Last edited by Darren; April 10th, 2011 at 03:54 PM.
As a first half of a story, this was good. The villans are wonderfully nasty, the precocious lad is obviously going to fall hard sooner or later, Martha is a perfect fit in a way she wasn't quite with Torchwood, and I liked the continuity references with UNIT.
Donna's still doing well, and I loved how she and Martha got on, and also how she brought her 'temp's eye view' into the investigation.
Reasons to like the Doctor more than ever:
1) He saves himself and the UNIT chap with a tennis ball. Okay, it's not quite up there with a cricket ball, but still...
2) He corrects someone's grammar. Please can he be real so I can marry him?
3) He says daps. Not trainers, plimsols or shoes: DAPS. I plan to have his babies.
Right where do I start, it's nice to see Gramps again and that he is the same bloke that was in the paper booth in VotD, not too sure about Donna's mum tho. Also the plot's a little lame, God save us from brainy teenagers, evil clones, UNIT grunts ignoring the Doctor and God save us from Helen Raynor's recycled aliens. IMO it really took it's time to get going, I hope there's more action next week. I did love the fact that Donna can figure something out by common sense rather than clever deductions
I see UNIT are hiring from the shallow end of the gene pool again, honestly those two squaddies deserve everything they get 'I can hear banging from inside an alien box, lets open it' D'OH
Ok so you know that the emission gizmo in your car is made by aliens, it's given off poisonus gases and you know the Sat Nav has a mind of it's own, so what do you do, you get in the car, D'OH
And why didn't Donna or the Doctor break the car's window to let fumes out.
I didn't expect much more from Helen Raynor to be honest but I did expect a more from the Sontaran's and bloody hell I'd forgotten Chris Ryan was that small
I rather liked this episode.
Aside from an outburst of anger at the Unified Intelligence Taskford element, I think UNIT's transition to modern day was fantastic. Particularly when the Doctor drew comparisons to the old style version of UNIT and when he was working with them (which was always supposed to be the not too distant future).
I like the Colonal. Very much so. He's no Brigadier, but he's got character. And dear God YES! He saluted the Doctor! Whoo! Sorry, but I just know that I personally would salute the Doctor and call him sir constantly, so it's nice to see a military bod respond as I would. If I were in UNIT and came across the Doctor he would be treated like the Chief of Defence Staff himself.
Now... Martha. Hmm.
Well she was a tad dramatic in bringing the Doctor back to earth... have you seen how often he's on earth? I'm not sure how her experience would get her fast tracked to a fully qualified doctor either... and lastly, what the hell was SHE doing commanding a military raid of a factory? Maybe the Col was just humouring her but Medical Officers do NOT do that. Furthermore you do NOT say "repeat" over the radio! It's basic military comms protocol. It's "I say again"! Grrrrrrrrrr
The actual UNIT staffing are good and it was nice to see a UN reference.
Sontarans. I really don't remember them being that tiny... oh well. But I did love their characterisation. Except their battle chant... hmm.... not very officerly is it?
Donna and Martha not fighting? Very clever little scene that.
And yes... they should have smashed the window...
"Five Rounds Rapid"
AHHH! My car! It's accelerating and steering towards the river!
Pop the clutch?
Still, it was good. A non-Whovian friend of mine even said he enjoyed it.
The center of Khlysty surrounds me
I knew there was something else I should have said. Did anyone else think that the Sontaran war dance looked more like the All Black's Haka?
I know the grammar fight thing was amazing!! It reminded me of some of my friends.
Why could the Sontarans not take part in the Time War? Didn't the Time Warrior show that they had time travel technology?
I liked it. And the whole Donna "I'm going home"/Doctor panicking/"You just meant you were going to pop by for a visit" exchange was quite funny - and mentioned the Medusa Cascade again.
Knowing only the new series, I enjoyed the militaristic aspect of the Sontarans. It's like someone cloned the ancient Spartans and took away their humanity.
Please to not kill grandpa? That would make me v. sad, I like his character. And I enjoyed the fact that he and the Doctor recognized each other from the Christmas episode.
I enjoyed that one. Pretty solid.
All that talk of the 70s, and no mention of the Brig?
The Doctor was wonderfully silly at the Academy and the Sontaran ship.
"Well, it's just like a thing, innit? People don't question things, they just think 'Err, it's a thing.'" "How did he get in? In-tru-der window?"
And the tennis ball!
Donna was great, as was her Grandad. He'd better live.
Hard to belive the sonic screwdriver couldn't open a car door, though... But they should have just broken the window...
You told Mr W about these plans of yours, Mads?Originally Posted by Madeleine_W
"Five Rounds Rapid"
I mean the ATMOS things are integrated into the vehicles so when they're deadlocked isn't the rest of the car???
That way, people can't get out, people can't get in and the Doctor can't use the sonic screwdriver to get in...
(Just a thought)
Apart from the fact that I am sick and tired and fed up of all military operations and operatives having to have only one brain cell between them, I loved that ep.
Especially the grammar thing. Very good.
In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king
I love that ep, it was very good. I loved the way Martha was reintroduced and the 'no fighting'. But I found myself cringing when she was shouting over the radio, did it look really bulky in her hand?
The Doctor is fantastic in this episode. Especially when he thought Donna was leaving, and another mention of the Medusa Cascade!
But, I think it was a squash ball not a tennis ball that he used to disarm the Sontaran.
http://i16.photobucket.com/albums/b4...sarahsig-1.jpghttp://i16.photobucket.com/albums/b4.../jamessig2.jpgTappity-tap. Tappity-tap.~Proud Member of the Ship Ship Hooray Special Ops Team~
A word of advice... there are creatures that live between this dimension and the next, fiendish creatures that feast on the suffering of an entire world to satiate their eternal hunger. Support the Gateworld Cantina or suffer the fate of all who fall into the clutches of the 'Eladrith Ynneas'
Mmm yes. Shouting into radios... another pet peeve.
RSVP. Rythm, Speed, Volume, Pitch. The first three are meant to be steady and at a normal rate, the latter being slightly higher.
"Five Rounds Rapid"