This is a neutral ground for all shippers to discuss in honest and friendly terms their ships. I'm doing this because of the recent numbers of Shep/Weir shippers poking into our thread, and the number of Shepmagen shippers doing the same to the Shep/Weir thread. This is a place for all those discussions and more.. Rule number one of this thread is to RESPECT ALL SHIPPERS! We are all similar, we just see things differently. Rember that, and we'll have a great time discussing this.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Sheppard/Teyla Ship and Sheppard/Weir Ship Discussion Thread
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
Sheppard/Teyla Ship and Sheppard/Weir Ship Discussion Thread
Last edited by Cpt. Ritter; 04 January 2006, 05:36 PM.Tags: None
-
Originally posted by Cpt. RitterThis is a neutral ground for Shep/Teyla shippers and Shep/Weir shippers to discuss in honest and friendly terms their two ships. Rule number one of this thread is to RESPECT ALL SHIPPERS! We are all similar, we just see things differently. Rember that, and we'll have a great time discussing this.
I think we should also all agree that people coming in to cause trouble and saying things like "Weir is a ho", should be kicked to the curb immediately. Because I'm sure that is not what you intended...
Comment
-
If we can handle this thread really neutraly, than it's great.
I'm a sparky too. At the beginning of the show I knew that TPTB planned on heading to Sheyla, but to be very honest, in the 1st season I didn't really like Teyla. That changed drastically this season, and now when I rewatch the 1st season I even see some good moments between John and Teyla, but I'm still not sooo sure that it's more than Brother/sister-like.
I think at the moment between John and Liz it's also the friendship what is much more important than anything else, and that's, what TPTB really try to explore at the moment I think!
Generally IMO if it either one of these two ships, they shouldn't get really together until the last 1-10 episodes of the show, otherwise it would ruin it
Comment
-
its a good idea... that way we can all talk as fellow shippers without bitin' each other's heads off, yes we all have our opinions... i ship shep/teyla, but who knows that could change, i like the friendship between shep/weir... (yes they do have good scenes together in S2.. who knows in time it may grow to more... but let it happen at its own pace and i may start to ship shep/weir)sigpic
Comment
-
Originally posted by astronomicalchickWith all respect Ritter, and heaven knows you know I'm all for shippers from all persausions talking to each other and I bounce in and out of shipper threads frequently (actually I like doing that), but I'm wondering if the thread title is a little inflammatory and we might get folks looking for trouble wandering in? Perahps just Sheppard/Teyla and Sheppard/Weir thread? Or the Sheppard/Teyla and Sheppard/Weir playground?
And once again, my ship sails by under the radar.
Comment
-
Originally posted by DorkaIf we can handle this thread really neutraly, than it's great.
I'm a sparky too. At the beginning of the show I knew that TPTB planned on heading to Sheyla, but to be very honest, in the 1st season I didn't really like Teyla. That changed drastically this season, and now when I rewatch the 1st season I even see some good moments between John and Teyla, but I'm still not sooo sure that it's more than Brother/sister-like.
I think at the moment between John and Liz it's also the friendship what is much more important than anything else, and that's, what TPTB really try to explore at the moment I think!
Generally IMO if it either one of these two ships, they shouldn't get really together until the last 1-10 episodes of the show, otherwise it would ruin it
I didn't hate the character but she wasn't my favorite so when Weir was to be part of Atlantis I just kinda shrugged my shoulders and was like okay...
So during 'The Rising' I really got into Teyla's character and the ship involved with her..I tend to ship more with the character of Teyla which is why I do visit the Ronon/Teyla thread and the now the Carson/Teyla thread...
Since watching Atlantis I can now say I love Weir played by TH ...female leadership is always good in my opinion but I was already a Shepmagan, Shep/Teyla fan and don't switch sides easily. I'm set in my ways and see ship for these two...
I also now start to see McWeir because of a friend I met here...Caz has me seeing moments for these two...and my brother has me seeing Caldwell/Weir!
I also now look for Shep/Weir moments but to me they always mean friendship first...I can't help it I'm bias towards Shepmagan prettiness!
But I did like the hug between them...it was so glad you're not dead
I think I need to come out with a siggy that says proud Multi-shipper!
Comment
-
Originally posted by ToasterOnFireI agree with astro - perhaps the thread should be changed to remove the "versus"? Other than that this thread is a great idea as long as everyone plays nice.
And once again, my ship sails by under the radar.
Comment
-
Originally posted by AthosianGirlI liked Teyla from the start...favorite character...it was actually Weir who I was nuetral on during 'The Rising' because of my previous opinions of the character I made from SG:1...she came in and good-bye Hammond! Noooo!
I didn't hate the character but she wasn't my favorite so when Weir was to be part of Atlantis I just kinda shrugged my shoulders and was like okay...
So during 'The Rising' I really got into Teyla's character and the ship involved with her..I tend to ship more with the character of Teyla which is why I do visit the Ronon/Teyla thread and the now the Carson/Teyla thread...
Since watching Atlantis I can now say I love Weir played by TH ...female leadership is always good in my opinion but I was already a Shepmagan, Shep/Teyla fan and don't switch sides easily. I'm set in my ways and see ship for these two...
I also now start to see McWeir because of a friend I met here...Caz has me seeing moments for these two...and my brother has me seeing Caldwell/Weir!
I also now look for Shep/Weir moments but to me they always mean friendship first...I can't help it I'm bias towards Shepmagan prettiness!
But I did like the hug between them...it was so glad you're not dead
I think I need to come out with a siggy that says proud Multi-shipper!
Well I think I could never switch John or Elizabeth shipping with anyone else than each other now.
The other I tend more. Funny I started to like Teyla when her interactions with Ronon started so I shipped for them, but now after seeing her with Carson, I'm very much into them
It's funny how different people can be...we are all watching exactly the same show, but ship for two totaly different pairings!
Comment
-
How far down to we have to break out in our categories? We have:
Sheppard/Weir Ship Thread
Sheppard/Weir Friendship Thread
Sheppard/Teyla Ship Thread
Teyla/Weir Friendship
Teyla/Weir Ship (yes, there IS one)
Teyla WOW
Weir WOW
Teyla Discussion
Weir Discussion
Now we have Shep/Tey/Shep/Weir Discussion
I guess we really need a Shep/Teyla Friendship Thread - we're missing that one.
My question is. . WHY do we even need all these threads? If you really want to talk to opposing shippers then go to that thread. If you come in with intelligent conversation, there isn't a problem. .now, if an S/T person goes into S/W spouting off about Shep/Teyla beautiful babies (yes, this has happened), they are going to be blasted. So it goes. Just be mature and honest and no one gets hurt.
In the meantime, we have a bazillion threads on basically the same subject with people posting the same things and racking up their post counts. To make matters worse, GW servers have enough trouble keeping up with the crowd. Redundency makes matters worse.
When all else fails, change channels.
Comment
Comment