The Anti Season 4 Thread (Spoilers). For complaints and misgivings ONLY.

[Pajus]

Guess he will die next

Now I know how FH feels when we talk about Teyla getting her kill-off

[Falcon Horus]

Now I know how FH feels when we talk about Teyla getting her kill-off

It feels like crap... in my opinion anyway.

Oh, I have a question for those who have seen BAMSR... spoiler it or pm it:

Does Teyla reveal the pregnancy or is it still a mystery why she's twice her size already? Are TPTB still playing ignorant and let the boys be dense?

Then again I heard that's a "blink and you'll mist Teyla" episode. Well, what do you want with CGI-episodes.

[Integrabyte]

It feels like crap... in my opinion anyway.

Oh, I have a question for those who have seen BAMSR... spoiler it or pm it:

Does Teyla reveal the pregnancy or is it still a mystery why she's twice her size already? Are TPTB still playing ignorant and let the boys be dense?

Then again I heard that's a "blink and you'll mist Teyla" episode. Well, what do you want with CGI-episodes.

Spoiler:

She tells them but it was badly handled!

[g.o.d]

Spoiler:

She tells them but it was badly handled!

I still think Sheppard's reaction was very good

[mcbarr]

It feels like crap... in my opinion anyway.

Oh, I have a question for those who have seen BAMSR... spoiler it or pm it:

Does Teyla reveal the pregnancy or is it still a mystery why she's twice her size already? Are TPTB still playing ignorant and let the boys be dense?

Then again I heard that's a "blink and you'll mist Teyla" episode. Well, what do you want with CGI-episodes.

Sheppard was an ass, Ronon was the sensitive guy. Ah, the irony!

[Falcon Horus]

Spoiler:

She tells them but it was badly handled!

Oh great.... How else would they handle it, but badly. It's the norm these days.

<Mod snip....guys please, what part of 'don't quote the trolls isn't clear?>

[g.o.d]

Sheppard was an ass...

no, he wasn't. Teyla has been putting her child in constant risk. Sheppard was right

[mcbarr]

Something that has been bugging me... The first half of s4 had so many filler episodes, and TPTB choose to summarize the real story in one ep! I see at least three interesting episodes (if handled properly) in BAMSR:

Spoiler:

1. Human populated worlds continue to be attacked by Replicators; Apollo and Daedalus armed with Asgard weaponry join the fight and start killing Asuran warships in response under Atlantis supervision, ultimately forcing them to withdraw;

2. Mckay/Zelenka devise a plan to destroy the Replicators; Sheppard, Teyla, Ronon and their blue friend establish an unholy alliance with the Wraith and the Travelers to attack Asuras;

3. Alliance fleet (make it 50-60 ships FCOL!) attacks Asuras; fleet suffers heavy losses; McKay does his thing, and the "good guys" get the job done; RepliWeir lives.

What do you think? In my view, BAMSR was so shallow.

[justhere1971]

Sheppard was an ass, Ronon was the sensitive guy. Ah, the irony!

I think Sheppard could've used a little finesse, but .... (you knew there was a but ) it's his team member, and they're going on all these missions that could've put Teyla's pregnancy in danger. Yes, I know she's able to fend for herself, she's a warrior .... but he should've been told earlier to better prepare for it. Not an off hand remark, when pressured. I don't blame John for this one. Ronon was perfect - so he must be the next one gone. If they kill Dr. Z, another reason for me to stop watching all together.

[justhere1971]

Something that has been bugging me... The first half of s4 had so many filler episodes, and TPTB choose to summarize the real story in one ep! I see at least three interesting episodes (if handled properly) in BAMSR:

Spoiler:

1. Human populated worlds continue to be attacked by Replicators; Apollo and Daedalus armed with Asgard weaponry join the fight and start killing Asuran warships in response under Atlantis supervision, ultimately forcing them to withdraw;

2. Mckay/Zelenka devise a plan to destroy the Replicators; Sheppard, Teyla, Ronon and their blue friend establish an unholy alliance with the Wraith and the Travelers to attack Asuras;

3. Alliance fleet (make it 50-60 ships FCOL!) attacks Asuras; fleet suffers heavy losses; McKay does his thing, and the "good guys" get the job done; RepliWeir lives.

What do you think? In my view, BAMSR was so shallow.

I compared BAMSR to chugging a gallon of milk and throwing up

[Falcon Horus]

I think Sheppard could've used a little finesse, but .... (you knew there was a but ) it's his team member, and they're going on all these missions that could've put Teyla's pregnancy in danger. Yes, I know she's able to fend for herself, she's a warrior .... but he should've been told earlier to better prepare for it. Not an off hand remark, when pressured. I don't blame John for this one. Ronon was perfect - so he must be the next one gone. If they kill Dr. Z, another reason for me to stop watching all together.

If Sheppard's an ass about it, it's TPTB's fault. They should have done the telling sooner for it had gotten quite ridiculous. (just my opinion)

Okay, I'm going to watch BAMSR now... be back in 40 or so minutes, sooner if I decide not to wait till the end and just FF to the good part, the last 10 seconds.

[mcbarr]

If Sheppard's an ass about it, it's TPTB's fault.

It's always their fault.

[Pajus]

no, he wasn't. Teyla has been putting her child in constant risk. Sheppard was right

Sheppard was right, but he shouldn't have yelled at her. It's bad for the baby.

Something that has been bugging me... The first half of s4 had so many filler episodes, and TPTB choose to summarize the real story in one ep! I see at least three interesting episodes (if handled properly) in BAMSR:

Spoiler:

1. Human populated worlds continue to be attacked by Replicators; Apollo and Daedalus armed with Asgard weaponry join the fight and start killing Asuran warships in response under Atlantis supervision, ultimately forcing them to withdraw;

2. Mckay/Zelenka devise a plan to destroy the Replicators; Sheppard, Teyla, Ronon and their blue friend establish an unholy alliance with the Wraith and the Travelers to attack Asuras;

3. Alliance fleet (make it 50-60 ships FCOL!) attacks Asuras; fleet suffers heavy losses; McKay does his thing, and the "good guys" get the job done; RepliWeir lives.

What do you think? In my view, BAMSR was so shallow.

That would've been good. Not even the Worshippers of the Holy TPTB will convince me that

Spoiler:

7 hives, the Apollo, the Daedalus, Larrin's Aurora and four Traveller ships had any chance of holding off 30 fully armed and operational Aurora class battleships. In fact, I'm having a hard time believing they would've survived for more than 15 seconds

I compared BAMSR to chugging a gallon of milk and throwing up

I'd pay good money to see JM doing that

[justhere1971]

{Mod Snip}

Maybe Shep's mind was addled by Larri?

[Integrabyte]

Maybe Shep's mind was addled by Larri?

It was more frustration than Larrin. He reacted as a protector and felt offended that Teyla did not think he deserves to know. Teyla should have told them under different circumstances, something like TMC or an episode with less things than BAMSR