Originally posted by Zatnikitelman
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
BC-303/304 Commanders - How much I do not like Emerson!!
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
See I've always had a problem with that. On SG-1 when ever they were on the Prommie or Oddy they gave the commands to the captain, wheather it was Pendergast, Ronson, or Emmerson. Atleast when Jack was on board he was of equal rank to them, but Emmerson and Pendergast out rank both Carter and Mitchell and it was their ship they were on. I think that its great on SGA they actually let Cawdwell be a stong enough character to comand his ship. I think its just the formats of the shows. On SG-1 its all about SG-1 and on Atlantis its less about the team so it gave the writers room to have Cawdwell be a stong leader and a good character, not just a doormatt their because a ship needs a commander.
Perfecto!
Comment
-
Originally posted by Major_GriffSee I've always had a problem with that. On SG-1 when ever they were on the Prommie or Oddy they gave the commands to the captain, wheather it was Pendergast, Ronson, or Emmerson. Atleast when Jack was on board he was of equal rank to them, but Emmerson and Pendergast out rank both Carter and Mitchell and it was their ship they were on. I think that its great on SGA they actually let Cawdwell be a stong enough character to comand his ship. I think its just the formats of the shows. On SG-1 its all about SG-1 and on Atlantis its less about the team so it gave the writers room to have Cawdwell be a stong leader and a good character, not just a doormatt their because a ship needs a commander.
Comment
-
Originally posted by McSwiftSo anyways I was watching the recent SG1 episode, "The Pegasus Project"
It was amazing.
But you gotta see though, if those of you watch Atlantis, Caudwell is WAY better commander than Emerson.
When they battled the Wraith Hive ship, they were thinking things on the spot, no strategy, no thought.
When Caudwell fights the wraith, he strategizes and knows what hes doing.
I gotta say, its a fluke that the Odyssey didn't get blown up too.
Spoiler:He is killed later this season by one of the members of the Lucian Alliance.
IMO they are both good commanders.
Comment
Comment