Modeling Challenge Thread

[knowles2]

I won the civ ship challenge, have we done alien ship?

Nope.

[Merlin1701]

I do remember you doing a wraith ship...did you finish it?

[Merlin1701]

very quiet here!

[Semmer]

We're waiting for the final results... ACTUALLY TWO FINAL RESULTS!!!!

[boberth2o]

We're waiting for the final results... ACTUALLY TWO FINAL RESULTS!!!!

im still waiting on the results from one judge

[Semmer]

im still waiting on the results from one judge

For 8th challenge too?

[boberth2o]

Click Me!

[Dr Lee]

Hmmm.....

EDIT- Can it be a sea base or must it be on land?

[boberth2o]

Hmmm.....

EDIT- Can it be a sea base or must it be on land?

doesn't matter

[Semmer]

YAY! A groundbase! I'm going underground.

[Experiment 442]

The possibilities, I'm going for ancient ground base, is that all right?

[boberth2o]

Ninth Challenge Results

Members that I could find with completed submissions:
Experiment 442
Pharaoh Hamenthotep
ManiacMike
puddlejumperOZ

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

-Member Name experiment 442
-Vehicle Name 3
-Vehicle Specs 2
-Vehicle Use 3
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently) 1
-Presentation 1
-Originality 1
-Style 3
-Other (you can specify a feature that they did well on or didn't at all)

Total = _____14_____

-Member Name pharo hamethotep
-Vehicle Name 2
-Vehicle Specs 2
-Vehicle Use 1
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently) 1
-Presentation 3
-Originality 2
-Style 3
-Other (you can specify a feature that they did well on or didn't at all)

Total = ____14______

-Member Name maniacmike
-Vehicle Name 3
-Vehicle Specs 3
-Vehicle Use 3
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently) 3
-Presentation 2
-Originality 1
-Style 3
-Other (you can specify a feature that they did well on or didn't at all)

Total = ___18_______


-Member Name PJ-OZ
-Vehicle Name 2
-Vehicle Specs 3
-Vehicle Use 3
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently) 3
-Presentation 1
-Originality 1
-Style1
-Other (you can specify a feature that they did well on or didn't at all)

Total = ___14_______

Spoiler:

-Member Name: Experiment442
-Vehicle Name: Chaos Tank
-Vehicle Specs: 3
-Vehicle Use: 3
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently): 3
-Presentation: 3
-Originality: 3
-Style: 3
-Other: 2. For the most part I thought that this was a very nice tank. Nice model and textures, and mean looking. A few quips that I had with the design were the viewing screen and beaming tech. Why make such an easy and lightly defended weak spot when they could easily use cameras and other methods, or slits to see out of? And as for getting the code wrong and being deleted from the buffer, seems a tad risky. Otherwise, great submission.

Total = 20


-Member Name: Pharaoh Hamenthotep
-Vehicle Name: Walker
-Vehicle Specs: 3
-Vehicle Use: 3
-Real Life Stargate Tech: 3
-Presentation: 3
-Originality: 3
-Style: 3
-Other: 3. When you were building this and showing the stages in the Modeling Challenge I was torn as to whether or not I liked it. But seeing it in its finished state, it is a very detailed and original piece of modeling and has great functionality. I like the simplicity behind the Walker's purpose too, excellent renders too! Full marks for you.

Total = 21


-Member Name: ManiacMike
-Vehicle Name: Humvee M2100
-Vehicle Specs: 2
-Vehicle Use: 3
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently): 3
-Presentation: 2
-Originality: 2
-Style: 2
-Other: 3. I like how this is an adaptation of the Humvee, which one would have to be crazy not to love. The only downside is that it kind of detracted from the originality, though scored you points on the Tech and Vehicle Use since they are believable and easily attainable. All in all, a good submission.

Total = 17


-Member Name: puddlejumperOZ
-Vehicle Name: Not given?
-Vehicle Specs: 1
-Vehicle Use: 2
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently): 3
-Presentation: 2
-Originality: 1
-Style: 1
-Other: 1. I don't mind that the submission is in 2D, that's not why you lost marks. But there was no write-up for your submission, not even a vehicle name. If it was posted elsewhere then I apologize, but in the submissions that I have to go on I see nothing but the pictures. So there isn't a lot to go on based off of that. It essentially appears as a pickup truck with a few different weapons systems and no protection from enemies, which would limit its usefulness off-world. Also, having the missile systems and such mounted on a vehicle with what appears to be no armour seems like a contradiction. I encourage you to keep on participating in the challenges, because these were pretty good drawings, your submissions just need more substance so that the judges have more to act upon. A few pictures don't give us anything to work with, so I wasn't really able to give you any marks.

Total: 11

Spoiler:

-Member Name: Experiment 442
-Vehicle Name: T206 Chaos Tank
-Vehicle Specs: 2
-Vehicle Use: 2
-Real Life Stargate Tech: 2
-Presentation: 3
-Originality: 2
-Style: 2
-Other: Good overall design, altough the size of the tank is a bit gagantuan. 120mm Gatling guns might be a bit too large of a caliber nevertheless...


Total = 13



-Member Name: Pharaoh Hamenthotep
-Vehicle Name: -missing-
-Vehicle Specs: 1
-Vehicle Use: 2
-Real Life Stargate Tech: 2
-Presentation: 2
-Originality: 3
-Style: 3
-Other: 3 Attention to detail and mechanics.


Total = 16



-Member Name: ManiacMike
-Vehicle Name: M2100 "Humwee"
-Vehicle Specs: 3
-Vehicle Use: 2
-Real Life Stargate Tech: 2
-Presentation: 2
-Originality: 1
-Style: 1
-Other: -

Total = 11



-Member Name: puddlejumperOZ
-Vehicle Name: ?
-Vehicle Specs: 1 (not presented)
-Vehicle Use: 1 (not presented)
-Real Life Stargate Tech: 1 (not presented)
-Presentation: 1 (no presentation)
-Originality: 2
-Style: 2
-Other: 1 (good for a 2D drawing)


Total = 9

Spoiler:

-Member Name: Experiment 442
-Vehicle Name: T-206 Chaos tank
-Vehicle Specs: 3
-Vehicle Use: 3
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently): 3
-Presentation: 2
-Originality: 2
-Style: 3
-Other (you can specify a feature that they did well on or didn't at all)
very nice detail work and vast backstory.
Total = 16

-Member Name: Pharaoh Hamenthotep
-Vehicle Name: Altairan Walker
-Vehicle Specs: 2
-Vehicle Use: 2
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently): 3
-Presentation: 3
-Originality: 3
-Style: 3
-Other (you can specify a feature that they did well on or didn't at all)
Nice use of old school stargate info
Total = 16

-Member Name: ManicMike
-Vehicle Name: Humvee M2100
-Vehicle Specs: 3
-Vehicle Use: 2
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently): 3
-Presentation: 2
-Originality: 1
-Style: 2
-Other (you can specify a feature that they did well on or didn't at all)
informative spec sheet
Total = 13

-Member Name: PuddlejumperOZ
-Vehicle Name: Not Shown
-Vehicle Specs: 0
-Vehicle Use: 2
-Real Life Stargate Tech: 3 (I assume)
-Presentation: 1
-Originality: 1
-Style: 2
-Other (you can specify a feature that they did well on or didn't at all)
Created before the challenge, not a model, no specs or history
Total = 9

Spoiler:

-Member Name: Experiment 442
-Vehicle Name: T-206 Chaos tank
-Vehicle Specs: 3
-Vehicle Use: 3
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently): 3
-Presentation: 3
-Originality: 2
-Style: 3
-Other: 2
Total = 19

-Member Name: Pharaoh Hamenthotep
-Vehicle Name: Altairan Walker
-Vehicle Specs: 2
-Vehicle Use: 3
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently): 3
-Presentation: 3
-Originality: 3
-Style: 3
-Other: 1
Total = 18

-Member Name: ManicMike
-Vehicle Name: Humvee M2100
-Vehicle Specs: 3
-Vehicle Use: 3
-Real Life Stargate Tech (no technology advanced beyond the show currently): 3
-Presentation: 2
-Originality: 1
-Style: 2
-Other 2
Total = 16

-Member Name: PuddlejumperOZ
-Vehicle Name:
-Vehicle Specs: 0
-Vehicle Use: 2
-Real Life Stargate Tech: 2
-Presentation: 1
-Originality: 1
-Style: 2
-Other:0
Total = 8

I would officially like to congratulate Pharaoh Hamenthotep for winning The Ninth Challenge. Good Job!

Spoiler:

[boberth2o]

its cool

[Semmer]

Congrats to Pharaoh Hamenthotep!!

[Merlin1701]

Congrats, a close run between 442 and PH!