The Anti Season 4 Thread (Spoilers). For complaints and misgivings ONLY.

[Suzotchka]

Hi mcbarr, I'm not stalking you I promise. Just quoted you over on the SEW thread.

Codefool, you are a genius. Please post more. Want some scotch?

*Sits on couch* Can I have some scotch too, please?

[dana]

*headdesks @ new GW article*

Who can see the oxymoron in the subject of said article? *giggles*

[DragonEagle]

Mega green for you codefool!! Some excellent points, especially about the Ancients. If only TPTB would read through your post.....

[DragonEagle]

*headdesks @ new GW article*

Who can see the oxymoron in the subject of said article? *giggles*

LOL, definitely

[mcbarr]

Hi mcbarr, I'm not stalking you I promise. Just quoted you over on the SEW thread.

Antis are allowed to stalk each other.

---

Heh, just saw it.

*headdesks @ new GW article too*

[Falcon Horus]

LOL, I think my glass is completely empty then.

Mine's always empty.

Aston Martin Vanquish

*thunk*

Random, I know.

Maybe it will when the all new Sci Fi series Painkiller Sam airs...

Would that be the new title for season 4?

Saint Carter is brillant, attractive, confident, smart and has all the right answers.

I so have to photoshop that one. *snort*

[mcbarr]

So Super Sam will have her hands full, huh?

[Falcon Horus]

So Super Sam will have her hands full, huh?

With the "the constant expressions of lust from Rodney McKay" she'll have more than her hands full...

Wait! I thought he was over her?

*inserting icon because Kate's expression says it all*

[Venus91187]

I dont know about any of you guys, but I can barely sit through an episode od SG1. I dont know why , but for some reason it seems too ridiculous sometimes. I didnt become a stargate fan until Atlantis premiered, it seemed more real that scientists would be heading an operation instead of the US Air Force.

[Falcon Horus]

I dont know about any of you guys, but I can barely sit through an episode od SG1. I dont know why , but for some reason it seems too ridiculous sometimes. I didnt become a stargate fan until Atlantis premiered, it seemed more real that scientists would be heading an operation instead of the US Air Force.

Well, I have been watching SG1 since it first aired on TV some 10 years ago. I loved the show, still do but not as much as I love Atlantis-That-Was. I actually stopped running around in the SG-1 fanfic-dom as soon as I discovered Atlantis. I used to write SG1 but that has long changed, as did the reading of fic.

I just like Atlantis-That-Was better than SG1.

[DragonEagle]

I dont know about any of you guys, but I can barely sit through an episode od SG1. I dont know why , but for some reason it seems too ridiculous sometimes. I didnt become a stargate fan until Atlantis premiered, it seemed more real that scientists would be heading an operation instead of the US Air Force.

Exactly what I think, unfortunately it will not longer be scientists heading the operation with Carter coming over. I also enjoyed the fact that Atlantis was a globally collaborated effort, and not just the US military coming into control of powerful alien technology. With Carter onboard the show will basically turn into a rehash of SG1, which I hate to see happen, because I think it is wonderful with the cast they have. TPTB just need to come up with original and creative writing like they did in the beginning of SG1

[mcbarr]

With the "the constant expressions of lust from Rodney McKay" she'll have more than her hands full...

Wait! I thought he was over her?

LOL, the way things are going, maybe McKay will get his hands full of Sam, who knows?

I dont know about any of you guys, but I can barely sit through an episode od SG1. I dont know why , but for some reason it seems too ridiculous sometimes. I didnt become a stargate fan until Atlantis premiered, it seemed more real that scientists would be heading an operation instead of the US Air Force.

I agree. SGA is obviously sci-fi etc., but the show is/was more realistic to me than SG-1.

[SG-1ssm]

Wow...I never thought I would see the day when Stargate fans would be dishing it on Atlantis...not that it isn't deserved, but it surprises me.

I do have to agree with most of what I've read, however. Killing off characters right and left and bring in Sam is not necessary. I agree that Daniel would be a better choice, and that the characters don't have enough backstory.

There is a bigger problem however. Where the hell is this show going? We haven't heard about the Weith since season 2, and there is no direction. There are no story arcs, and nothing is making since. This reminds me of Star Trek's worse times.

[DragonEagle]

Wow...I never thought I would see the day when Stargate fans would be dishing it on Atlantis...not that it isn't deserved, but it surprises me.

I do have to agree with most of what I've read, however. Killing off characters right and left and bring in Sam is not necessary. I agree that Daniel would be a better choice, and that the characters don't have enough backstory.

There is a bigger problem however. Where the hell is this show going? We haven't heard about the Weith since season 2, and there is no direction. There are no story arcs, and nothing is making since. This reminds me of Star Trek's worse times.

Ahh, but we're heading into the replicator story these past couple of seasons *gags* The wraith were so much more fun, with the replicators its like, uh we've been here done this, they beat em on SG1, now can't you just let it be!!

[mcbarr]

Wow...I never thought I would see the day when Stargate fans would be dishing it on Atlantis...not that it isn't deserved, but it surprises me.

Well, Antis oppose unnecessary cast changes and SG: Carter. That's about it. Other than that, we're all PRO Stargate Atlantis, but we also reckon the writers could have done a better job on seasons 1-3.