Originally posted by YappiChick
View Post
It's just that...
Spoiler:
As an Athosian, she understand the dangers of living in a dangerous world. This issue was already addressed in Quarantine. She's obviously not been communicating with John, her team captain, about returning (hence the confusion in the beginning).
Think about it John's way. He wants her to stay on the team. Woolsey is telling him to pick someone else. I think it was him being upset that he felt like he was trapped in a corner.
Unfortunately, that came from Teyla not making a decision.
Had Ronon not been captured how long would it have taken her to make a decision? To me, her character has never been one to "sit back and let other people fight for me" so her struggle seemed out of place. That's just my .02.
Think about it John's way. He wants her to stay on the team. Woolsey is telling him to pick someone else. I think it was him being upset that he felt like he was trapped in a corner.
Unfortunately, that came from Teyla not making a decision.
Had Ronon not been captured how long would it have taken her to make a decision? To me, her character has never been one to "sit back and let other people fight for me" so her struggle seemed out of place. That's just my .02.
Spoiler:
Yeah but we know since Reunion that she always had a doubt if leaving her people was a good choice and they disappear she feels that it was her fault. John feels the same everytime but he is harsh on his leader his team is always here to support him. This is not the same for Teyla she's exactly in the same case than John except that in this case it's John the leader so it's normal she's angry after him. I think she was in a difficult situation chooses between a new life or an old make the same faults (in letting her people and now her baby) or fighting for their security. We saw her risks her people and herself if I can say for Charrin funeral but it was their custom their choices. The road was right here she had choices and even if she had stayed with her people it wasn't for someone to survey her but to protect her people the better she can IMO I think it was a continuity of all even quarantine now the baby is a reality and a new one to take care. All the people that she knows risk their life everyday so to who could she gives him ?
Originally posted by Linda06
View Post
Spoiler:
But it just seems everyone is laying the blame squarely on her shoulders...I mean who can blame her for wanting to do the right thing for her child and her people....
I mean she just got them back and she's a new mum,i can't really blame her for struggling to figure out what to do..
And i can understand why she was angry at Shep for not telling her about the mission to rescue Ronon.....Like i said if it was any other mission i would understand John's frustration but this was Ronon,the closest thing she has to a brother and i don't know about anyone else but if it was me i'd do anything to save my brother....If it was the other way about i think John would be seriously pissed too!
I mean she just got them back and she's a new mum,i can't really blame her for struggling to figure out what to do..
And i can understand why she was angry at Shep for not telling her about the mission to rescue Ronon.....Like i said if it was any other mission i would understand John's frustration but this was Ronon,the closest thing she has to a brother and i don't know about anyone else but if it was me i'd do anything to save my brother....If it was the other way about i think John would be seriously pissed too!
Originally posted by Linda06
View Post
Spoiler:
Well like i said this was Ronon we're talking about.....Why couldn't he have brought it up after they rescued Ronon.....How would John have felt if they went on a mission to try save Ronon without him.....He wouldn't have been happy at all..
Well i wasn't that happy with the Teyla stortline in S4 and some of the writing either but i think it's improved greatly so far for her in S5..
Well if it's jealousy that's spurring him on he's got no right to take it out on Teyla...He didn't tell her how he felt so who can blame her for moving on with her life,he has just got to face the facts that Teyla has found someone else and move on..
I don't place any of the blame on Teyla either...
Guess i'm the only one on this forum at the moment on Teyla's side on this...Everyone else seems to be blaming her for everything
Maybe i should take a break for a while!
Well i wasn't that happy with the Teyla stortline in S4 and some of the writing either but i think it's improved greatly so far for her in S5..
Well if it's jealousy that's spurring him on he's got no right to take it out on Teyla...He didn't tell her how he felt so who can blame her for moving on with her life,he has just got to face the facts that Teyla has found someone else and move on..
I don't place any of the blame on Teyla either...
Guess i'm the only one on this forum at the moment on Teyla's side on this...Everyone else seems to be blaming her for everything
Maybe i should take a break for a while!
Spoiler:
Hey if they were gone without Shep it would have been the worst thing of the show everybody would be screaming and crying that Shep is the show and it's a shame that we let him down alone with a baby and his people to take care and alone with nobody to help him take a decision and with harsh people screaming at him and all his friend letting him lol. Yeah Ronon needed someone to help him but as for Critical Mass I think Teyla needed someone and it's sad for us JT but I think the one was Kanaan.
Originally posted by Linda06
View Post
Really...
Spoiler:
Well at least someone is praising her!
Spoiler:
It's not you......It's just,I feel alot of the times Teyla gets bashed and blamed for some things that aren't her fault or beyond her control and sometimes i feel like i'm the only one on her side or see's things from her perspective....It's a very lonely place being a Teyla fan...
Yeah it's just a TV show but football is just a sport except for the folks like me who are passionate about they're team When you invest so much time and passion in something it's hard not to feel the passion and emotion!
Yeah it's just a TV show but football is just a sport except for the folks like me who are passionate about they're team When you invest so much time and passion in something it's hard not to feel the passion and emotion!
Spoiler:
Yeah i would go to hell and back to protect Teyla but i sometimes feel i'm alone on this....I feel sometimes i'm the only one who see's her POV and who's on her side...
And in regards to that scene where she was angry with him for not telling her about the mission to rescue Ronon...Like i said if it was any other mission i would totally understand John's stance on this but this was Ronon.....Well let's put it this way,would you do anything to protect you're brother if he was in trouble..I would like to think i would and i think Teyla would to as would John...
Well neither of them has made a move and i don't blame either because i don't think either of them really know just how much they feel for each other and neither would want to ruin what they've got so we're stuck to the status quo but life is too short and sometimes you just have to take the chance or it will pass you by....Life is full of regrets and i hope this isn't gonna be one of them...
Well y'all know i wasn't very happy with alot of S4 and i wasn't happy with the pregnancy storyline either an i was hoping against hope that Mivhael still had something to do with it.......I still think there's something about this whole thing that we don't know yet or it could just be wishful thinking on my part!
Shep has so many fans who stick by him....But Teyla doesn't exactly have alot of fans so i guess i go that extra mile to protect her because i feel i'm the only one that does!
And in regards to that scene where she was angry with him for not telling her about the mission to rescue Ronon...Like i said if it was any other mission i would totally understand John's stance on this but this was Ronon.....Well let's put it this way,would you do anything to protect you're brother if he was in trouble..I would like to think i would and i think Teyla would to as would John...
Well neither of them has made a move and i don't blame either because i don't think either of them really know just how much they feel for each other and neither would want to ruin what they've got so we're stuck to the status quo but life is too short and sometimes you just have to take the chance or it will pass you by....Life is full of regrets and i hope this isn't gonna be one of them...
Well y'all know i wasn't very happy with alot of S4 and i wasn't happy with the pregnancy storyline either an i was hoping against hope that Mivhael still had something to do with it.......I still think there's something about this whole thing that we don't know yet or it could just be wishful thinking on my part!
Shep has so many fans who stick by him....But Teyla doesn't exactly have alot of fans so i guess i go that extra mile to protect her because i feel i'm the only one that does!
Spoiler:
Yeah I'm totally the same I'm not sure to tell it here with a lot of people reading and I don't want to bother you but it's sad to say and I will say that Stargate is a great part of my life I know it's a TV show and life shows me this but it's too one of the few things in my life lol and I live it passionately like with sports lol and ITA that Teyla is a lot bashed on the contrary of Shep and I don't always understand why it has to do with favoritism lol
Originally posted by scifan
View Post
Yes, I did. Thank you.
Ditto!!!
I agree.
LOL!!!
NP hun.
ROFL!!!!
Where is that darn watergun!!!
Ok. My POV on BT
Ditto!!!
I agree.
LOL!!!
NP hun.
ROFL!!!!
Where is that darn watergun!!!
Ok. My POV on BT
Spoiler:
I really enjoyed it. I could've used more whump, I swear JoeM said something about that, but I guess I was wrong. Couldn't be that luck to get 3 eps of physical whump, but emo whump is good too.
I think Jason was awesome in this ep especially at the end. Very well done and if I was alone it the room, I think I would've cried. Especially when John and Teyla were watching over him.
Ok, I hate to say this, but as much as I want Kanaan gone, I did like him in this ep. He was able to relieve some burden off of Teyla's mind. I don't see a real connect either and I hope that it stays that way, but we'll see.
Ok. This is not Teyla bashing, far from it. I actually liked how the writers did the scene with Teyla and John and him not informing her of leaving on the hunch.
Here me out. She's in the middle of two worlds. Her old one and a new one. Being on John's team and him calling when they are going on missions and the new where she has other responsibilities and needs to think of that too. She's a new mom and alot happened to her, lets not forget that. She just got reunited with Kanaan and her people. I'm sure some of that was playing with her decission too. I know there are other women in RL that make these decissions too and I know that Rachel wanted to be able to share that as well.
As for John, I don't think he was harsh. Listen to the tone in his voice. It's gentle and understanding like in the locker room scene in SoW, maybe even more gentle.
You know he wants he back. He said it right in the beginning of the ep. I saw him feeling a little hurt that she was upset with him and I don't think that he wanted to feel that burden of always wondering if Teyla wants to be on or not. Did that make sense?
I think both actions were warrented. She relies on him alot and you can see that she doesn't want to leave his team. I also think that John had to tell her that it was up to her and it shouldn't be his responsibilities and he understood her as well.
Everyone did an awesome job in the ep. Lots of funny parts to break up the serious ones. All and all a really good ep.
I think Jason was awesome in this ep especially at the end. Very well done and if I was alone it the room, I think I would've cried. Especially when John and Teyla were watching over him.
Ok, I hate to say this, but as much as I want Kanaan gone, I did like him in this ep. He was able to relieve some burden off of Teyla's mind. I don't see a real connect either and I hope that it stays that way, but we'll see.
Ok. This is not Teyla bashing, far from it. I actually liked how the writers did the scene with Teyla and John and him not informing her of leaving on the hunch.
Here me out. She's in the middle of two worlds. Her old one and a new one. Being on John's team and him calling when they are going on missions and the new where she has other responsibilities and needs to think of that too. She's a new mom and alot happened to her, lets not forget that. She just got reunited with Kanaan and her people. I'm sure some of that was playing with her decission too. I know there are other women in RL that make these decissions too and I know that Rachel wanted to be able to share that as well.
As for John, I don't think he was harsh. Listen to the tone in his voice. It's gentle and understanding like in the locker room scene in SoW, maybe even more gentle.
You know he wants he back. He said it right in the beginning of the ep. I saw him feeling a little hurt that she was upset with him and I don't think that he wanted to feel that burden of always wondering if Teyla wants to be on or not. Did that make sense?
I think both actions were warrented. She relies on him alot and you can see that she doesn't want to leave his team. I also think that John had to tell her that it was up to her and it shouldn't be his responsibilities and he understood her as well.
Everyone did an awesome job in the ep. Lots of funny parts to break up the serious ones. All and all a really good ep.
Comment