Ancients or Asgard

[.jolinar.]

As we all know the Ancients were one of, if not the most advanced races in the universe. And we all know that after the Lantians retreated to Earth from Atlantis they didnt advance any further. Also we know that after that this the Asgard race which was already very advanced had ten thousand years to advance further. So which to date is the most advanced?

- Im positive that Ancient sheilds are more powerful than the Asgard sheilds from battles with Wraith hive ships.
- I know that the Ancient Drone weapons are more advanced than any Asgard weapons.
- The Asgard beam tech is much more efficient than Ancient ring transports.
- Also when the Orion and the Daedalus jumped into hyperspace to intercept the Wraith hive ships headed to Earth the Daedalus jumped a second or two before the Orion but the Daedalus arrived considerably sooner then the Orion, I know that the Orion wasnt working as efficient as it could have but it is still possible that the Asgard hyperdrive is more effective than the Ancient hyperdrive.

So what are your opinions and evidence?

[Buba uognarf]

- Im positive that Ancient sheilds are more powerful than the Asgard sheilds from battles with Wraith hive ships.
- I know that the Ancient Drone weapons are more advanced than any Asgard weapons.
- The Asgard beam tech is much more efficient than Ancient ring transports.
- Also when the Orion and the Daedalus jumped into hyperspace to intercept the Wraith hive ships headded to Earth the Daedalus jumped a second or two before the Orion but the Daedalus arrived considerably sooner then the Orion, I know that the Orion wasnt working as efficient as it could have but it is still possible that the Asgard hyperdrive is more effective than the Ancient hyperdrive.

So what are your opinions and evidence?

-i agree, atlantis's shields are deffinately stronger than anything the asgard could build IMO
-Drones are different, but in general after looking at the Satelite and the Triniy weapon i'd say ancients
-Asgard have more practical beaming tech
-The deadalus hyperdrive is inta galactic, the Orions is not so it's unfair to compare them...
-Asard holograms seem atleast as good as ancient ones maybe more advanced

In general i think ancients are more advanced and have researched into areas the Asgard probably have hardely touched due to time...though those little rey guys do seem to have the edge in some respects

[ur uncle urgo]

even the asgard say that they are young compared to the ancients remember when they got the repoatory from jacks head they said they barly scratched the sureface.

[VSHARMA]

I'm positive that Ancient sheilds are more powerful than the Asgard sheilds from battles with Wraith hive ships.

You talking about City Ship shields or Aurora Class shields here??????
If you’re talking about City Ship shields, they are more powerful than Asgard shields with help from the ZPM.
If you’re talking about Aurora Class shields, we haven't seen an Ancient Battle Ship Vs Hive Ship one on one. The little battle in 'No Mans Land' didn't count as shields were taken off line to fire drones so we have no idea how long an Ancient Ship could take Hive Weapons. So I wouldn't be that 'Positive' that Ancient shields are more powerful than Asgard shields (without ZPM.)

[.jolinar.]

-Drones are different, but in general after looking at the Satelite and the Triniy weapon i'd say ancients

I didnt think of the Satalite or the trinity cannon

-The deadalus hyperdrive is inta galactic, the Orions is not so it's unfair to compare them...

I didnt know about that

-Asard holograms seem atleast as good as ancient ones maybe more advanced

I didnt consider this but I would say that they are both equal.

[ACharmedAsgard]

As much as I love the Asgard, The Ancients were more advanced then the Asgard. This is probably due to the fact that the Ancients are far far older then the Asgard and had alot more time to develop.

The Asgard beam is more advanced as it needs to be due to the Asgard being alot frailer physically then the ancients were.

[wilson359]

From what i've observed when the treasure appears in the episodes Avalon & Camelot, Asgard beaming technology my be infact Ancient technology.

Plus Thor once said that they got their hands on part of the Ancient repository of knowledge & were able to understand & adapt a small percentage of it. That may have included the beming technology

[mlund05]

From what i've observed when the treasure appears in the episodes Avalon & Camelot, Asgard beaming technology my be infact Ancient technology.

Plus Thor once said that they got their hands on part of the Ancient repository of knowledge & were able to understand & adapt a small percentage of it. That may have included the beming technology

Thats something i never considered, but it may be possible. Maybe they got those holograms things that same way.

[VSHARMA]

Every species in the StarGate network is different. Each species is more advance in its own way.

I could say the Mimic aliens are the most advance aliens because of they mimic device. I have not seen any species of the Great Alliance of 4 ever use technology like this.
Or even the Tollen, they had Ion cannon which could destroy a Ha’tak in a single shot, (like the Ori) Phase-shifting technology, had a Symbiotie silencer device and even reverse-engineered a Stargate with (help from the NOX)
The Asgard or Ancients have never had a Symbiote Silencer, Phase Shifting Tech and the Asgard could never destroy a Ha’tak with a single shot.

[wise one]

Every species in the StarGate network is different. Each species is more advance in its own way.

I could say the Mimic aliens are the most advance aliens because of they mimic device. I have not seen any species of the Great Alliance of 4 ever use technology like this.
Or even the Tollen, they had Ion cannon which could destroy a Ha’tak in a single shot, (like the Ori) Phase-shifting technology, had a Symbiotie silencer device and even reverse-engineered a Stargate with (help from the NOX)
The Asgard or Ancients have never had a Symbiote Silencer, Phase Shifting Tech and the Asgard could never destroy a Ha’tak with a single shot.

well im pretty sure if the ancients were around then they could biuld anything,
the ancients never biult a symbiote silencer because they never encounted the gould when they came back from pegasus, they ascended shorlty after.
the ancients do have some phrase ****fing tech like merlins phrase shifting device in arthurs mantle or the sodans cloak

and i belive the asgard can destroy a gouald ship with one shot, most likey a oniel anyway, i think the only time the asgard couldnt destoy one was because anubis upgraded his tech from ancient knowledge

[Raj_2006]

i believe all the asgard technology is dervived from the Ancients. Tht maybe explains y we see the Asgard showing beam tech and hyperdrives which r faster because there is no point in showing it again. Plus the Ancients were explores and could live for a very long time. So tht might explain y they don't use faster hyperdrives.

[kefke20]

we have only see the agard tech on the tau`ri ships to go agenst the wraiht
and we know that we have power problems to jus the tech to its max

we dont know how a oniell or a bestelix class wold do agenst a hive ship
probely a no game at all for the asgard.

and we also dont know wat is the power sors of the asgard

so for wapons and shild we have no base line to comper dem
we have only seen that asgard are supriorer to the gaùold and the ancient drons on mass can wipe out a gaòuld fleet.

but we know that all asgard ships have intersteller drive wat can raets incradebul speeds
not all ancient ships have intersteller drive and if they do you can comper dum wiht a 304 (see no man land)

and we know that hologram tech of the asgad are beter the ancents have no to way hologram tech (see the return)

and the asgart have beam tech, we have only see the ancient gave transport rings (jet), it can be that the asgart have prefectet the tech

[wise one]

well i think a asgard ship like a oniel or a beliskner can do alot of damage to a wraith hive ships like if you watch trinty from atlantis that weapon can inflict alot of damage when sheppard was flying away from the planet and would similar to a asgard weapon


plus the beliskner has tranporter ray beam on it similar to the wraith which most likey got it from the ancients.

the asgard ship just beam all the darts away and some of the hull of a hive and the whole ship would decompress

[IWKYZerocool]

Every species in the StarGate network is different. Each species is more advance in its own way.

I could say the Mimic aliens are the most advance aliens because of they mimic device. I have not seen any species of the Great Alliance of 4 ever use technology like this.
Or even the Tollen, they had Ion cannon which could destroy a Ha’tak in a single shot, (like the Ori) Phase-shifting technology, had a Symbiotie silencer device and even reverse-engineered a Stargate with (help from the NOX)
The Asgard or Ancients have never had a Symbiote Silencer, Phase Shifting Tech and the Asgard could never destroy a Ha’tak with a single shot.

Acutally in the epsiode 'Its Good to Be King'

Spoiler:

O'Neill flies the Puddle Jumper and 1 hit from the drone, destroyed the Haktak

So The Ancients are powerful.

[kirmit]

Acutally in the epsiode 'Its Good to Be King'

Spoiler:

O'Neill flies the Puddle Jumper and 1 hit from the drone, destroyed the Haktak

So The Ancients are powerful.

It was 2 drones and they said they must've hit critical systems, that's the only reason they destroyed a ha'tak in 2 shots.