Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Favorite episode(s) of season 3 (overall) Spoilers

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Favorite episode(s) of season 3 (overall) Spoilers

    my traditional season ending thread

    Favorite episode(s) of season 3 (overall) all 20 please list the episode you liked and why you liked them.


    No Man's Land
    Misbegotten
    Irresistible
    Sateda
    Progeny
    The Real World
    Common Ground
    McKay and Mrs. Miller
    Phantoms
    The Return, Part 1

    The Return, Part 2
    Echoes
    Irresponsible
    Tao of Rodney
    The Game
    The Ark
    Sunday
    Submersion
    Vengeance
    First Strike
    --------------------------------------------
    mine are ...pretty much all of them IMO it was a really solid season.

    stand outs

    Sateda,no mans land,tao of Rodney,return 1-2, first strike

    have fun
    110
    No Man's Land
    0.00%
    0
    Misbegotten
    0.00%
    0
    Irresistable
    0.00%
    0
    Sateda
    7.27%
    8
    Progeny
    0.00%
    0
    The Real World
    15.45%
    17
    Common Ground
    28.18%
    31
    McKay and Mrs Miller
    6.36%
    7
    Phantoms
    4.55%
    5
    The Return pt 1
    1.82%
    2
    The Return pt 2
    5.45%
    6
    Echoes
    8.18%
    9
    Irresponsible
    0.91%
    1
    Tao of Rodney
    10.00%
    11
    The Game
    0.00%
    0
    The Ark
    0.00%
    0
    Sunday
    4.55%
    5
    Submersion
    0.00%
    0
    Vengeance
    0.00%
    0
    First Strike
    7.27%
    8
    https://twitter.com/#!/Solar_wind84

    #2
    No Man's Land was a great opener, great SFX and character moments.

    Sateda was very cinematic, and shed some light on Ronan's history.

    Progeny was a great intro for the Asurans, and once again, great team moments.

    Common Ground was seriously shocking at times, and we got more layers to the Wraith than ever before.

    McKay and Mrs. Miller was heart breaking; the ending makes me tear up everytime I watch it (and I've done that about 6 times now).

    The Return (both parts) had, again, great team moments, and I loved how they resolved the whole thing with that flash back...thing. Of course, there was great banter between O'Neill and Woosey

    Sunday was just excellent drama. I'll miss Carson, but IMHO he had one of the most meaningful deaths in the 2 shows. Besides that, there were a huge amount of character moments that I'll cherish.

    First Strike was just kick-assedly awesome, there is no way around that.

    Comment


      #3
      I decided the moment after seeing it that The Real World was my favorite thus far, and after watching the rest of the season out I think I am going to leave it on top. Elizabeth is my favorite character and it was just such a great episode for her.

      Following though in a close second I think would have to be First Strike. Awesome episode all around, possibly the best season finale I've seen.

      Comment


        #4
        Common Ground and Phantoms. Though Echoes was great, too... Oh, man, there were lots of good epis in season 3! But I think, my favourites are still the two mentionned above. If I had to make a list, I'd say:

        1.: Common Ground and Phantoms
        2.: The return Part 2 and Echoes
        3.: The game and The return Part 1
        4.: Sateda and First strike
        5.: McKay and Mrs. Miller and No Man's Land
        6.: The real World
        7.: Tao of Rodney
        8.: Sunday
        9.: Submersion
        10.: Progeny
        11.: The Ark and Misbegotten
        12.: Vengeance
        13.: Irresistible and Irresponsible

        Comment


          #5
          No Man's Land - Ehh.
          Misbegotten - Erm...
          Irresistible - What?
          Sateda - Eh.
          Progeny - Ugh.
          The Real World - Gwah.
          Common Ground - Yay?
          McKay and Mrs. Miller - Wee.
          Phantoms - Okay.
          The Return, Part 1 - Blech...

          The Return, Part 2 - Augh!
          Echoes - Seriously?
          Irresponsible - Oh dear...
          Tao of Rodney - Yay!
          The Game - Eh.
          The Ark - x_x
          Sunday - Wooooo--! aaauughghghhhhaa
          Submersion - Okay.
          Vengeance - -_____-
          First Strike - Nice!

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by AutumnDream View Post
            No Man's Land - Ehh.
            Misbegotten - Erm...
            Irresistible - What?
            Sateda - Eh.
            Progeny - Ugh.
            The Real World - Gwah.
            Common Ground - Yay?
            McKay and Mrs. Miller - Wee.
            Phantoms - Okay.
            The Return, Part 1 - Blech...

            The Return, Part 2 - Augh!
            Echoes - Seriously?
            Irresponsible - Oh dear...
            Tao of Rodney - Yay!
            The Game - Eh.
            The Ark - x_x
            Sunday - Wooooo--! aaauughghghhhhaa
            Submersion - Okay.
            Vengeance - -_____-
            First Strike - Nice!
            Not a big season 3 fan, are we?

            As for meself, I thought... Real World, Phantoms, Return 1 & 2, Echoes, Tao of Rodney, Sunday and First Striek were all brilliant; No MAn's Land, Misbegotten, Common Ground and Progency excellent, yet somewhat less brillaint; Sateda, McKay and Mrs Miller, The Game and The Ark reasonable, and Irresistable, Irresponsible, Submersion and Vengeance horrid.
            Quite a lot better than season 2
            Pinky, are you thinking what I'm thinking?
            Yes, I am!
            sigpic
            Improved and unfuzzy banner being the result of more of Caldwell's 2IC sick, yet genuis, mind.
            Help Pitry win a competition! Listen to Kula Shaker's new single
            Peter Pan R.I.P

            Comment


              #7
              Common Ground - Strong acting, full of emotion, good philosophical-like dialog, especially the Wraith.
              Sateda - Strong acting, full of emotion plus allot of cowboy action from Ronan

              * Both the above episodes had a similar idea but unique in their own way. One man stuck in hostile ground being tortured/hunted and apparently with no escape. Brilliantly done (Reminded me a bit of Abyss).

              Plus:

              McKay and Mrs. Miller - The brother sister relationship.
              Vengeance - Micheal and his army of Super-Wraith. Reminds me of Anubis (and Alien + Predetor ). Hope he becomes really powerful in the Pegasus Galaxy one day.
              First Strike - Well, the Special Effects.

              PS: Probably noticed I am not a big fan of the Asurans

              Comment


                #8
                My favourite episodes are:
                Common Ground
                Echoes
                Sateda
                First Strike
                Return I
                Tao of Rodney
                Edit: Forgot Sunday!!! It was awesome!!!!

                I liked all the others, except Irresponsible and The Real World. They were my least favourite episodes by a long way.
                Last edited by Linzi; February 7, 2007, 06:19 AM.
                sigpic

                Comment


                  #9
                  Common Ground for the Shep whumping.
                  Tao of Rodney and Sunday for the touchy-feely stuff.
                  McKay and Mrs Miller for Alternate Rod(ney).
                  The Return for the teamwork.
                  First Strike for general awesomeness.

                  Forgot to say Irresponsible was my least fave, for two reasons: Lucius (obviously) and the completely pointless and stupid offing of Kolya.
                  sigpic
                  "Ce qui ressemble a l'amour est toujours de l'amour." - Tristan Bernard

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by Pitry View Post
                    Not a big season 3 fan, are we?
                    Just to provide some context:

                    Rising, Part 1 - Woo!
                    Rising, Part 2 - Sweet!
                    Hide and Seek - Cool.
                    Thirty Eight Minutes - Eek. o_O
                    Suspicion - Nice.
                    Childhood's End - La la laaa.
                    Poisoning the Well - ^_^
                    Underground - Interesting!
                    Home - Woah, cool.
                    The Storm - Omg!

                    The Eye - Zomg!
                    The Defiant One - Creepy. >_>
                    Hot Zone - Intriguing!
                    Sanctuary - Huh?
                    Before I Sleep - I love this show.
                    The Brotherhood - Okay.
                    Letters From Pegasus - LOLZ!
                    The Gift - Kickarse!
                    The Siege, Part 1 - *is captivated*
                    The Siege, Part 2 - NOOOO SEASON 1 DON'T GO AWAY!!!

                    Comment


                      #11
                      No Man's Land - quite interesting
                      Misbegotten - boring
                      Irresistible - What the heck was that???
                      Sateda - Ronon's matrix-fighting was boring
                      Progeny - nice
                      The Real World - didn't see it(I doubt I will ever see this episode)
                      Common Ground - probably the best in the third season for me
                      McKay and Mrs. Miller - good one
                      Phantoms - boring
                      The Return, Part 1 - first 15 minutes were very good, the rest was boring

                      The Return, Part 2 - qiute good
                      Echoes - good one
                      Irresponsible - what the heck was that??
                      Tao of Rodney - good one
                      The Game - Eh.
                      The Ark - silly and borind
                      Sunday - I was expecting more
                      Submersion - Okay.
                      Vengeance - good one
                      First Strike - excelent CGI, the rest was very boring and predictable

                      overall:Third season sucks.I really didn't enjoy it
                      Stolen Kosovo
                      sigpic

                      Comment


                        #12
                        I loved season 3. There was a few that let it down, but I think it has been great overall. My favourites are:

                        Sateda
                        Progeny
                        Common Ground
                        McKay and Mrs Miller
                        The Return I
                        The Return II
                        Echoes
                        Sunday
                        Vengeance
                        First Strike

                        The ones I didn't like:

                        Irresistable
                        Phantoms
                        Irresponsible

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by AutumnDream View Post
                          Just to provide some context:

                          Rising, Part 1 - Woo!
                          Rising, Part 2 - Sweet!
                          Hide and Seek - Cool.
                          Thirty Eight Minutes - Eek. o_O
                          Suspicion - Nice.
                          Childhood's End - La la laaa.
                          Poisoning the Well - ^_^
                          Underground - Interesting!
                          Home - Woah, cool.
                          The Storm - Omg!

                          The Eye - Zomg!
                          The Defiant One - Creepy. >_>
                          Hot Zone - Intriguing!
                          Sanctuary - Huh?
                          Before I Sleep - I love this show.
                          The Brotherhood - Okay.
                          Letters From Pegasus - LOLZ!
                          The Gift - Kickarse!
                          The Siege, Part 1 - *is captivated*
                          The Siege, Part 2 - NOOOO SEASON 1 DON'T GO AWAY!!!
                          Hahaha, yes s1 is still the best.

                          Favorites of s3
                          The Real World- Still my favorite. Elizabeth, John and angst. LOVE.
                          Echoes- WHALES!!! SAM!! actually original and interesting. Carl Binder is love.
                          Common Ground- Shep whump, Team angst, OMGWTFBBQ at the end. Can we have this wraith back. KOYLA!!!
                          Tao of Rodney- Rodney was cute and I loved his interactions with everyone.
                          Sateda- Ronon is awesome and yeah I love him.
                          Progeny- Fakeout and I believed it. Elizabeth was awesome and some ancient backstory.
                          sigpic
                          My OTP's LEAP with passion. Weir did it better.

                          Comment


                            #14
                            i for one love atlantis and i loved this season overall. there were however a few episoeds that were not so good and i hope will not be revisited. oh and please for the love of god no more lucius

                            • No Man's Land- excellent opener, orion kick ass, deddy kick ass, micheal, 10/10
                            • Misbegotten- hive ship cool, having to bomb the planet dark, overall plot kinda boring though 6/10
                            • Irresistible- lucius = balls 2/10
                            • Sateda- ronon back story, wraith king??, carson killing the wraith 8/10
                            • Progeny- excellent cgi, new villian, replictors! 9/10
                            • The Real World- rda yay, kinda boring though not a weir fan and with no action or other character arcs in the ep i have to give a 4/10
                            • Common Ground- sheppard fed on, gift of life, wraith insight, genii, koyila 9/10
                            • McKay and Mrs. Miller- cool new type of story worked really well, liked mkay's sister, good humor, carter, alt universe, new part of atlantis. 8/10
                            • Phantoms- good shep back story, felt kinda filler though 6/10
                            • The Return, Part 1- replicators, ancients ,oneill 9/10
                            • The Return, Part 2- excellent cgi, oneill in the water!, pj out flying drones 10/10
                            • Echoes- wasnt much of a fan of this ep apart from deddy at the end that was cool. 6/10
                            • Irresponsible- luicuis = balls 2/10
                            • Tao of Rodney- brilliant ep, great humor, great drama, love mkay 9/10
                            • The Game- good humor, some nice teck, good story but not ground breaking 6/10
                            • The Ark- nice idea, cool new set and cgi however was again a tad bit boring and fillery. 6/10
                            • Sunday- loved this ep made me realise what a cool guy carson was, great finial scenes and loves davids acting showing how much mckay missed carson. 9/10
                            • Submersion- cool new teck etc, wraith! 8/10
                            • Vengeance- micheal was good but those bug things looked like putty monsters from power rangers just not menacing at all. 6/10
                            • First Strike- apollo, ellis, atlantis flying, asurans, horizon excellent ep 9/10


                            my season summary would be less stand alone eps and more story arcs. more cool cgi, no more lucius, more development of the wraith and assurans its nice to have two enemys kinda varies things

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by AutumnDream View Post
                              Just to provide some context:

                              Rising, Part 1 - Woo!
                              Rising, Part 2 - Sweet!
                              Hide and Seek - Cool.
                              Thirty Eight Minutes - Eek. o_O
                              Suspicion - Nice.
                              Childhood's End - La la laaa.
                              Poisoning the Well - ^_^
                              Underground - Interesting!
                              Home - Woah, cool.
                              The Storm - Omg!

                              The Eye - Zomg!
                              The Defiant One - Creepy. >_>
                              Hot Zone - Intriguing!
                              Sanctuary - Huh?
                              Before I Sleep - I love this show.
                              The Brotherhood - Okay.
                              Letters From Pegasus - LOLZ!
                              The Gift - Kickarse!
                              The Siege, Part 1 - *is captivated*
                              The Siege, Part 2 - NOOOO SEASON 1 DON'T GO AWAY!!!
                              LoL, thought so.
                              I thought season 1 was ncie, but I wasn't overly excited by it. The second half arc was good, but I thought it had too many problems - that just became more apparent come season 2 and it's general "eurgh" feeling. But I love season 3. I think SGA was finally made a r eal show this year.

                              ...btu that's me
                              Pinky, are you thinking what I'm thinking?
                              Yes, I am!
                              sigpic
                              Improved and unfuzzy banner being the result of more of Caldwell's 2IC sick, yet genuis, mind.
                              Help Pitry win a competition! Listen to Kula Shaker's new single
                              Peter Pan R.I.P

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X