Happy Birthday Falcon Horus!!!
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
The Anti Season 4 Thread (Spoilers). For complaints and misgivings ONLY.
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
Originally posted by mcbarr View PostJust watched BAMSR through alternative means. There are so many things wrong with this episode that I don't even know how to put it into words.Stolen Kosovo
sigpic
Comment
-
Originally posted by mcbarr View PostJust watched BAMSR through alternative means. There are so many things wrong with this episode that I don't even know how to put it into words.
Originally posted by g.o.d View Postfor example Auroras don't use shieldsSpoiler:Wraith hives not being blown up in a matter of seconds, Ellis and Caldwell not using the opportunity to beam down assault teams to get themselves some ZPMs,...
Comment
-
Did anyone notice the huge stab in the back they gave Weir before Caldwell and Ellis beamed down?
Rodney: "Both ships at the same time, this is a first"
Carter:"First time we've needed them"
Sheppard and Rodney look at her weird
Carter:"...well...since I've been here....
Fran was cute. Anyone got her number? I don't think she'll mind if a hot shark calls her
Comment
-
Originally posted by dana View PostI think your sig says it really well.True, but let me try anyway:
1. Too much stuff packed into a single episode;
2. The Apollo and the Daedalus should have been killing Asuran ships throughout the first half of the season, not just this episode;
3. Technobabble crapfest;
4. No major ethical debate over creating a sentient lifeform, and using it as a weapon;
5. One episode the Asurans are the undisputed rulers of PG, the next they're weak little babies who can't defend themselves;
6. Asuran homeworld and ships had no proper shielding/drones. WTF!!!
7. No Oberoth;
8. Deus ex machina solution. *yawn*
In short, everything was too convenient and superficial! Some characters felt OOC, especially Sheppard and McKay. Needless to say, I didn't like what they did to Dr. Weir, nor the amount of screen time she got.
Just to remind you, O'Neill, a chair and a bunch of drones defeated Anubis fleet easily.sigpic
Comment
-
I have a scary theory as to why TPTB haven't said who's on board for s5 yet. When talking about the finale Last Man, Joe M. saidSpoiler:"I joined Marty G. and Paul for a special screening of 'The Last Man' director's cut. A great season-ender (and a bit of a tearjerker -- I defy you not to cry or feel sad or pity or slightly dizzy) with a final shot that will have fandom buzzing from final fade to the opening shot of season five."
So...could that mean thatSpoiler:a main cast member will die in that ep, therefore the actor is not signed onto s5 and TPTB are keeping that quiet?
Comment
Comment