Beckett vs. Keller

[Save Carson]

Ok, i want to know which Doc. you all like better? Personally i thought Carson was so much better but thats just my opinion.

[Infinatus]

Season 1 and 2 Becket was just like Keller. In season 3 he got a lot better.

[DrJenniferDex]

I think Keller.

[Ethell]

I don't know why we absolutely have to compare them... I really liked Carson, and I cried during Sunday, but now I really like Keller. I think they're both great characters.

[atlantisk]

I like both... I can't chose, I liked carson when he was still alive, but now i like Keller

[Krissie678]

I don't know why we absolutely have to compare them... I really liked Carson, and I cried during Sunday, but now I really like Keller. I think they're both great characters.

Exactly. Completely agree.

[Yaskaleh]

I really like them both. But as a McKeller and Jewel fan I have to say Keller.

[Blencathra]

Keller

[Jackie]

beckett by far

[M337ING]

Keller. Beckett had some great episodes during Season 3, but his performances during 1 + 2 weren't as... fleshed out as Keller's in Season 4.

[Save Carson]

Like you know in that episode Satida (one of my favorites) where Rodney and Carson are fighting over who get's the machinegun, and goes to save Ronan? Sweet! lovin it

[Vis Uban]

Definitely Beckett. Keller gets more screen time, because TPTB are trying to get everyone to like her since many don't. On the other hand, Beckett became a highly popular character without the writers setting out to make him one.

[Save Carson]

Yep, exactley. Plus she has gained the title of the Whore of Atlantis because she screwed around with Ronan and someone else.

[naamiaiset]

my vote goes to beckett.

[Yaskaleh]

Yep, exactley. Plus she has gained the title of the Whore of Atlantis because she screwed around with Ronan and someone else.

Let's keep it civil in this thread please. Such a comment will only bring anger. I should know you've made me quite pissed off.