That's a true story and no urban myth. They talked about it on some behind-the-scenes thing on one of the LOTR DVDs, but with the billions of featurettes on those DVDs I can't remember which one it was.Originally Posted by Major Fischer
I thought so But the point being, just because we can help someone behind us, doesn't nessecarily mean we can solve the problem instantly. Especially given that I haven't seen much evidence that the Atlantis team has access to the city's computers. If the city has computers.
After watching "Affinity," I found this episode to be such a relief. Not much action, but a good episode that dealt with ethics and morality. Is it just me, or does it seem that ethics and morality were checked at the door (or, rather the gate) when the SGA crew stepped foot on Atlantis? Thus far, some of the SGA crew seems quite willing to cast aside ethics if it benefits Atlantis. I loved Beckett in this episode, and I also think Weir and Teyla are beginning to find their niche. My only problem is when will we see Ford shine? Oh well, maybe in a future episode. But Steve? Absolutely hilarious.
Shep: I don't even know your name.
Wraith: I am your death.
Shep: I think I prefer Steve.
*sniff* Please do not remind me of Steve, I am still in mourning.
Teyla still annoys me. I say take her and bring Steve back, then Steve could become REALLY like Teal'c. Ya know, and old "bad guy" helping out the "good guys" But I don't think that Steve would have given up his awesome leather jacket for the regular old Atlantis civillian gear. I still like Weir better, although I think she's still kinda shifting from side to side a little.
Why yes, I am aware that I am too sexy for my catRIP Stargate SG-1: The iris may be closed, but the gate will always be spinning, lighting the chevrons in my heart
And to the Sci Fi Channel...
It was very interesting to me to see how Sheppard's perception of the Wraith seemed to shift just a little as soon as he named him. One of you mentioned something about naming animals in testing labs... so true. We give something a human quality - even just a name - and begin to attribute other human qualities to it as well. Sheppard was actually concerned about him when he was dying.
Someone else asked about the metal things on the wraiths hands... I think they administer the chemical that allows them to drain life forces, kind of like a fingertip hypodermic.
Ummm... what else? Oh yeah, it was mentioned that 96% support seemed unrealistic and WWII mentioned as an example. Problem is that example doesn't really fit. In WWII the average American didn't really feel the threat of Hitler - it was on the other side of the world, what did we have to worry about? So we were slow to care about another culture being wiped from the face of the planet. Once America was directly attacked, we were in it 100%. Not too difficult to believe nearly 100% of Hoffans would want the drug as it the Wraith directly affected *them* not some distant group of people.
I think the Hoffans were stupid not to give more consideration to Wraith retaliation once the Wraith discovered the effects of the drug. Sheppard's probably right - they won't exist after the Wraith find out the human's have discovered weakness.
I did not like the fact that Parna was killed off. I think it would have been an interesting dilemma for Beckett to be attracted to someone whose values are so completely opposite of his and see how he coped with that. It would also put a dent in his fear of gate travel. BTW - this is the 2nd Star Trek reference directly involving Beckett. Think he's a fan?
Overall I haven't seen a character I don't like in Atlantis, except Bates. Interesting to note that Bates always seems to have a scowl on his face and tries to look menacing... seems to come off as constipated, though. Teyla is a bit dramatic, but her character is around I think to act as a guide to worlds the Athosians have traded with in the past. I've like Weir and Ford from the beginning and McKay is one of my favorites.
Raised a few more questions than answered though... they tried other life forms to feed Steve, but what and where did they get them? And did it not work because it wasn't human, or because Steve wasn't hungry enough yet to break down and feed on something non-human? It would certainly knock some of the wind out of the Wraith if it was discovered they could feed on other forms but chose humans because they were more satisfying and Steve would most likely attempt to protect that image. Or it could just be late and I'm off on a weird tangent.
Oh yeah, someone else asked how Steve died... not sure if it's a "spoiler" so better safe than yelled at...Spoiler:
Last edited by Cydonia; August 21st, 2004 at 09:17 PM. Reason: one more thing...
The city has computers. We brought them with us! Remember the Dells with the nice Atlantis stickers? Oh yeah, now that's the technology of the Ancients.Originally Posted by Major Fischer
Yep. It wasOriginally Posted by TechnoBoY
True, from OUR perspective. When WE think of getting the WHOLE CIVILIZATION to vote, we are talking about 5-6 billing people. They never mentioned HOW MANY total people voted or how large their population had grown since the last culling.Originally Posted by Bobthespirit
If they had only been around for say 100 years, it is doubtful they had grown beyond the size of a large city. Plus, the vote didn't take very long to execute which supports the fact that there weren't many of them to survey.
Also, as another member said. Their whole society built on and was devoted to the successful development and execution of this serum. They were very committed.
This might just be my favorite episode after Rising. Good to see Beckett take center stage and get out of the infirmary. (Although, he ends up in another one, but still...)
Loved all the scenes with Sheppard and Steve the Wraith (who has already reached legendary status, it would seem). "I am your death, that is all you need to know." ... "I prefer Steve." Too funny. I don't really get all the comparisons to O'Neill though, regarding Sheppard. Sure, he's witty and sarcastic, but I think Flanigan has put a whole other spin on the character and I have not once found myself thinking that RDA would say it this way or that way.
Really liked the fact that there was no happy ending and that it was all left sort of 'out in the open'. I'm thinking they´re gonna revisit this plot again, some day.
One question about Sheppard's last line of the episode: What was it?
Beckett: Victory at all cost. That sound familiar, major?
Beckett: Aye. Never thought I'd disagree.
I've rewatched that part a bunch of times, but I can't decipher his line! Help, anyone?
I think it was Churchill. I had a difficult time making it out myself, but I'm pretty sure that's it.Originally Posted by Ugly Pig
It's definitely "Churchill". Notice how Beckett, a citizen of the United Kingdom, says how he never imagined ever disagreeing with it (with its WWII/Earth implications)...
We suspend our disbelief, and we are entertained...
Do we or do we not have a REALLY effective anti-Wraith weapon? And how effective is it? And in what scenarios would it be best used?
Might be an alternative to cyanide pills. Sounds like it's a more painful way to go, but not as bad as being Wraith food.
As it is currently constituted, and for the Atlantis team, the only way that it could be used ethically would be as a 'last ditch' thing. If you KNOW that you are going to be captured by the Wraith, you take it, and pray that the way they chose to kill you when they find out what's in your system is faster than what the feeding might do, or what the drug might do.Originally Posted by gwangung
Now, there's a good idea!Originally Posted by Livi2Jack
Does that mean she'll get squished?Originally Posted by TheHomegaMan
One cliche, from both SG-1 and Atlantis, that I begin to hate is that any culture not "primative" seems to be Victorian.
And after "Childhood's End"
it seemed odd that they were so adamant that the Hoffan government respect our values. I saw their point of view, but I also saw the Hoffans'.
Last point: Dr. Weir had a Terra Cotta Soldier miniature and South American native-looking pot in her office. Personal items or was there an Interior Decorating Alowance in the mission planing?
Develop a gaseous/powered version of the serum, put it in a delivery system, and when they find hive ships, feed it through the venting system. It looked kinda red, so we can call it red dust. Oh wait, we did that in V. So glad the full series is out on dvd now but that's off topic.
However, I'm curious if they would have explored the possibility of salt-water types of attacks for effectiveness against wraith since it had some effectiveness on the bug on Shepherd's neck that seemed to be a distant relative. Sure, might be hard to capture wraith, but it might be easier to collect a bunch of those slug things and work on those for a while as well. Just a thought.
Overall, I found the episode decent, ethics and morality, etc. I'm kinda bothered that the ancients never found a way to counter the wraith life sucking with their advanced biotech. Watch out, I'll predict that in season 5 of SGA, we'll find sneezing on wraith is the miracle weapon, and they'll stop bothering us when someone gets SARS.
Could be. Could have been that they are part of a representation of traditional earth cultures, which is my guess, but i don't think we'll know.Originally Posted by Summerfield
Gifts from a lovestruck Daniel who smuggled them into the team's supplies.
Or maybe they're actually Ancient trinkets.