SG1 Best Episode Tournament - Seasons 1 through 7 overall

[GatetheWay]

The Broca Divide
Prisoners
Crossroads
Divide and Conquer
Message in a Bottle
Fallout
Birthright
Ascension

[CatGoddess]

Show and Tell
Message in a Bottle
Birthright
Entity
The Broca Divide
The Light
Crossroads
Divide and Conquer

[Dahar Master Thor]

The Changeling
The First Ones
Forever in a Day
Absolute Power
Meridian
Crossroads
Upgrades
Paradise Lost

[L-JADE]

Round 29 :

Resurrection
Family
Holiday
Proving Ground
The Warrior
Entity
Fallout
Revisions

[Frostfox]

Round 2


Learning Curve
Frozen
Divide and Conquer
Momento
Entity
Revisions
Metamorphosis
The Sentinel

FF

[the dancer of spaz]

Round 29

Crossroads
Prisoners <-- you're still here, why?
Message In a Bottle
The Sentinel
Show and Tell
Summit
Frozen <-- gurgle
The Light

[SimilarCadence]

Round 29

The Sentinel
Birthright
Red Sky
Momento
Forsaken
The Other Side
The Warrior
Fallout

[Adamas]

1> Holiday
2> Legacy
3> CrossRoads
4> Scorched Earth
5> Tangent
6> The Light
7> Threshold
8> 48 Hours

If Any Errors Sub "Revisions" for Errored Choice.

[Atlantis1]

Hathor
The Nox
Forever in a Day
Prisoners
2010
Beneath the Surface
1969
Allegiance

[Atteria]

Round 29

1. The Light
2. Prisoners
3. Red Sky
4. Metamorphosis
5. Scorched Earth
6. The Sentinel
7. Momento
8. The Warrior

[fair_nymph]

Holiday
Birthright
Red Sky
Crossroads
Family
The Light
1969
Urgo

I want to vote for The Sentinel too but NOT until The Light goes.

[aizjanika]

Round 29 Votes:

1. Entity
2. Descent
3. Metamorphosis
4. Divide and Conquer
5. Prometheus
6. Momento
7. Foresaken (Back on my list now that the hated Prodigy is gone. How could I have forgotten how much I hated it? LOL)
8. Cure

aizjanika, hopefully if the number of votes is high enough, the episodes remaining will be a fair sampling of what a good majority of fans (or at least GW fans) consider to be the best of the best, and not just the mediocre middle (though that's my theory as to why Season 5 is in the "best" season place so far. IMHO its episodes contained neither the best nor the worst, just a group of so-so.)

hehe It'll be interesting to see how it all works out, regardless. This is a lot of fun so thanks to Celsius for the idea and Katerine for doing the all-season tournament.

I also would classify season 5 pretty much as you did--as a reasonably good season of so-so episodes. hehe I like it about as much as I like season 7, which is better than seasons 4 or 6. But even though I'd classify season 4 as the worst season besides the bland season 6, it actually had a fair number of episodes that I had a strong reaction to--either loved'em or hated'em. hehe

As far as Teal’c episodes go, I actually liked Bloodlines better than Family. Interesting character development for him. To each his own…….

I liked both Bloodlines and Family They were good Teal'c episodes that also had lots of good team stuff and character stuff for the other characters--plus Bra'tak!

I enjoyed Prodigy (even though she does remind me of Paris Gellar--can't remember who mentioned it where, but I agree!). It kind of made me think about what Sam must have been like as a young whipper-snapper in training and how it must have been for her.

Aw, I loved The Light, but absolutely hated Prodigy--so much so that I blanked it off my radar of least favorite episodes. ;-) Cadet Haley is my least favorite character who ever appeared on the show. I actually though the whole episode had nothing redeeming it except...wasn't that Dr. Lee there, IIRC? I wouldn't want to think that Sam was anything at all like Haley when young. :-)

[Peteo]

Round 29:

Fail Safe
Red Sky
Metamorphosis
Out of Mind
Small Victories
Proving Ground
The Broca Divide
Message in a Bottle

[Shir]

The Fifth Man
Prophecy
Resurrection
Crossroads
The Sentinel
Birthright
The Changeling
fallout

[Derek]

Round 29

Prisoners
The Warrior
Message in a Bottle
New Ground
The Light
Entity
Rite of Passage
Metamorphosis