The Anti Season 4 Thread (Spoilers). For complaints and misgivings ONLY.

[Chrysalis]

Wow, this ep sucked. Really, really sucked. As in "I feel bad for whoever wrote this pile of crap" sucked. From Rodney to Katie to Ronon to Keller to the boring as hell story itself. Sucked.

If there is anyone here who is on the fence over watching it or not, may I give you a gentle SHOVE in the "HELL NO!" direction.

Wow. You're one of the more open antis I know, so seeing this from you means a lot.

I guess it's not worth checking out then. Not that I really wanted to see Ronon and his new child-bride -- I mean the CMO -- stuck in a room together anyway.

[parisindy]

so atlantis is living up to its potential then eh? was there shep whump at least?

i went to a movie instead... anything has to be more interesting

oh a bit of new tricking in about the writers strike...and the new contract offer. hmmm i thought this were going good but Some anaylisis is starting to come out over the DGA contract...and it isnt' good. Some think its a trap from the writers. There is some good stuff in there, but also a lot of loop holes and very bad deals in there too...

[Ruined_puzzle]

I watched Before I Sleep after Quarantine since my husband is new to SGA and we are going through the series together on the dvds he got me for Christmas. I could just weep at the contrast.

I miss those characters.

Maybe Carl can't write for Keller because he doesn't believe in her. I certainly don't.

Before I Sleep is one of my favorite episodes. But then again this was when Carl was not part of the writers team.

I just realized S1 had alot of different writers that are not part of SGA anymore.

[Pajus]

One of the things Radek said in Quarantine was:

Spoiler:

Yuck, this stinks

Not just this

Spoiler:

BTW: What the hell was Teyla doing outside the window? Had the baby decided to make its first kick there, she might've had 790 meters of free fall ahead of her. If I was the baby I'd be kicking her in the head, not the stomach

[gateraid]

Before I Sleep is one of my favorite episodes. But then again this was when Carl was not part of the writers team.

I just realized S1 had alot of different writers that are not part of SGA anymore.

BIS was a bit meh for me, but yeah I usually love Carl Binder's eps. Haven't seen it yet, so can't really comment, but maybe this was another case of having to have the characters meet the plot/arc rather than the other way around? Also, if anyone doesn't like Carl Binder eps, he is on strike at the moment, so it might be a while before he churns out another good one.

Also, s1 had a lot of different characters that are not part of SGA anymore

[Integrabyte]

What an incredible waste of time ....

[dana]

Spoiler:

BTW: What the hell was Teyla doing outside the window? Had the baby decided to make its first kick there, she might've had 790 meters of free fall ahead of her. If I was the baby I'd be kicking her in the head, not the stomach

[Integrabyte]

This new ep was bad...on so many levels. I have a feeling things will never be the same in SGA. When I saw what Keller was saying I felt like TPTB was stabbing people in the back for not accepting poor lill miss fix it

[Pajus]

The sad thing is that I wasn't joking

[dana]

The sad thing is that I wasn't joking

I know but it amused me none the less.

[silkie]

Quarantine - a complete waste of time except for the part

Spoiler:

with Zelenka staring at Carter's boobs

[mcbarr]

Do not worry! Season 5 will be better!

[silkie]

Do not worry! Season 5 will be better!

Yeah

Spoiler:

with Katie out of the way it would be Mckay staring at Carter's boobs next time

[mcbarr]

That's Threes... Oops, Trio!

[Integrabyte]

Quarantine - a complete waste of time except for the part

Spoiler:

with Zelenka staring at Carter's boobs

You perv