The Anti Season 4 Thread (Spoilers). For complaints and misgivings ONLY.

[Trialia]

*nips in* Yes, we rock. And anyone who says otherwise is just jealous.

Lizzie icons, because I made them for the Save Elizabeth campaign and I figure that makes them suitable here, right?

[Irish Eyes]

totally snurched the name thanks! hope you don't mind!

Don't mind a bit!

Lost Expedition:

- Beckett doesn't die on Sunday;
- Weir is not seriously injured on First Strike;
- No Sam/Keller;
- Atlantis is stranded in space after dodging Asuran attack (First Strike);
- McKay finds a way to dial the gate in deep space, thus allowing the expedition to evacuate the city to a safe planet;
- Atlantis is presumably captured by the Asurans;
- All communications with Earth are severed, thus Lost Expedition ;
- The expedition has to use its skills to survive in PG (everyone is useful again/enemies are dangerous again);
- Show's objective: reclaim Atlantis and reestablish contact with Earth someday.

What do you think?

I think this sounds like something I would like to see on tv...

I would SO like to pull the wings off the little "reset" fairy.......

Oooo! Me too! Can I help?

Yep. You distract it, I'll club it over the head with a martini glass, knock it senseless, and then we'll each yank a wing off.

*steps on it for good measure*

AND THE SITE IS UP! thanks to the wonderful work of Falcon Horus! ((hugs))

Here you go everyone!
http://community.livejournal.com/atl...?view=268#t268
LET THE POSTING BEGIN!

please also support
celcool's anti site
http://antistargate.s4.bizhat.com/

Sounds like a lot of fun!

[parisindy]

*nips in* Yes, we rock. And anyone who says otherwise is just jealous.

Lizzie icons, because I made them for the Save Elizabeth campaign and I figure that makes them suitable here, right?

[http://www.unfaithful-mirror.net/images/icons/Stargate_Atlantis/weir-141.jpg[/img] ]http://www.unfaithful-mirror.net/images/icons/Stargate_Atlantis/weir-142.jpg[/img] http://www.unfaithful-mirror.net/images/icons/Stargate_Atlantis/weir-143.jpg[/img] http://www.unfaithful-mirror.net/images/icons/Stargate_Atlantis/weir-144.jpg[/img] http://www.unfaithful-mirror.net/images/icons/Stargate_Atlantis/weir-145.jpg[/img]

oh awesome can we snurch?

Sounds like a lot of fun!

I hope so!

[YappiChick]

I've gotta quick question...

If there are some (and I'm willing to help too) who do want to write an AU season four...do you think we should "rewrite" the ending to Sunday and write alternative storylines for "First Strike" that way people who stumble into our safe haven for Carson and Elizabeth know what happened? Or should we ignore the fact that those episodes happened in the first place?

[parisindy]

I've gotta quick question...

If there are some (and I'm willing to help too) who do want to write an AU season four...do you think we should "rewrite" the ending to Sunday and write alternative storylines for "First Strike" that way people who stumble into our safe haven for Carson and Elizabeth know what happened? Or should we ignore the fact that those episodes happened in the first place?

gosh good question... i think i would rewrite sunday and pretend FS didn't happen

but its up to you guys...

You should post the question on the LJ site to

[Anuna]

I'd rewrite both Sunday and FS (and end FS a bit differently then it did),my question is do we want pregnant Teyla going darker?

We could make all of them bit darker, change their dynammics (create some new conflicts and something like that in this new situation) in odred to bring them closer together, which could work out good thanx to the afct they'll be lost. (Too much of Battlestar Galactica? Nah)

How about them trying to make it back to Atlantis' original planet?

[Trialia]

Yes, Paris, they can be snurched. Just credit back, that's all I ask- I'm Trinity1986 on LJ and Trialia on IJ/JF.

[Celcool]

Lost Expedition:

- Beckett doesn't die on Sunday;
- Weir is not seriously injured on First Strike;
- No Sam/Keller;
- Atlantis is stranded in space after dodging Asuran attack (First Strike);
- McKay finds a way to dial the gate in deep space, thus allowing the expedition to evacuate the city to a safe planet;
- Atlantis is presumably captured by the Asurans;
- All communications with Earth are severed, thus Lost Expedition ;
- The expedition has to use its skills to survive in PG (everyone is useful again/enemies are dangerous again);
- Show's objective: reclaim Atlantis and reestablish contact with Earth someday.

What do you think?

I think you should take over Mallozi's job.

[Southern Red]

I'd rewrite both Sunday and FS (and end FS a bit differently then it did),my question is do we want pregnant Teyla going darker?

We could make all of them bit darker, change their dynammics (create some new conflicts and something like that in this new situation) in odred to bring them closer together, which could work out good thanx to the afct they'll be lost. (Too much of Battlestar Galactica? Nah)

How about them trying to make it back to Atlantis' original planet?

I like the idea of rewrites. That shows how much better you guys can do it than the original writers. FS had some great character moments.

Spoiler:

The office scene with John, Rodney and Elizabeth about writing the personnel evaluations was priceless. And I even like the rift between John and Elizbeth. There was good drama potential there. Heck, most of you will probably stone me, but I don't think you need to change a thing except to bring back Carson. Just write Adrift so she recovers, continue with the effort to find a place to land and move on.

As for the Teyla story, I love the idea of her going darker, but I'd drop the pregnancy and make her a wraith queen. Talk about getting in touch with your roots. Then she would have some great scenes as the newest enemy of her former friends. Imagine what her team would do with that. They not only have to deal with finding a new home, but Teyla knows all their secrets and if you bring Michael into the mix you've got yourselves an interesting situation. Just my thoughts.

[mcbarr]

I think you should take over Mallozi's job.

Nah, I don't want anyone to be fired. Just bring SGA back as it is supposed to be.

As for the Teyla story, I love the idea of her going darker, but I'd drop the pregnancy and make her a wraith queen. Talk about getting in touch with your roots. Then she would have some great scenes as the newest enemy of her former friends. Imagine what her team would do with that. They not only have to deal with finding a new home, but Teyla knows all their secrets and if you bring Michael into the mix you've got yourselves an interesting situation. Just my thoughts.

Sounds quite interesting indeed.

[Falcon Horus]

I'd love to join in, in the whole AU thing...but I'd keep it as close to the show as possible but without killing characters and bringing certain others. We write our own season 4 without Carter, Keller ... but with Beckett alive and kicking, and Elizabeth at the helm...

[Anuna]

I like the idea of rewrites. That shows how much better you guys can do it than the original writers. FS had some great character moments.

Spoiler:

The office scene with John, Rodney and Elizabeth about writing the personnel evaluations was priceless. And I even like the rift between John and Elizbeth. There was good drama potential there. Heck, most of you will probably stone me, but I don't think you need to change a thing except to bring back Carson. Just write Adrift so she recovers, continue with the effort to find a place to land and move on.

As for the Teyla story, I love the idea of her going darker, but I'd drop the pregnancy and make her a wraith queen. Talk about getting in touch with your roots. Then she would have some great scenes as the newest enemy of her former friends. Imagine what her team would do with that. They not only have to deal with finding a new home, but Teyla knows all their secrets and if you bring Michael into the mix you've got yourselves an interesting situation. Just my thoughts.

It was already done. But I think we could do something similar, yet not all the same. I agree with you... like I always do; hon' have we been borg'ed??

[justhere1971]

I like the idea of rewrites. That shows how much better you guys can do it than the original writers. FS had some great character moments.

Spoiler:

The office scene with John, Rodney and Elizabeth about writing the personnel evaluations was priceless. And I even like the rift between John and Elizbeth. There was good drama potential there. Heck, most of you will probably stone me, but I don't think you need to change a thing except to bring back Carson. Just write Adrift so she recovers, continue with the effort to find a place to land and move on.

As for the Teyla story, I love the idea of her going darker, but I'd drop the pregnancy and make her a wraith queen. Talk about getting in touch with your roots. Then she would have some great scenes as the newest enemy of her former friends. Imagine what her team would do with that. They not only have to deal with finding a new home, but Teyla knows all their secrets and if you bring Michael into the mix you've got yourselves an interesting situation. Just my thoughts.

ITA!!! That's how it should've been done.

[Reefgirl]

Ok, I can't be @ssed to read the backlog so forgive me if this has been said before.

S3 was cr@p and if that trend continues, which it looks like doing I'm afraid, they should kill it off now. I don't mind seeing Sam Carter take over as Weir got on my and I'll hope against hope that she will save the show. What will really make me switch off in series 4 will be if the show becomes Stargate Atlantis: The John and Rodney Show, this really got up my nose last year along with the poor quality writing and a combination of those two will make me not bother watching to see if it's getting any better, I did enough of that last year and I'm certainly not going to bother with the DVD boxset, that money's already been spent on series 1 of Torchwood. Can you imagine what Atlantis would have been like if writers of the calibre of Stephen Moffat and Paul Cornell got hold of it? even Russel T Davis, at least John and Rodney would have got a snog out of it

Time put Atlantis out of it's misery I'm afraid

[Southern Red]

It was already done. But I think we could do something similar, yet not all the same. I agree with you... like I always do; hon' have we been borg'ed??

Resistance is futile.