Season Five : Compliments and Praise Thread

[Linda06]

*draws sword*

This will be a short battle.

'The Prodigal' would be deserving of at least 3 stars (IMO).

Well if The Shrine got 4 stars Prodigal is deserving of 5 stars seeing as it's the best ep of the season so far

[Pegasus_SGA]

Spoiler:

my top 5 eps...

S&R
DV
FC
TLT
The Prodigal



what about the C story?







me too



LOL a bit?



um yes

Well....

Remnants

Spoiler:

Kolya

Spoiler:

Beats the crap out of Sheppy

Spoiler:

Even though we know he's dead... is he?

Spoiler:

SO there's angst, and whump and blood and then....

Spoiler:

Are you sure you wanna know?

Spoiler:

Really sure?

Spoiler:

It's a big honking thing and might spoil it for you, but if you really want to know?

Spoiler:

Sure?

Spoiler:

Am I pissing you off yet?

Spoiler:

Kolya hurts Sheppy in a big big way and

Spoiler:

chops his hand off!!

Spoiler:

squeeeeeeeeee

Spoiler:

Yeah I know I'm sick!

[jelgate]

Well....Remnants

Spoiler:

Kolya

Spoiler:

Beats the crap out of Sheppy

Spoiler:

Even though we know he's dead... is he?

Spoiler:

SO there's angst, and whump and blood and then....

Spoiler:

Are you sure you wanna know?

Spoiler:

Really sure?

Spoiler:

It's a big honking thing and might spoil it for you, but if you really want to know?

Spoiler:

Sure?

Spoiler:

Am I pissing you off yet?

Spoiler:

Kolya hurts Sheppy in a big big way and

Spoiler:

chops his hand off!!

Spoiler:

squeeeeeeeeee

Spoiler:

Yeah I know I'm sick!

I cocure with this conclusion. Peg is sick

[Jumper_One]

Well....

Remnants

Spoiler:

Kolya

Spoiler:

Beats the crap out of Sheppy

Spoiler:

Even though we know he's dead... is he?

Spoiler:

SO there's angst, and whump and blood and then....

Spoiler:

Are you sure you wanna know?

Spoiler:

Really sure?

Spoiler:

It's a big honking thing and might spoil it for you, but if you really want to know?

Spoiler:

Sure?

Spoiler:

Am I pissing you off yet?

Spoiler:

Kolya hurts Sheppy in a big big way and

Spoiler:

chops his hand off!!

Spoiler:

squeeeeeeeeee

Spoiler:

Yeah I know I'm sick!

Spoiler:

no

Spoiler:

you

Spoiler:

are

Spoiler:

not

Spoiler:

pissing

Spoiler:

me

Spoiler:

off

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

but

Spoiler:

are

Spoiler:

you

Spoiler:

sure

Spoiler:

it

Spoiler:

is

Spoiler:

his

Spoiler:

hand

Spoiler:

?

Spoiler:

I

Spoiler:

thought

Spoiler:

he

Spoiler:

cut

Spoiler:

off

Spoiler:

his

Spoiler:

arm

I cocure with this conclusion. Peg is sick

[Guest]

*Cuts Linda head off* Said it would be a short battle.

Well if The Shrine got 4 stars Prodigal is deserving of 5 stars seeing as it's the best ep of the season so far

I doubt it will get 5 stars, 3 at least though (IMO).

[Guest]

I cocure with this conclusion. Peg is sick

I agree.

[Linda06]

Ooh ooh I wanna join in on the top 5

hmmm...*thinking*

1. Prodigal
2.S&R
3. The Queen
4. DV
5.First contact

Joel is awesome! I mean come on he's been working on SG since 1997 and still manages to amaze us

Joel is god *bows at feet of Joel*

I have seen a lot hotter. ...occasionally on Stargate too. But she is the hottest main character on the show.....or Jewel...Amanda...Jewel...Jewel...Amanda.
Not really.....

hmmmm.....Rachel but like cazz I am also a heterosexual female so what do I know

[Pegasus_SGA]

I cocure with this conclusion. Peg is sick

Indeed.

Spoiler:

no

Spoiler:

you

Spoiler:

are

Spoiler:

not

Spoiler:

pissing

Spoiler:

me

Spoiler:

off

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

but

Spoiler:

are

Spoiler:

you

Spoiler:

sure

Spoiler:

it

Spoiler:

is

Spoiler:

his

Spoiler:

hand

Spoiler:

?

Spoiler:

I

Spoiler:

thought

Spoiler:

he

Spoiler:

cut

Spoiler:

off

Spoiler:

his

Spoiler:

arm

Spoiler:

Are

Spoiler:

You

Spoiler:

taking

Spoiler:

the

Spoiler:

piss?

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

I

Spoiler:

can

Spoiler:

honestly

Spoiler:

and

Spoiler:

definately

Spoiler:

say

Spoiler:

that

Spoiler:

it's

Spoiler:

not

his

Spoiler:

arm

Spoiler:

it

Spoiler:

is

Spoiler:

indeed

Spoiler:

his

Spoiler:

hand

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Trust me

Spoiler:

I'm a whumper

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

and

Spoiler:

a

Spoiler:

sick one at that!!

Spoiler:

[Guest]

hmmmm.....Rachel but like cazz I am also a heterosexual female so what do I know

Indeed plus the defining hot is subjective anyway.

[Jumper_One]

Ooh ooh I wanna join in on the top 5

hmmm...*thinking*

1. Prodigal
2.S&R
3. The Queen
4. DV
5.First contact

woohoo S&R

Joel is god *bows at feet of Joel*

are you sure?

hmmmm.....Rachel but like cazz I am also a heterosexual female so what do I know

exactly however you do like Sam so...

Spoiler:

Are

Spoiler:

You

Spoiler:

taking

Spoiler:

the

Spoiler:

piss?

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

I

Spoiler:

can

Spoiler:

honestly

Spoiler:

and

Spoiler:

definately

Spoiler:

say

Spoiler:

that

Spoiler:

it's

Spoiler:

not

his

Spoiler:

arm

Spoiler:

it

Spoiler:

is

Spoiler:

indeed

Spoiler:

his

Spoiler:

hand

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Trust me

Spoiler:

I'm a whumper

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

and

Spoiler:

a

Spoiler:

sick one at that!!

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

hm

Spoiler:

it

Spoiler:

might

Spoiler:

be

Spoiler:

unwise

Spoiler:

to

Spoiler:

trust

Spoiler:

a

Spoiler:

whumper

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

I

Spoiler:

think

Spoiler:

jelgate

Spoiler:

would

Spoiler:

agree

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

[Linda06]

Remants looks like an episode that I'll find the B story more entertaining then the A story. Similiar to Broken Ties

Oh what's the B story....But seriously

Spoiler:

How much whump can one guy take....At the beginning of the season a building landed on him and the very next ep he gets stabbed by a tentacle....And now he gets beaten to a bloody pulp in Prodigal and the very next ep he gets beaten to a bloody pulp again I mean, seriously....Isn't anyone else allowed to get whumped occasionally....Is it only Shep that's allowed to get all this whump!

about Remnants

Just for the record for "Remnants" there will be a Story A, B, and C! So should be interesting what happens.

Wait, there's a C story too? hmm maybe there will be something for me to enjoy in this ep after all!

*Cuts Linda head off* Said it would be a short battle.

I doubt it will get 5 stars, 3 at least though (IMO).

Well didn't The shrine get 4 stars...And well The Prodigal was way better than The Shrine so it deserves more stars

[Linda06]

Indeed plus the defining hot is subjective anyway.

Indeed...We all have different tastes.....Not that I'm into females in any way whatsoever

woohoo S&R

Well S&R was one of the best season openers ever

are you sure?

Yes i'm sure..His music never ceases to amase me!

exactly however you do like Sam so...

Yes I do

An I am not clicking on any more spoilers between you and Peg

[Guest]

Well didn't The shrine get 4 stars...And well The Prodigal was way better than The Shrine so it deserves more stars

That's your opinion, Darren might feel different, though I wouldn't be surprised if it got 4 stars as well.

[Pegasus_SGA]

woohoo S&R



are you sure?



exactly however you do like Sam so...

Spoiler:

hm

Spoiler:

it

Spoiler:

might

Spoiler:

be

Spoiler:

unwise

Spoiler:

to

Spoiler:

trust

Spoiler:

a

Spoiler:

whumper

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

I

Spoiler:

think

Spoiler:

jelgate

Spoiler:

would

Spoiler:

agree

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

*Giggles*

[Linda06]

That's your opinion, Darren might feel different, though I wouldn't be surprised if it got 4 stars as well.

That's why I don't listen to critics any more....Generally what they say is good I find crap...Take American Psych for instance...They were bumming this film up to high heavens so I got it to watch...I've never been so bored in all my life, half way through I started fast forwarding it to see what happens at the end