Is Keller a vital part of the expedition?

[Integrabyte]

As the title says: Is Keller a vital part of the expedition?

Options:
1. Yes (why? )
2. No (why?)
3. This isn't where I parked my car.

No flaming, no insults nothing. I don't want another versus. I want people to explain why they chose a certain option. I would also like people to respect other people's opinion.

You will be able to vote soon. Hang on a sec .

[The Prophet]

Atlantis needs a Chief of Medicine, so yes.

[PG15]

Yes, because she's the CMO.

[jenks]

Spoiler:

[Xiphias]

Option c. Or 3.

[Integrabyte]

A huge resounding NO. Why? She is not good enough and does not fit at all on Atlantis.


Will vote when one of the mods makes this a poll .

[JackHarkness_Hot]

I'm going with YES because the expedition needs a CMO, so I like to think that her role is vital, LOL

[Integrabyte]

I guess I am the underdog .

[Jumper_One]

Yes, because she's the CMO.

[Blencathra]

Resounding yes.

Atlantis needs a CMO.

[Agent_Dark]

yes, the role is vital to the expedition and she's holding that role.

[jasminaGo]

Big NO

Atlantis can get better another CMO

[elliecat]

I guess I am the underdog .

I'll join you will a definate NO! She is not vital, she hasn't proved she can do anything that any other doctor could do, just get a new doctor!

[Col. Newman]

A Resounding YES

[Agent_Dark]

I'll join you will a definate NO! She is not vital, she hasn't proved she can do anything that any other doctor could do, just get a new doctor!

illogical statement, if she couldn't do what any other doctor could then she wouldn't have got the job in the first place. Unless you're suggesting that Weir is incompetent for putting an unsuitable in the position.