The Anti Season 4 Thread (Spoilers). For complaints and misgivings ONLY.

[Falcon Horus]

Talking about ships, have they explained what the heck happened to the Tria yet?

The who of the what?

[Madeleine]

why? we aren't pro's who love reporting other people

Maybe you (plural) aren't pros who love reporting, but you (singular) are a person who is getting in sly digs. Stop, please.

I get as many reports from pros as antis. There are troublemakers from both groups, and the decent members of each group are reporting those troublemakers. 'Sides' is irrelevant.

[mcbarr]

The who of the what?

What?

[Falcon Horus]

What?

Exactly.

[Luz]

What's the Tria? I don't remember which episode it's from, I wonder if someday the same thing that happened with BSG will happen with Atlantis and I'll forget about everything, even the names of the characters.

Though I doubt I'll ever forget about Sheppard, Weir or McKay, they'll be like Apollo and Starbuck, forever ingrained on my mind.

[parisindy]

[mcbarr]

What's the Tria? I don't remember which episode it's from, I wonder if someday the same thing that happened with BSG will happen with Atlantis and I'll forget about everything, even the names of the characters.

Though I doubt I'll ever forget about Sheppard, Weir or McKay, they'll be like Apollo and Starbuck, forever ingrained on my mind.

It's an Ancient warship introduced in The Return - Part 1:

Tria

Her fate remains a mystery. Some say she fell in a plot hole.

LOL!

[Luz]

It's an Ancient warship introduced in The Return - Part 1:

Tria

Her fate remains a mystery. Some say she fell in a plot hole.

LOL, characters keep falling on it too, Gates, Ford, Weir, Cadman, Tha Return was a good episode, and the third season could have been great, had it not been for what a BHBOS some (most) of the episodes from the second half were.

[parisindy]

LOL!

[mcbarr]

LOL, characters keep falling on it too, Gates, Ford, Weir, Cadman, Tha Return was a good episode, and the third season could have been great, had it not been for what a BHBOS some (most) of the episodes from the second half were.

Yeah, things started going downhill back then (ratings included), but the show was watchable 'cause it still had some shred of identity. Now...

[Luz]

Yeah, things started going downhill back then (ratings included), but the show was watchable 'cause it still had some shred of identity. Now...

There were some episodes that were not so watchable, like Irresponsible, the Ark and Sunday, and there is Submersion and Vengeance, and the Return 2 (O'neill just ruined that episode for me). In a nutshell, the only episodes I liked from 3.5 were Tao of Rodney and the Game, was Echoes from the second or first half?

Speaking of ratings, I can't wait to see how bad the ratings for the second half are (hoping they're even worse than those of the first half, though I know, but it can be done ), and the best will be the spinning, good laughing material.

[Ruined_puzzle]

There were some episodes that were not so watchable, like Irresponsible, the Ark and Sunday, and there is Submersion and Vengeance, and the Return 2 (O'neill just ruined that episode for me). In a nutshell, the only episodes I liked from 3.5 were Tao of Rodney and the Game, was Echoes from the second or first half?

Speaking of ratings, I can't wait to see how bad the ratings for the second half are (hoping they're even worse than those of the first half, though I know, but it can be done ), and the best will be the spinning, good laughing material.

Echoes was in the second half. I think s3 could have been the best season ever if it would have continued the awesomeness of the first half. Let's see the first half had Sateda, Progeny, The Real World, Common Ground, The Return. People seemed to love Mckay and Mrs. Millar, I didn't, but I'll add it to the list of awesome then it just started to suck. I will never stop laughing at the cheap rewind method they used in The Return II.

[mcbarr]

There were some episodes that were not so watchable, like Irresponsible, the Ark and Sunday, and there is Submersion and Vengeance, and the Return 2 (O'neill just ruined that episode for me). In a nutshell, the only episodes I liked from 3.5 were Tao of Rodney and the Game, was Echoes from the second or first half?

Yes, Echo is 3.5. Fine exception.

Speaking of ratings, I can't wait to see how bad the ratings for the second half are (hoping they're even worse than those of the first half, though I know, but it can be done ), and the best will be the spinning, good laughing material.

If the trend continues..., but yeah, the spinning is the best part.

[Luz]

Echoes was in the second half. I think s3 could have been the best season ever if it would have continued the awesomeness of the first half. Let's see the first half had Sateda, Progeny, The Real World, Common Ground, The Return. People seemed to love Mckay and Mrs. Millar, I didn't, but I'll add it to the list of awesome then it just started to suck. I will never stop laughing at the cheap rewind method they used in The Return II.

Well, then add Echoes to the episodes I liked from the second half, the first half of season three was awesome, Common Ground and Sateda were two of the best episodes of the entire show.

Take any from that trash that is season 4, compare them to the best of season three or one and they won't stand a chance, it'll only showcase the immeasurable suckitude that is season 4, it's not even the same show anymore.

The rewind thingy from the Return 2 was simply ridiculous and a cheap plot device, it was dumb and the Return 2 was a horrible follow up to a wonderful cliffie like the Return. And don't even get me started on what a waste of an action sequence it was to have O'neill doing that underwater scene, it should have been Sheppard, I don't care for seeing the clown O'neill playing hero, I can't take him seriously, and WTF?! IT-WAS-ATLANTIS!, I'm sure people from SG1 would have been thrilled to have that man on their show, why did I have to suffer when I wanted to watch SGA, not SG1: Atlantis.

[mcbarr]

Every SG-1 character who sets foot on Atlantis looks tired and out of place. It is inevitable.