Last edited by GateWorld; April 19th, 2014 at 07:31 PM.
Bye, bye Kate we hardly knew you. *sad*
I did like the episode though. I have sneaky suspicion these leaked episodes are all very planned moves.
I am not an expert though.
Remember that "Doppelganger" carried a production number of 401, since it was shot first. It's not a leap to think that someone at MGM sent over the wrong file because it was tagged by number and not by title.
That's a good point, Darren and probably the explanation. I hadn't remembered that about the shooting order.
Either way, this was a fantastic episode. Killing Heightmeyer off was, well, whatever. Did it have to be her, no, but it did add a little more depth since Teyla has relied on her before a few times and maybe that was the point more than anything.
The dialogue was witty, the fight scene was really fantastic. I loved Evil!Shep, Joe F did a marvelous job portraying a sociopath. I sure believed it!
For as much footage of this episode was used in promo vids, the plot surprised me. It didn't unravel quite like I had expected and that was kind of cool. Instead of it actually basing itself in Sheppard like I had figured, it was going from one person to the next. Interesting.
I really enjoyed the episode as well.... Unfortunately, I was attempting to download Adrift from iTunes and was really looking forward to seeing the season premier. I guess I should explain, I don't have a television because of my kids so I rely on either Unbox or iTunes to watch Atlantis. Well Unbox doesn't have it and iTunes got it wrong....
But on a side note. Doppelganger was a great episode! I love the clown in the boat. That was hilarious! Especially if you remember last season J Sheppard talking about how much he hated them.
I see TPTB are still dusting off old SG1 scripts. Sad. Really sad.
Oh yes, let's kill off another well-liked character. *shakes head*
Its Cold Lazarus from SG1. They just tweaked it a bit for the Atlantis characters, but its clearly based on the old CL script.
Thumbs down for lack of imagination, but I guess those who didn't watch SG1 will probably enjoy it.
Hmm. Doppelganger. I don't get SciFi, so I have to rely on iTunes or Unbox to see the show. I set out to get Adrift, but ended up with Doppelganger.
Overall, not a bad episode. I wish I'd made some notes while watching, but here's my impression.
Death of Kate. I have mixed emotions on this one. It made more impact than the death of a guest character would have, and I'd rather lose Kate than Zelenka or Lorne. But...we've had quite a few losses lately. It just...I'm tired of losing people. This isn't Heroes.
The obvious (and awkward IMO) pushing of the J/T ship. I'm keeping in mind this was filmed before TPTB knew that Rachel was pregnant (although there was one shot she almost looked like she was showing a little bit), so....I have a feeling they derailed this later on down the road. But...for a nonshipper like myself, it was cringeworthy, and rather felt like I was getting hit over the head. The hug in particular was quite forced, and felt out of place.
Carter-mixed here also. She's still really stiff in her dialogue, and I was hoping she'd lose a little of that. There was also far too much of the "When I was on SG-1" thrown in....remember Mitchell and him constantly bringing up reading SG-1's mission reports? But she did have a few good moments - there was a good moment with Keller after she announced the death of Dr Heightmeyer.
I like Keller! I really do! I'm surprised that I like her so much. Yeah, she's too young for the job, but if I don't let myself think about that part of it, she's really an enjoyable character.
The dream sequences were good(mostly). Teyla's fear of the bug!Sheppard was understandable, after the way Shep attacked her in S2, although I could have really done without Ronon's "I always knew you guys would hook up." Thud! Another hit over the head-way to be subtle. Ronon's fear of being buried alive? Where did that come from? It would have been nice if we'd known why Ronon has a fear of that. Keller's dream was the best I think. Lorne was good in his sleepwalking. And very thunkworthy. I think they could have done more with the dream sequences - for all the buildup for this ep, it wasn't near as big a deal as I thought it was going to be, and they weren't near as dark as I was expecting. I liked what they did - I guess I just wanted more of it, darker dreams, more dreams per person. I think it would have been better if they'd all kept having the dreams, instead of one dream per person. That kind of took down the creepy element I think.
Some great Sheppard/McKay friendship moments. Shep going into Rodney's dream to save him, and then Rodney doing the same for him. That whole last part was great. The evil!Shep tearing down Rodney, and the real Shep encouraging him. And Shep's stunned devastation when he thought Rodney was dead, and everyone condeming him for it. And lots of Shep whump - the evil!Shep really beat Shep up good. I could hear the whumpers screaming in my ear.
So....overall pretty good. Not awesome great, but pretty good.
Killdeer, yeah I felt like I was getting hit over the head with J/T too. It was way too much for a show that never commits to ships.
I really like Keller too but I am so bitter about Carson that I just cannot like her too much. She's fun though.
So, Heightmeyer joins the Dead Doctors Club. Who's next? My money is on Zelenka.
Coop really needs to stay away from Atlantis. Referencing one SG-1 episode is bad, but three? Just sad. At least it wasn't McKay remembering old SG-1 mission reports. I guess referencing old SG-1 missions is okay because Carter experienced them.
but who knows after that?Spoiler:
Ah, this maybe then where the Rodney dies rumours came from?Originally Posted by Killdeer
Hmm, so the stuff in the rowboat? Is that from DG? What happened there? *inquiring minds want to know* Also I am just nosey.
Here's what happens. They have the entity trapped in Rodney. But they have to get it out of him so it doesn't kill him. So Shep gets hooked up to this device and goes into Rodney's dream. In Rodney's dream, he's trapped in a rowboat out on the ocean in a storm, and he's trying to get to Atlantis. The evil Shep is in the front of the boat, taunting him, telling him what a loser he is, that he may as well give up. There's also a whale circling the boat. Then the real Shep appears in the back of the boat, and starts telling Rodney not to listen, that it's not real, to not give up. He's helping Rodney row, and tells him "This isn't as bad as I thought it would be." Then they both turn around and see a clown in the back of the boat.
The evil!Shep tells them they can't win, and you see an overhead shot of a huge whale mouth coming up and eating the boat. Shep jerks awake, and sees Rodney flatlining and Keller trying to revive him, to no avail. The next shot is Shep staggering stunned down the hallway. Everyone comes up to blame him for Rodney's death, and tell him what a horrible friend he is, and how he let Rodney down. Carter tells him he's relieved of duty. Then he sees the evil!Shep and attacks him, and they have a very cool fight. Just as he's losing, Rodney comes back into his dream and tells him he's not dead. The evil!Shep attacks him, but gets hit with an electrical current, and the real Shep throws him through the Stargate. Then they both wake up.
Anyone have a idea on if or when they might fix the episode / problem.
Aw, this makes me happy in so many wrong *g* and good ways!The evil!Shep tells them they can't win, and you see an overhead shot of a huge whale mouth coming up and eating the boat. Shep jerks awake, and sees Rodney flatlining and Keller trying to revive him, to no avail. The next shot is Shep staggering stunned down the hallway. Everyone comes up to blame him for Rodney's death, and tell him what a horrible friend he is, and how he let Rodney down. Carter tells him he's relieved of duty. Then he sees the evil!Shep and attacks him, and they have a very cool fight. Just as he's losing, Rodney comes back into his dream and tells him he's not dead. The evil!Shep attacks him, but gets hit with an electrical current, and the real Shep throws him through the Stargate. Then they both wake up.
I was just thinking about why we don't see anymore Heightmeyer. She is one of my favorite characters because she seems so "real", compared to getting lost the character realm of stargate. And to read she dies, ruins my Saturday night, which was already ruined by boring friends... But this just makes things worse.
On a side note, I never heard the term doppelganger used before. But once the title of this episode was released, I hear it all over the place. I am still waiting to use it in a real world conversation.