Favorite Season 3 Eps First Half Season

[Pharaoh Atem]

No mans land

misforgotten

irressstbale

Seteda

Progeny

The real world

Common ground

McKay and Mrs Miller

Phatoms

the return pt 1

[Elinor]

The first half of s3 has been SO good that all the episodes range from very good to excellent!

Common Ground, Sateda, Phantoms, and The Return pt 1 stand out for me though...in that order!

Common Ground was an amazing and outstanding episode...Joe Flanigan was fantastic....and I'm really looking forward to more from writer Ken Cuperus!!

[Descent]

Season 3 has been outstanding so far, its hard to choose.

My favorite has been Sateda, followed closely by Common Ground and The Return.

[Dr McKay]

i liked them all but i was very impressed with Progeny, The city and the gate room was spectacular. I also loved The Return part 1! its a cruel cliffhanger!

[Night Marshal]

Common Ground, MCKAY AND MRS. MILLER, and NO MAN'S LAND were the only ep worth watching. So far as bad ones go Seteda, THE REAL WORLD, PROGENY, and PHANTOMS were so bad I stoped watching half way through. The rest were so so not so bad I turned them off, but not good enough to watch them again. I know this is a stargate forum and I enjoy stargate but Atlantis really seem to be losing its spark and my wife who a bigger atlantis fan than I has told me can stop watching it because it just a waste her time. And I have to agree. I mean I will never understand why people geek out so hard for Setda when the Super Wraith only has one speaking line and Grows the rest of the time. Atlantis has already been renewed for another year but I really can't see it airing much past that.

[The Sweet Guy]

Common Ground, McKay and Mrs. Miller, Sateda, and No Man's Land are up there as favorites of the show. The Return, Phantoms, and Progeny were also pretty good. I didn't like parts of Misbegotten, but Michael redeems it. Irresistible and The Real World are my least favorites, but they weren't horrible.

[MasterPower]

I forgot what it was called, but my favorite first half episode was when Sheppard was captured by the Genii and the Wraith kept feeding off of him.

[Descent]

Basically this is how I'd list them:
1. Sateda
2. Common Ground
3. Mckay and Mrs. Miller
4. The Return
5. No Man's Land
6. Progeny
7. Phantoms
8. The Real World
9. Misbegotten
10. Irresistable

[Descent]

I mean I will never understand why people geek out so hard for Setda when the Super Wraith only has one speaking line and Grows the rest of the time. Atlantis has already been renewed for another year but I really can't see it airing much past that.

Were not geeking out over anything here. Sorry we enjoyed the episode and have been enjoying this wonderful season and you haven't.

[Dr McKay]

I forgot what it was called, but my favorite first half episode was when Sheppard was captured by the Genii and the Wraith kept feeding off of him.

The one you are looking for is Common Ground, that also was a great episode

-The gift of life is reserved only for our most devout worshippers ... and our brothers.

- Well, I guess there's a lot about the Wraith we don't know.

[Xeon_1]

it had its good episodes and it bad episoed like irresitable
overal i am likeing season10 of SG1 more

[sueKay]

Mods - McKay and Mrs. Miller's not on the poll!

[Descent]

it had its good episodes and it bad episoed like irresitable
overal i am likeing season10 of SG1 more

Wish I could say the same but I'd gladly take Irresistable over Memento Mori or Uninvited any day of the week.

[Vespasianus]

It was really hard for me to choose between Common Ground and The Return I. Season 3 is the best season so far and much better with than the fantasy-like season 1 of SG-1.

1. The Return I. (best team moments ever)
2. Common Ground (acting chemistry between Wraith soldier and Sheppard)
3. Progeny (Oberoth, Niam - great actors as great villains)
4. The Real World (great acting by Torri)
5. No Man's Land (very good season opener with Michael)
6. McKay and Mrs. Miller (Jeannie and Rodney, great music)
7. Phantoms (a bit tired story for me)
8. Misbegotten (human-Wraith in pyjamas, but it wasn't bad)
9. Sateda (too much slow-motion, only the team moments were good)
10. Irresistible (I didn't find this funny)

[NowIWillDestroyAbydos]

Sateda was my favorite episode so far. It has a lot of action and (spoiler: Sateda)

Spoiler:

Rodney got shot in the ass