Lieutenant Lucylee's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jun 2008
    Posts
    385

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Quote Originally Posted by Showfan View Post
    Cats! OMG...anything but cats!

    Well, personally, I think Rodney has been shown to have a deeper relationship with his cat than with Keller.

  19. #19
    Chief Master Sergeant
    Member Since
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    236

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    I'm not even convinced that Rodney is capable of any feeling other than egotism. There was absolutely no build up to this relationship. The Seed shows some but it also shows Ronon attacking the ship to save Keller. I picked up on that much more than McKay. I remembered Ronon having a conversation with Keller about who he reminded her of. I saw that on screen and it stuck with me. Having a beer with Mckay was not shown and I've never really seen Keller and McKay interact. The episode where McKay says he loved her was entirely forced and didn't really make much sense other than that SGA has trouble handing carry over from one episode to the next.

  20. #20
    Major General CazzBlade's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 2008
    Location
    I feel like a star.../The Home of Football
    Posts
    11,026

    Default Re: Showing vs. Telling

    Quote Originally Posted by Showfan View Post
    Telling rather than showing is a great big writing no-no. Therefore McKeller is the result of some very bad writing. If McKay never announced his LOVE to Keller in that video in The Shrine, I would never have seen anything on screen to support it.

    IMO, the fans had to be told McKay loved Keller..because there was nothing there for them to see.
    My dad watched The Shrine for the first time the other day and after Rodney's declaration he asked me: "Who's he talking to? "
    What we do in life echoes in eternity - Gladiator vghUp the Blades!
    http://i259.photobucket.com/albums/h...gs/CSI-sig.jpg

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Tags for this Thread

Similar Threads

  1. Upload Us A Video Telling Why You Are The Best Sg-atlantis Fan
    By infanity in forum General Stargate Discussion
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: August 20th, 2007, 03:17 PM
  2. Next Showing?
    By Shishire in forum Stargate SG-1
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: August 26th, 2005, 10:42 PM
  3. Are the Ori Telling the Truth?
    By Liam Kincaid in forum Stargate SG-1
    Replies: 26
    Last Post: August 2nd, 2005, 03:45 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •