Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

SG1 Best Episode Tournament - Seasons 1 through 7 overall CTD.

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    SG1 Best Episode Tournament - Seasons 1 through 7 overall CTD.

    This tournament, which was a da_hippie-Katerine production was run survivor style, so that as well as getting a winner, we get a full list showing favourite to least favourite. It ran for about 8 months, but only for seasons 1-7. Here are the results (More results in second post due to character limit:


    EPISODES LIST (Least favourite to most favourite)

    This is just the standard list based on when the episodes were eliminated. The ones at the top were least favourite and they gain popularity as you go down.

    (1.04) Emancipation - Round 1
    (7.08) Space Race - Round 2
    (6.05) Nightwalkers - Round 3
    (2.10) Bane - Round 4
    (7.13) Grace - Round 5
    (6.13) Sight Unseen - Round 6
    (1.21) Politics - Round 7
    (1.16) Cor-ai - Round 8
    (7.15) Chimera - Round 9
    (2.04) The Gamekeeper - Round 10
    (7.09) Avenger 2.0 - Round 11
    (1.06) The First Commandment - Round 12 (Tie)
    (2.13) Spirits - Round 12 (Tie)
    (2.19) One False Step - Round 13
    (2.05) Need - Round 14
    (6.17) Disclosure - Round 15
    (7.07) Enemy Mine - Round 16
    (6.08) The Other Guys - Round 17
    (1.09) Brief Candle - Round 18
    (5.07) Beast of Burden - Round 19
    (3.08) Demons - Round 20
    (3.17) A Hundred Days - Round 21
    (6.07) Shadow Play - Round 22
    (5.12) Wormhole X-Treme! - Round 23
    (2.14) Touchstone - Round 24 (Tie)
    (3.09) Rules of Engagement - Round 24 (Tie)
    (3.02) Seth - Round 25 (Tie)
    (7.20) Inaugeration - Round 25 (Tie)
    (1.07) Cold Lazarus - Round 26
    (1.12) Bloodlines - Round 27
    (4.19) Prodigy - Round 28
    (4.04) Crossroads - Round 29
    (5.20) The Sentinel - Round 30
    (7.14) Fallout - Round 31
    (2.03) Prisoners - Round 32
    (1.05) The Broca Divide - Round 33
    (7.10) Birthright - Round 34
    (2.08) Family - Round 35
    (6.18) Forsaken - Round 36 (Tie)
    (6.20) Momento - Round 36 (Tie)
    (4.18) The Light - Round 37
    (5.05) Red Sky - Round 38
    (5.18) The Warrior - Round 39
    (7.19) Resurrection - Round 40
    (5.04) The Fifth Man - Round 41
    (2.20) Show and Tell - Round 42
    (4.07) Watergate - Round 43
    (6.16) Metamorphosis - Round 44
    (3.19) New Ground - Round 45 (Tie)
    (7.05) Revisions - Round 45 (Tie)
    (1.14) Hathor - Round 46 (Tie)
    (2.07) Message in a Bottle - Round 46 (Tie)
    (2.17) Holiday - Round 47
    (4.08) The First Ones - Round 48
    (5.11) Desperate Measures - Round 49
    (2.22) Out of Mind - Round 50
    (6.04) Frozen - Round 51
    (5.13) Proving Ground - Round 52
    (3.11) Past and Present - Round 53
    (4.20) Entity - Round 54
    (6.10) Cure - Round 55
    (6.19) Prophecy - Round 56
    (6.11) Prometheus - Round 57
    (7.06) Lifeboat - Round 58 (Tie)
    (4.05) Divide and Conquer - Round 58 (Tie)
    (5.06) Rite of Passage - Round 59
    (4.11) Point of No return - Round 60
    (3.05) Learning Curve - Round 61 (Tie)
    (4.09) Scorched Earth - Round 61 (Tie)
    (2.16) A Matter Of Time - Round 62
    (5.15) Summit - Round 63 (Tie)
    (6.14) Smoke & Mirrors - Round 63 (Tie)
    (1.18) Tin Man - Round 64 (Tie)
    (7.04) Orpehus - Round 64 (Tie)
    (1.03) The Enemy Within - Round 65 (Tie)
    (7.16) Death Knell - Round 65 (Tie)
    (5.16) Last Stand - Round 66
    (1.12) Fire & Water - Round 67
    (5.03) Ascension - Round 68
    (6.09) Allegiance - Round 69
    (5.02) Threshold - Round 70 (Tie)
    (4.10) Beneath The Surface - Round 70 (Tie)
    (5.17) Fail Safe - Round 71 (Tie)
    (3.07) Deadman Switch - Round 71 (Tie)
    (5.08) The Tomb - Round 72
    (4.02) The Other Side - Round 73
    (1.17) Enigma - Round 74
    (1.15) Singularity - Round 75
    (3.04) Legacy - Round 76
    (5.19) Menace - Round 77 (Tie)
    (3.16) Urgo - Round 77 (Tie)
    (7.12) Evolution, Part 2 - Round 78 (Tie)
    (3.18) Shades of Grey - Round 78 (Tie)
    (6.01) Redemption, Part 1 - Round 79(Tie)
    (2.11) The Tok'ra, Part 1 - Round 79(Tie)
    (7.11) Evolution, Part 1 - Round 80
    (2.18) Serpent's Song - Round 81
    (1.07) The Nox - Round 82
    (6.15) Paradise Lost - Round 83
    (3.06) Point Of View - Round 84 (Tie)
    (3.14) Foothold - Round 84 (Tie)
    (2.09) Secrets - Round 85(Tie)
    (3.10) Forever In A Day - Round 85 (Tie)
    (3.15) Pretense - Round 86
    (4.12) Tangent - Round 87
    (1.09) Thor's Hammer - Round 88
    (2.06) Thor's Chariot - Round 89
    (3.01) Into The Fire - Round 90
    (6.19) The Changeling - Round 91
    (3.20) Maternal Instinct - Round 92
    (3.03) Fair Game - Round 93
    (4.15) Chain Reaction - Round 94
    (4.16) 2010 - Round 95
    (4.13) The Curse - Round 96
    (5.10) 2001 - Round 97
    (7.03) Fragile Balance - Round 98
    (2.12) The Tok'Ra, Part 2 - Round 99
    (6.03) Descent - Round 100
    (2.02) In The Line of Duty - Round 101
    (3.21) Crystal Skull - Round 102
    (4.17) Absolute Power - Round 103
    (7.17) Heroes, Part 1 - Round 104
    (5.14) 48 Hours - Round 105
    (4.21) Double Jeopardy - Round 106
    (6.02) Redemption, Part 2 - Round 107
    (1.18) Solitudes - Round 108
    (6.12) Unnatural Selection - Round 109
    (4.03) Upgrades - Round 110
    (4.14) The Serpent's Venom - Round 111
    (7.02) Homecoming - Round 112
    (3.12) Jolinar's Memories - Round 113
    (5.09) Between Two Fires - Round 114
    (1.11) The Torment of Tantalus - Round 115
    (3.13) The Devil You Know - Round 116
    (2.21) 1969 - Round 117
    (7.01) Fallen - Round 118
    (5.22) Revelations - Round 119
    (4.01) Small Victories - Round 120
    (3.22) Nemesis - Round 121
    (5.01) Enemies - Round 122
    (5.21) Meridian - Round 123
    (4.22) Exodus - Round 124
    (7.18) Heroes, Part 2 - Round 125
    (1.01) Children of the Gods, Part 1 - Round 126
    (1.20) There But for the Grace of God - Round 127
    (1.22) Within The Serpent's Grasp - Round 128
    (1.02) Children of the Gods, Part 2 - Round 129
    (6.22) Full Circle - Round 130
    (2.01) The Serpent's Lair - Round 131
    (7.21) Lost City, Part 1 - Round 132
    (6.06) Abyss - Round 133
    (2.15) The Fifth Race - Round 134
    (4.06) Window of Opportunity
    (7.22) Lost City, Part 2


    Total number of episodes: 154

    The winner!

    LOST CITY, PART 2

    Once again, thanks to all who took part and especially to Katerine for all her hard work.
    Last edited by da_hippie; 16 February 2006, 12:15 PM.
    * Always remember - You are unique, just like everyone else. *

    * Avoid employing unlucky people, throw half of the CVs in the bin without reading them. *

    Lost City, Part 2 - The Gateworld best ep S1-7

    The 'Everyone Gets A Compliment' Thread

    #2
    These results have been compiled by Katerine and they are much more complex:

    Here are the results of the tournament, based on all votes in valid posts. The difference between this and the official results , is that the official results are based on the majority in any given round, while this list is based on ALL votes in ALL rounds.

    The percentage listed is the average percentage of votes that ep got during all of the rounds up until it was eliminated. It's also weighted a little, so votes in early rounds count a bit more than votes in later rounds. The object is to distinguish between those eps that had been getting votes for a while, vs. those eps that had gotten surges of votes as other eps were eliminated. FYI, the very last round is not counted, since both WoO and Lost City got around 50% of the votes, and that would have thrown things off. Tiebreakers are also not counted, for the same reason.

    1. (2.15) The Fifth Race - Round 135 - -7.067%
    2. (1.02) Children of the Gods Part 2 - Round 129 - -6.035%
    3. (7.22) Lost City, Part 2 - Round 137 - -5.798%
    4. (7.21) Lost City, Part 1 - Round 132 - -5.618%
    5. (1.22) Within the Serpent's Grasp - Round 128 - -5.604%
    6. (2.01) The Serpent's Lair - Round 131 - -5.361%
    7. (5.01) Enemies - Round 122 - -4.954%
    8. (6.06) Abyss - Round 133 - -4.670%
    9. (6.22) Full Circle - Round 130 - -4.413%
    10. (5.22) Revelations - Round 119 - -4.075%
    11. (4.22) Exodus - Round 124 - -3.995%
    12. (4.06) Window of Opportunity - Round 136 - -3.986%
    13. (1.01) Children of the Gods Part 1 - Round 126 - -3.610%
    14. (5.14) 48 Hours - Round 105 - -3.222%
    15. (1.20) There But For the Grace of God - Round 127 - -3.167%
    16. (7.01) Fallen - Round 118 - -2.926%
    17. (5.09) Between Two Fires - Round 114 - -2.839%
    18. (5.10) 2001 - Round 97 - -2.735%
    19. (2.02) In the Line of Duty - Round 101 - -2.673%
    20. (3.13) The Devil You Know - Round 116 - -2.583%
    21. (7.17) Heroes, Part 1 - Round 104 - -2.249%
    22. (4.21) Double Jeopardy - Round 106 - -2.073%
    23. (3.22) Nemesis - Round 121 - -2.045%
    24. (4.01) Small Victories - Round 120 - -2.019%
    25. (6.01) Redemption, Part 1 - Round 79 (Tie) - -1.835%
    26. (7.11) Evolution, Part 1 - Round 80 - -1.824%
    27. (5.21) Meridian - Round 123 - -1.808%
    28. (6.02) Redemption, Part 2 - Round 107 - -1.757%
    29. (4.03) Upgrades - Round 110 - -1.675%
    30. (7.18) Heroes, Part 2 - Round 125 - -1.672%
    31. (2.11) The Tok'Ra, Part 1 - Round 79 (Tie) - -1.560%
    32. (7.03) Fragile Balance - Round 98 - -1.301%
    33. (2.12) The Tok'Ra, Part 2 - Round 99 - -1.252%
    34. (3.12) Jolinar's Memories - Round 113 - -1.181%
    35. (4.14) The Serpent's Venom - Round 111 - -0.952%
    36. (1.11) The Torment of Tantalus - Round 115 - -0.893%
    37. (3.01) Into the Fire - Round 90 - -0.870%
    38. (1.18) Solitudes - Round 108 - -0.819%
    39. (4.15) Chain Reaction - Round 94 - -0.767%
    40. (7.02) Homecoming - Round 112 - -0.702%
    41. (2.18) Serpent's Song - Round 81 - -0.517%
    42. (6.03) Descent - Round 100 - -0.446%
    43. (4.12) Tangent - Round 87 - -0.442%
    44. (5.19) Menace - Round 77 (Tie) - -0.243%
    45. (4.13) The Curse - Round 96 - -0.238%
    46. (7.12) Evolution, Part 2 - Round 78 (Tie) - -0.177%
    47. (2.21) 1969 - Round 117 - -0.154%
    48. (6.12) Unnatural Selection - Round 109 - -0.065%
    49. (6.15) Paradise Lost - Round 83 - 0.017%
    50. (4.17) Absolute Power - Round 103 - 0.184%
    51. (3.03) Fair Game - Round 93 - 0.285%
    52. (2.06) Thor's Chariot - Round 89 - 0.491%
    53. (2.09) Secrets - Round 85 (Tie) - 0.505%
    54. (3.14) Foothold - Round 84 (Tie) - 0.567%
    55. (1.17) Enigma - Round 74 - 0.582%
    56. (4.16) 2010 - Round 95 - 0.688%
    57. (3.20) Maternal Instinct - Round 92 - 0.780%
    58. (5.17) Fail Safe - Round 71 (Tie) - 1.031%
    59. (1.10) Thor's Hammer - Round 88 - 1.550%
    60. (6.09) Allegiance - Round 69 - 1.729%
    61. (3.11) Past and Present - Round 53 - 1.926%
    62. (3.06) Point of View - Round 84 (Tie) - 1.949%
    63. (6.14) Smoke and Mirrors - Round 63 (Tie) - 2.156%
    64. (1.15) Singularity - Round 75 - 2.217%
    65. (3.07) Deadman Switch - Round 71 (Tie) - 2.295%
    66. (7.16) Death Knell - Round 65 (Tie) - 2.464%
    67. (3.18) Shades of Grey - Round 78 (Tie) - 2.523%
    68. (3.15) Pretense - Round 86 - 2.551%
    69. (1.08) The Nox - Round 82 - 2.636%
    70. (3.21) Crystal Skull - Round 102 - 3.263%
    71. (2.16) A Matter of Time - Round 62 - 3.279%
    72. (7.04) Orpheus - Round 64 (Tie) - 3.755%
    73. (5.16) Last Stand - Round 66 - 3.797%
    74. (5.02) Threshold - Round 70 (Tie) - 4.186%
    75. (4.02) The Other Side - Round 73 - 4.441%
    76. (6.19) The Changeling - Round 91 - 4.663%
    77. (5.08) The Tomb - Round 72 - 5.150%
    78. (5.06) Rite of Passage - Round 59 - 5.428%
    79. (4.09) Scorched Earth - Round 61 (Tie) - 5.456%
    80. (1.03) The Enemy Within - Round 65 (Tie) - 5.591%
    81. (3.04) Legacy - Round 76 - 5.649%
    82. (6.11) Prometheus - Round 57 - 5.685%
    83. (5.18) The Warrior - Round 39 - 5.690%
    84. (4.07) Watergate - Round 43 - 5.902%
    85. (5.03) Ascension - Round 68 - 6.185%
    86. (6.10) Cure - Round 55 - 6.217%
    87. (5.15) Summit - Round 63 (Tie) - 6.471%
    88. (1.13) Fire and Water - Round 67 - 6.638%
    89. (4.10) Beneath the Surface - Round 70 (Tie) - 6.746%
    90. (2.22) Out of Mind - Round 50 - 7.358%
    91. (3.16) Urgo - Round 77 (Tie) - 7.435%
    92. (7.05) Revisions - Round 45 (Tie) - 7.711%
    93. (1.19) Tin Man - Round 64 (Tie) - 8.502%
    94. (7.06) Lifeboat - Round 58 (Tie) - 8.637%
    95. (5.13) Proving Ground - Round 52 - 8.651%
    96. (6.21) Prophecy - Round 56 - 8.652%
    97. (5.04) The Fifth Man - Round 41 - 8.654%
    98. (7.14) Fallout - Round 31 - 9.139%
    99. (2.17) Holiday - Round 47 - 9.642%
    100. (2.08) Family - Round 35 - 9.900%
    101. (6.04) Frozen - Round 51 - 9.980%
    102. (3.10) Forever in a Day - Round 85 (Tie) - 10.981%
    103. (4.11) Point of No Return - Round 60 - 11.031%
    104. (5.11) Desperate Measures - Round 49 - 11.039%
    105. (5.20) The Sentinel - Round 30 - 11.712%
    106. (2.20) Show and Tell - Round 42 - 11.718%
    107. (6.20) Momento - Round 36 (Tie) - 11.770%
    108. (1.07) Cold Lazarus - Round 26 - 11.990%
    109. (1.14) Hathor - Round 46 (Tie) - 12.034%
    110. (3.05) Learning Curve - Round 61 (Tie) - 12.273%
    111. (7.10) Birthright - Round 34 - 12.467%
    112. (1.12) Bloodlines - Round 27 - 12.614%
    113. (6.18) Forsaken - Round 36 (Tie) - 12.640%
    114. (3.19) New Ground - Round 45 (Tie) - 12.837%
    115. (4.19) Prodigy - Round 28 - 14.185%
    116. (7.19) Resurrection - Round 40 - 14.542%
    117. (2.14) Touchstone - Round 24 (Tie) - 14.883%
    118. (3.02) Seth - Round 25 (Tie) - 15.179%
    119. (4.08) The First Ones - Round 48 - 15.228%
    120. (3.09) Rules of Engagement - Round 24 (Tie) - 15.249%
    121. (1.09) Brief Candle - Round 18 - 15.844%
    122. (5.05) Red Sky - Round 38 - 15.879%
    123. (4.04) Crossroads - Round 29 - 15.991%
    124. (7.20) Inaugeration - Round 25 (Tie) - 17.109%
    125. (6.16) Metamorphosis - Round 44 - 17.543%
    126. (4.18) The Light - Round 37 - 17.565%
    127. (1.05) The Broca Divide - Round 33 - 18.056%
    128. (2.07) Message in a Bottle - Round 46 (Tie) - 18.095%
    129. (2.03) Prisoners - Round 32 - 18.799%
    130. (1.06) The First Commandment - Round 12 (Tie) - 18.917%
    131. (7.07) Enemy Mine - Round 16 - 19.478%
    132. (6.08) The Other Guys - Round 17 - 19.716%
    133. (4.05) Divide and Conquer - Round 58 (Tie) - 19.772%
    134. (4.20) Entity - Round 54 - 20.060%
    135. (3.17) A Hundred Days - Round 21 - 20.123%
    136. (5.12) Wormhole X-Treme! - Round 23 - 20.177%
    137. (5.07) Beast of Burden - Round 19 - 20.445%
    138. (2.05) Need - Round 14 - 20.461%
    139. (6.07) Shadow Play - Round 22 - 21.827%
    140. (6.17) Disclosure - Round 15 - 22.332%
    141. (3.08) Demons - Round 20 - 22.434%
    142. (2.13) Spirits - Round 12 (Tie) - 22.635%
    143. (7.15) Chimera - Round 9 - 23.113%
    144. (2.19) One False Step - Round 13 - 25.171%
    145. (1.16) Cor-ai - Round 8 - 25.245%
    146. (2.04) The Gamekeeper - Round 10 - 26.392%
    147. (7.09) Avenger 2.0 - Round 11 - 28.131%
    148. (1.21) Politics - Round 7 - 31.119%
    149. (7.13) Grace - Round 5 - 32.959%
    150. (6.05) Nightwalkers - Round 3 - 34.610%
    151. (6.13) Sight Unseen - Round 6 - 35.848%
    152. (2.10) Bane - Round 4 - 37.777%
    153. (7.08) Space Race - Round 2 - 37.969%
    154. (1.04) Emancipation - Round 1 - 43.039%

    And here are the weighted season results:
    5 - 5.210%
    4 - 5.505%
    3 - 5.983%
    7 - 8.873%
    1 - 8.929%
    6 - 9.191%
    2 - 9.478%

    So while the two sets of results are similar, they do show some different trends. Both should be viewed when deciding on the overall most popular episode from season 1 to 7.

    Once again thanks to Katerine for these results.
    Last edited by da_hippie; 16 February 2006, 12:16 PM.
    * Always remember - You are unique, just like everyone else. *

    * Avoid employing unlucky people, throw half of the CVs in the bin without reading them. *

    Lost City, Part 2 - The Gateworld best ep S1-7

    The 'Everyone Gets A Compliment' Thread

    Comment


      #3
      Fragile Balance
      Rite of Passage
      Tin Man
      Chain Reaction
      Entity
      Double Jeopardy
      Cure
      Secrets

      Comment


        #4
        It's so great to have this thread up and runnin' again!
        Thanks da_hippie and everyone else who was involved.

        Round 54:
        Pretense
        Divide & Conquer
        Point of No Return
        Summit
        Last Stand
        Descent
        Smoke & Mirrors
        Evolution Pt 2

        Sig courtesy of InvisibleGirl
        Proud to be an Aussie - the Calling all Australians thread.

        My incredibly boring blog!

        Comment


          #5
          Thank you for taking responsibility for this tournament.

          Are we restarting the numbering from round 1, or continuing from round 54?

          Okely-dokely... my votes:

          Entity
          Divide and Conquer
          Learning Curve
          Tin Man
          Lifeboat
          Prophecy
          Rite of Passage
          Cure
          I'd start a revolution if I could get up in the morning.

          Comment


            #6
            I can't believe some of these episodes have made it this far! I mean.. A Matter of Time???


            Fire and Water
            A Matter of Time
            Deadman Switch
            Allegiance
            Orpheus
            Fair Game
            Entity
            Tin Man

            Comment


              #7
              Round 54:

              Solitudes
              Singularity
              Tin Man
              Shades of Grey
              Summit
              Homecoming
              Jolinar's Memories
              The Devil You Know

              Glad to see this going again!

              Member of W.A.S.P. ~ My Fan Fiction ~MySpace ~ Thanks to *E*K*R* for the sig!

              Comment


                #8
                It's good to be back---thanks, da_hippie!

                Round 1 (or 54, depending on the time dilation device )

                1) Learning Curve
                2) The Other Side
                3) Scorched Earth
                4) Entity
                5) Prophecy
                6) Smoke and Mirrors
                7) Exodus
                8) Fail Safe

                Comment


                  #9
                  My votes for Round 54:

                  The Tomb
                  Unnatural Selection
                  Death Knell
                  Prophecy
                  Divide and Conquer
                  Entity
                  Foothold
                  A Matter of Time

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Round 54 Redux

                    1. Prometheus
                    2. Learning Curve
                    3. A Matter of Time
                    4. Entity
                    5. Singularity
                    6. Urgo
                    7. Cure
                    8. Deadman Switch

                    During the hiatus, I rewatched Prophecy, and it wasn't as bad as I thought, so it's off my current least fav list.

                    Thanks again to da hippie and Walter for taking over Katerine's responsibilities (and Katerine, if you're still out there somewhere, hope you're ok and we miss you!)

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Divide and Conquer
                      The Other Side
                      Beneath the Surface
                      Entity
                      Lost City, Part II
                      Point of No Return
                      Window of Opportunity
                      2010
                      "There is simply no other choice than this: either to abstain from interference in the free play of the market, or to delegate the entire management of production and distribution to the government. Either capitalism or socialism: there exists no middle way."
                      -Ludwig von Mises

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Round 54

                        The Enemy Within
                        Pretense
                        Shades of Grey
                        Point of No Return
                        Tangent
                        Cure
                        Orpheus
                        Last Stand
                        My View From The Peanut Gallery

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Round 54
                          1. Learning Curve
                          2. Right of passage
                          3. Divide and Conquer
                          4. Entity
                          5. Death Knell
                          6. Point of No Return
                          7. Prometheus
                          8. Foothold
                          ___________
                          sigpic

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Fire and water
                            Urgo
                            Tin man
                            Prophecy
                            Allegiance
                            Rite of passage
                            Threshold
                            A matter of time

                            Ps. Thanks for doing this! I think i speak for all of us involved when i say, thank you!!

                            The center of Khlysty surrounds me

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Round 54

                              Cure
                              Lifeboat
                              Thor's Hammer
                              Summit
                              Last Stand
                              Forever in a Day
                              Legacy
                              Ascension
                              sigpic

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X