The Anti Season 4 Thread (Spoilers). For complaints and misgivings ONLY.

[nowvoyager908]

I know it's a bit late, but I wanted to add my congratulations on 10,000+ posts. Too bad SGA continues to provide so much ammunition for the anti-nation. Can't wait for 20,000+ (with the way things are going, it shouldn't be too far off). Keep up the good fight.

[parisindy]

I know it's a bit late, but I wanted to add my congratulations on 10,000+ posts. Too bad SGA continues to provide so much ammunition for the anti-nation. Can't wait for 20,000+ (with the way things are going, it shouldn't be too far off). Keep up the good fight.

oh! another song!!!

Fight the good fight by triumph! thats perfect for our list!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IImC_...eature=related

[Irish Eyes]

You told the truth, that's what's important. I don't hate Keller, but I find her somewhat annoying, and she's been given far too much screen time this season. If they want to highlight a recurring character, I vote for Zelenka.

I agree with your Keller sentiments. And now that

Spoiler:

she is coming back in season 5, I just have to hope that Carson does as well and she becomes his assistant. There's a chance I could stomach that better.

*hugs Jewel* though because she is great.

True he's probably not a draw for that demographic...but, really, is anyone anti-Zelenka? I suppose there must be, but I've not seen a thread against him or anything. So they should make everyone happy and let him have an episode devoted to him. But no character arcs, please.

I'm very bored at work...maybe I'll see if I can reach 100 posts this evening, to help celebrate over 10,000 for this thread.

I hate to say it, but there wasn't much anti-Carson either and look what happened to him. We must protect Zelenka somehow!

I don't think anyone is untouchable, but I haven't seen a lot of anti-Zelenka sentiment, though I have seen some in various places. Just goes to show you can't please everyone, I guess.

Strangely enough, before Sunday and this season I was happily going along liking everyone well enough. (Except Lucius.....) My tendency to want to like everyone took a major hit and I've yet to recover.

I could be wrong, but I think most of fandom would be happy if E.T. visited Lucius.



*E.T. = exploding tumor

[parisindy]

I could be wrong, but I think most of fandom would be happy if E.T. visited Lucius.



*E.T. = exploding tumor

to bad one couldn't get sam and keller instead... you know i almost prefer lucius over them

sorry guys i'm in a bit of a ranty mood tonight....i think its the fact that
the slight hint from the oh so trust worthy PTB that...

Spoiler:

liz might come back

has everyone thinking everything will now be buttercups and butterflies and its driving me batty

[Pajus]

Do you mine if I use that? Will credit.

Go ahead

I am not fully anti, too, but I feel better here. I think this dividing between pro´s and anti´s is weird but it seems almost impossible to be "both". I don´t know...
I have never written anything into pro threads, but when I critisized something in episodes section, they yelled at me how wrong I am and that I shouldn´t watch.
It´s almost a crime to say something negative today. I wonder why? I sitll love this show but I don´t love it without limits. I am not blind and I don´t like some things. I don´t want to be a blind admirer who says that writers are doing an excellent job, that Teyla is perfectly written character or that Carter is better than Weir, when I see it´s not true. Or at least it is my opinion. When I looked last time, we have democracy and right to say our opinions, right?

If you have anything to complain about, you're more than free to do so here

I was told to take my opinion elsewhere since I responded to a poster stating Carson was in too many episodes last year by saying that Keller is in too many this one.

So here I am.

Down with Keller!!

I was among those, who gave Keller a fair chance, but after all the whining and letting Heightmeyer just lie there and die, my feelings about her are clear:

Well, this was my original verse to TPTB this time last year

*cough*

AN ODE FROM THE LEMMINGS

We are such funny creatures,
Mob-like some would say,
When certain people tick us off,
We always find a way.
To explain just how we’re feeling,
And show you all our might,
We’re not just little lemmings
Who give up without a fight.

Although we know so little,
A problem it can be,
When unruly lemmings go beserk,
A riot you will see.

Now I’m sure you don’t intend to hurt,
But it feels that way at times,
We’ll stick together through think and thin,
Even when we jump right in.
We watched and we cried when our poor Carson

Spoiler:

Died

With all of the lemmings, right by our side.

We ask that you not change the cast,
Or certainly it will be the last,
That some of us, the last you’ll see,
I’m imploring you now, the powers that be.

Thanks and goodnight

Much better than JM's poem if you asked me. Well, as far as my knowledge of statistics goes, at least 200,000 people feel the same way (even after I take Brian's beloved DVRs into account)

You told the truth, that's what's important. I don't hate Keller, but I find her somewhat annoying, and she's been given far too much screen time this season. If they want to highlight a recurring character, I vote for Zelenka.

Are you mad??? That would get him killed for certain!!!

Every time I see a car with a Czech license plate, I yell out loud - ZELENKA!!!

Please, never visit the Czech Republic. I have a feeling people would call Dr. Chocholousek on you

True he's probably not a draw for that demographic...but, really, is anyone anti-Zelenka? I suppose there must be, but I've not seen a thread against him or anything. So they should make everyone happy and let him have an episode devoted to him. But no character arcs, please.

I'm very bored at work...maybe I'll see if I can reach 100 posts this evening, to help celebrate over 10,000 for this thread.

I've never seen any anti-Zelenka posts at all. I have seen anti-Carson, but no anti-Zelenka

I could be wrong, but I think most of fandom would be happy if E.T. visited Lucius.



*E.T. = exploding tumor

to bad one couldn't get sam and keller instead... you know i almost prefer lucius over them

By what I know about TPTB, E.T. will visit either Zelenka or Chuck

[Pegasus_SGA]

{Mod Snip}

Go ahead

Much better than JM's poem if you asked me. Well, as far as my knowledge of statistics goes, at least 200,000 people feel the same way (even after I take Brian's beloved DVRs into account)

*takes a bow* Thanks I did a tonne of them, way back when, when the Lemming thread was in full swing. Thing is, I hope it shows that we're not that different. I did have strong reservations and was hurt with the cast changes just as much as everyone here. So many threads were opened when these changes were announced, and I personally thought it was too much too soon. People don't like change. I couldn't really imagine how I was going to like S4 with so many changes. I thought it wasn't going to be the same, hence the reasons I spent a lot of time playing on the Lemmings thread, but people change, circumstances change, and I know a lot more than I did at the beginning of last year.

[Reefgirl]

I'm sure it does. But i'm not the 'other side' i'm me! Just as when I talk to you or Inte, or Brian, or TOF, Killdear, Gregorious, Southern Red, Red Pheonix, Borgprincess, Celcool.... shall I go on? I see you, I speak to you. I could give a flying fig which side of the fence you sit on. I've never dismissed any of you for posting off topic or otherwise in any threads, be they on topic or off. I would hope that that same courtesy would be extended. I never call you names, never belittle your views or go post behind your backs. I never have and I never will, because that's not me. How others behave is down to them. You know me, and know how I post, where I post and come to the forum to interact with everyone. I don't dump you all in the same catagory, I see you all as individuals;

Maybe not but you red rep people for not sharing your love for the Sainted Sheppard

[Pegasus_SGA]

Maybe not but you red rep people for not sharing your love for the Sainted Sheppard

Actually I haven't, but thanks for playing! Maybe it was some other Shep fan you're thinking of, it's an easy mistake to make since we are all clones and think the same. If you want to know (though it is woefully off topic as is your post) I think i've redded one person in the history of my time in GW, and I know for a fact it had nothing to do with a retalitory red or for bashing Sheppard.

[Integrabyte]

Good morning ANTIS

Spoiler:

Dunno why, but I have that film in my head now...Charlie's Angels

I see you lot have been busy "loving" one another . Why doesn't JAbberjaws send his CV to replace Keller? Saw, Missing last night before I went to bed, and I got a killer headache .



Nothing compares to waking up and seeing some red in "my controls" . Ahh, the lovely taste of success

[Anuna]

It's the season of Capricorns, and we have few of them here - happy brithday to dana!!! I wish you better SGA episodes and less anti - ness Or if that doesn't work lots of joy with old seasons

[Reefgirl]

Actually I haven't, but thanks for playing! Maybe it was some other Shep fan you're thinking of, it's an easy mistake to make since we are all clones and think the same. If you want to know (though it is woefully off topic as is your post) I think i've redded one person in the history of my time in GW, and I know for a fact it had nothing to do with a retalitory red or for bashing Sheppard.

Fair enough, I'll be back when things calm down in Sniper Ally

[mcbarr]

oh! another song!!!

Fight the good fight by triumph! thats perfect for our list!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IImC_...eature=related

The Stinky Sock Mix - Volume 8

1. Queen - We Are The Champions
2. Triumph - Fight The Good Fight
3. Van Halen - Dreams
4. Tears For Fears - Sowing The Seeds Of Love
.
.
.

I took the liberty to add two more songs about Antis, TPTB and stuff.

It's the season of Capricorns, and we have few of them here - happy brithday to dana!!! I wish you better SGA episodes and less anti - ness Or if that doesn't work lots of joy with old seasons

Really?!

Happy Birthday Dana!!!

Fair enough, I'll be back when things calm down in Sniper Ally

Sorry, couldn't resist!

[marielabbott]

Are you mad??? That would get him killed for certain!!!

I did say no character arcs for Zelenka, because that really would get him killed. Hmm, but he has had a fair amount of screen time this year. Crap, now I'm scared.

[SPOILERS]Saw, Missing last night before I went to bed, and I got a killer headache .

That was my reaction too. *sends virtual Tylenol*

It's the season of Capricorns, and we have few of them here - happy brithday to dana!!! I wish you better SGA episodes and less anti - ness Or if that doesn't work lots of joy with old seasons

Ditto that, Happy Birthday, Dana!

[Skydiver]

Let's get your personal issues off the thread please.

[g.o.d]

Let's get your personal issues off the thread please.

or you will all burn in the fires of eternal damnation!!!