'Reunion' (403) General Discussion

[jelgate]

I would disagree. Atlantis Sam is definatly different then SG1 Sam. At the same time she is suppose to be. She is not the astrophysict of the team anymore. She is the command leader. Sure she could do the science stuff that Rodney does but she has bigger administration responsibilities when McKay is more than capable of doing the science stuff. I was most interested in the Sam stuff in watching her adjust to life as a leader and dealing with the command stuff she sometimes put Hammond and Landry through. It was an interesting transition. I on the other hand was not interested in the Ronon story. I have seen the story of the alien want to leave Earth so many times with Teal'c it was boring. But once captured on the Wraith ship I thought it got better. Not only seeing the Satedians betray Ronon but see the Wraith's respons to reprogramming the Asurans. The anger they feel is quite humorous. But what got more then anything was see Ronon's face when his friends when they became traitors. It was a sight to see his fury when he battled them. Makes me really hate The Broken Ties as it kind of cheapens this episode

[Jae'a]

My LiveJournal post
Not a very happy reunion in the end. Poor Ronon.

[Nikki Alexander]

So I've nearly finished this episode, just at the bit near the end where Teyla gives him back his painting and it got me thinking, where did Ronan get that painting from. I mean he was on the run from the Wraith from his homeworld, and unless he returned after he'd had that chip removed and wasn't on the run from the Wraith, I'm thinking it probably didn't come from there, so I wonder where it came from, do you think someone gave it to him or maybe painted it for him or something.

I quite liked this episode, not my favorite granted, that goes to Dopleganger, but I do like Sam in it and I love Sam as leader of Atlantis, I wish she could've stayed on throughout S5. I think the episode would have been better with Lorne in it HAHA, just because I love seeing Lorne. But yeah, I didn't mind this episode too much, liked the bit with Sam and Rodney in her quarters and the awkwardness of it.

[Falcon Horus]

I believe it is mentioned that Lorne painted it for him.

[garhkal]

Would make sense, since we did see Lorne painting in "sunday".

[Cluas]

Sam is a better leader than McKay, no doubt, but is she really better than Weir? I guess I still miss Torri a lot.

It was good to see Teal'c (and Sam), but this ep was average.
Didn't like Ronon in this ep.

How did McKay get into that wraith-hibernation thingy? We saw earlier, how tough they were to break ... Well maybe it's easier from the outside? It just didn't seem to fit...

Looking forward to the next ep. 'cos it will probably be Ronan-free

[Baron Of Hell]

I liked this episode. Think the best part for me was the one on three fight between Ronin and his people. The idea of the wraith fighting the replicators was a good one. I like Sam as a character but would have rather seen someone from SGA put in charge of things. I would have liked seeing Sam in command of SG1 back on that show.

[garhkal]

Whom else would you have liked in charge?

[Baron Of Hell]

Shep or Mckay and moving Lorn to a regular.

[mrscopterdoc]

Sam is a better leader than McKay, no doubt, but is she really better than Weir? I guess I still miss Torri a lot.

I agree.