Independence day vs SGC

[SG66]

another vs thread, i know, but this one i hope will be kinda fun. i was watching the movie Independence day this morning, starring will smith, and i got to thinking, how would the SGC fair against those aliens. any thoughts, or scenarios etc?

[mrbob]

i reckon if they had the deadulas n apollo with asgard beams thay mite win, or a few ori warship

[Detox]

i reckon if they had the deadulas n apollo with asgard beams thay mite win, or a few ori warship

Or they could just use their drones?

[SG66]

with the tech we have post-unending, we would certainly put up a fight.

send the replicators to attack?

[pbutter]

That thing was nothing but an oversized regular Hatak. And all they tried was fire a nuke and a few missiles at it.

[P-51D Mustang]

I think that post uneding the alleins would have gotten the crap kicked out of them. The Oddisey, Apollo and Daedulus would have taken out thoes ships. And if that didnt work the drones need a good work out.

[SG66]

be an interesting way to reveal the stargate program

[wise one]

earth could always say that a spy gruop has learned that the aliens are here to pick up something that resembles a metal ring and that they kill humans and earth all of sudden found it and knows how to use hidden technology found in this place

[Ripple in Space]

be an interesting way to reveal the stargate program

What reveal? It was on Independence Day, the government could just say it was an Air/Fireworks Show

[jhkplaya888]

What reveal? It was on Independence Day, the government could just say it was an Air/Fireworks Show

i go for the giant balloon that looks like a alien ship idea

[pbutter]

I was right all along. According to this thread, Independence Day was orignally titled StarGate 3.
http://forum.gateworld.net/showthread.php?t=24261

So i was right about the Hatak connection, man, i get tired of being right all the time.

[JSPuddlejumper]

Those ships 10km, Hives=11km.

3 hit Asgard beams = destroyed Hives.

the 304's would own those sucka's. just needs sufficient 304s. asgard beams would shred them. only weapon we saw on the motherships were good for planetary targets.

600km ship orbiting earth? no shields on the *****a. all over. mark 9s.

[SG66]

it certainly seems that the favor is in the hands of the SGC

[Mister Oragahn]

another vs thread, i know, but this one i hope will be kinda fun. i was watching the movie Independence day this morning, starring will smith, and i got to thinking, how would the SGC fair against those aliens. any thoughts, or scenarios etc?

Scenario is that we don't even need to wait for the 4th of july to win.

[Chicagods]

Ok, I cant verify that the city attack ships were 10 km across but even if so they are circular. That is a hell of alot of mass. Not to mention the size of the mothership or the amount of fighters which both carried en-mass those fighters seem like they'd wipe the floor with our 302s.
I am a SG1 fan and a SGA fan but this earth pwns everything crap has to stop. SERIOUSLY.