Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Ship Scaling Sprites

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Ship Scaling Sprites

    This thread's purpose is to discuss the relative size of various ships/constructs in the Stargate universe. Only ships that have appeared in more than one episode (not counting stock-footage) are candidates to be added to the scale.

    NOTICE: This thread is to discuss relative and practical sizes of the constructs in the scales below. Various objects are re-sized by the 3d departments who work on the show, depending on the practicum of the shot- I.e.: The super gate was stated in ‘Beachhead’ to be 300-400 meters wide, but later in that episode, as well as in ‘Camelot’, and ‘The Pegasus Project’, the Super gate was shown as being far larger that the original 300-400 estimation. One could surmise that the individual super gate segments either expand, or connect to one another to form completed segments which then connect to one another to form an operational super gate. This increase in size was no doubt done so the Ori Warships whose only method to get into the Milky Way was the super gate, could be made many times larger than any human, Goa’uld, or even Asgard vessel, and make the Ori seem far more powerful.

    Basic estimates:

    Prometheus (303-class): 375 meters.
    Daedalus (304-class): 586 meters (credit to boberth2o for scaling)
    Ha’tak: 680 meters
    F-302: 6 meters:
    Al’kesh: 36.5 meters
    Anubis Super-weapon: 5168 meters
    Cargo Ship: 10.5 meters
    Beliskner (Asgard Mothership): 1088 meters
    O’Neill (Asgard advanced warship): 1632 meters
    Fifth’s/Replicarter’s Mothership:
    Ori Warship: 3196 meters
    Ori Fighter: 9.25 meters
    Wraith Hive Ship: 11km
    Atlantis:3300 meters

    Here is a chart of some of the ships from the scalings above:







    Credit for the images used in the scales goes to 'Herbert' from the Game Maker Games Forums.
    Except for Atlantis, which was made by Shane Benson (Vilandra from the Sci-fi meshes forums)
    Credit for the Wraith Cruiser, Ori Supergate Wraith Scout, and the Ancient Warship goes to Aiden Ford. Liam887 made the Halcyon cruiser and the Assault Carrier. ????*Co¬¬in L ??? made the Oribtal defense station, and the forerunner Keyship. All Under Heaven made the CCS-Class Battlecruiser and the Seraph fighter. =UnlimitedGuy= made the Longsword. Warsock made the Frigate.

    Proof-screenshots:
    Al'kesh relative size based on rings, and people below 'The Other Guys':


    Cargo Ship 'Fail-Safe':
    Cargo bridge height derived from the set used over and over and over again.


    Ori Fighter Proofs 'Line in the Sand':




    Proof screenshots for Atlantis:




    An addition scaling for the length of the wraith scout ship:


    Orion-class and Wraith Cruiser:


    More proof screenshots for the other ships coming soon. If you disagree with the sizes stated above, please provide screenshots from one of these sites to show why your estimates are correct and mine aren't:

    http://www.stargatecaps.com/
    http://www.stargatesg1971.com/sg1caps.html



    PLEASE do not use sizes taken from 'Camelot' or 'Flesh and Blood' as arguments. The sizes in these two episodes are horribly out of proportion for 'dramatic effect'!
    Last edited by Battera; March 3, 2008, 12:34 PM.
    You look but you do not see. You listen but you do not hear. You cannot accept us, but we are here to stay. You think we are just a shadow, a bad memory that will go away if you ignore us long enough but we won't.

    We are human too whether you like it or not. We are here and our time is now. Together we can only soar. We will remain strong forever more, and nothing can quell our pride.

    -LGBT-

    #2
    What do you base your figures on?

    Comment


      #3
      The current figures are based on the episodes 'Lost City', 'Exodus', 'Revelations', and 'Off the Grid'. There are others, but those episodes are the only significant ones.
      You look but you do not see. You listen but you do not hear. You cannot accept us, but we are here to stay. You think we are just a shadow, a bad memory that will go away if you ignore us long enough but we won't.

      We are human too whether you like it or not. We are here and our time is now. Together we can only soar. We will remain strong forever more, and nothing can quell our pride.

      -LGBT-

      Comment


        #4
        I'd like to see the numbers

        Comment


          #5
          What exactly do you mean by numbers? Like screen caps?
          You look but you do not see. You listen but you do not hear. You cannot accept us, but we are here to stay. You think we are just a shadow, a bad memory that will go away if you ignore us long enough but we won't.

          We are human too whether you like it or not. We are here and our time is now. Together we can only soar. We will remain strong forever more, and nothing can quell our pride.

          -LGBT-

          Comment


            #6
            calculations. How you reached those sizes.

            Comment


              #7
              Well, the Prometheus was very small compared to a Ha'tak in 'Lost City', and we already know that the Ha'tak's pyramid is about the size of the great pyramids (220 meters wide), and we've seen an intensive comparison of a Ha'tak to an al'kesh, and an Al'kesh to a Death glider in 'Exodus', as well as a decent comparison of a beliskner to a Ha'tak in 'Revelations'. The f-302 size was determined in comparisons done of the fighters exiting the Daedalus. And:

              The Death glider can seat two people, so it's logically about 5-6 meters.

              The Al'kesh is quite a few times bigger than a glider, about 6-8 times longer, giving it an approximate length of 32-36 meters.

              The Prometheus is 5-6 times longer than an Al'kesh as shown in 'Lost City'.

              The Ha'tak's base is approximately the width of the great pyramids, and the total width of the pyramid, and the super-structure creates a variable range of any where from 550-800 meters, depending on which episode you look at. I, of course, chose 'Lost city', in the scene where the Prometheus approached Anubis's ship, passing a Ha'tak.

              The Beliskner's size was rather difficult to calculate. Using the scene in 'Revelations', when the Beliskner begins to approach Osiris's Ha'tak, I guessed the distance the Beliskner was to the Ha'tak, (also using a screen cap from 'Thor's Chariot'), and calculated its approximate size to be about 1340 Meters.
              You look but you do not see. You listen but you do not hear. You cannot accept us, but we are here to stay. You think we are just a shadow, a bad memory that will go away if you ignore us long enough but we won't.

              We are human too whether you like it or not. We are here and our time is now. Together we can only soar. We will remain strong forever more, and nothing can quell our pride.

              -LGBT-

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Battera
                Alot of fans have no idea how big some ships are compared to one another. Like Ha'tak to prometheus, or the Daedalus to an Ori warship, so inorder to end this quarrel, I have created a size comparison chart for the ships of stargate. If you see something that you think is incorrect, please post your opinion, and if possible screencaps supporting you.:



                Ships I'm currently working on:
                O'neill
                Replicator Cruiser

                Other ships to be included:
                Ori Warship
                Wraith hive ship

                i will have to disagree according to my sources.

                Prometheus= Length 257 m
                Width 104 m
                Height 71 m
                sources=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prometheus_%28Stargate%29

                F-302 not specified!!!

                Daedalus= Length 335 m
                Width 192 m
                Height 68 m
                http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daedalu..._battlecruiser

                Al'kesh not specified!!

                Ha'tak not specified!

                Beliskner not specified!

                O'Neill class battleship not specified!

                Daniel Jackson not specified!

                Aurora class battleship = Unofficial data suggests length about 500 metres and breadth about 220 metres.
                http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aurora_class_battleship

                SuperGate= 300 to 400 meters. Kallana gate. first Ssg.
                http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supergate_%28Stargate%29

                Ori BattleCrusier = The Ori ships appear to be far larger than any of the Earth/Jaffa/Asgard/Tok'ra ships present, each battlecruiser being comparable in size to at least 4 Ha'taks but probably more. This, however, could be just a matter of perspective, as very little quality footage is available. Based on extrapolation from the relative size of a human to one of the new supergate´s blocks, an Ori ship could be 700–800 metres (2100–2500 ft.) wide and 1000–1200 metres (3000–3600 ft.) long. The primary weapon of the ship is housed at the base of the bow. Given that supergates are about 1000 to 1300 feet (300 to 400 meters) in diameter, an Ori Battle ship must be smaller than these boundaries.
                http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ori_battlecruiser

                Wraith Hive-ships = Length 5545m
                Width 3970m
                http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wraith_Hive-Ship

                Now in use. pps is at 4,929 Terawatts
                pps = power per second
                The power that power's the great cities of the Ancients.
                xfire = zpm
                [m2k] klan, and forever will be.
                http://m2kclan.com
                vent info: voice250.hurricanehost.com
                port: 3785
                P90>M4A1+AK47+Machine Gun
                halo player and cs:s, cs:1.6, cz, cod2.
                Save Stargate NOW!!!- http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/Stargate/

                Comment


                  #9
                  Ok. If the Daedalus is only 78 meters longer than the Prometheus, then why does everyone say that the Daedalus is several times the size of the prometheus? The Wikipedia is likely incorrect. The most credible (perhaps only credible) source for the scales of the ships are the episodes themselves excep camelot which screwed up royally.
                  You look but you do not see. You listen but you do not hear. You cannot accept us, but we are here to stay. You think we are just a shadow, a bad memory that will go away if you ignore us long enough but we won't.

                  We are human too whether you like it or not. We are here and our time is now. Together we can only soar. We will remain strong forever more, and nothing can quell our pride.

                  -LGBT-

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Sorry.... but I wouldn't depend on Wikipedia for starship info. First off all, the data is submitted from fan observation. Observations which does not do things like pixel calcuation and etc.

                    You might wanna try StarGate-Tech instead of Wikipedia...
                    http://www.stargate-tech.net/

                    IMO, the largest ships (barring City-Ships) are the Ori warships.

                    BTW... no calculations for the Aurora Class ships?
                    http://www.myspace.com/peoples_general
                    http://www.brickshelf.com/cgi-bin/ga...PeoplesGeneral

                    Comment


                      #11
                      I wish the StarGate VFX guys paid attention to ship sizes the way that Star Wars and Star Trek guys do.
                      http://www.myspace.com/peoples_general
                      http://www.brickshelf.com/cgi-bin/ga...PeoplesGeneral

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by Peoples_General
                        IMO, the largest ships (barring City-Ships) are the Ori warships.
                        Not according to certain scalling sites online, Atlantis is only 3km at the largest, and maybe only 1.5km at the smallest.

                        Of course, those of us with active imaginations take the "size of Manhattan" quote literally and upscale that to 21km from end to end
                        sigpic
                        http://www.nerdtests.com/ft_space.php

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Considering the size of those skyscrappers on Atlantis... I somehow doubt that the city is a mere 3.1km or the VFX guys need to redo the design, visit an actual big city with tons of skyscrapper (Shanghai, New York, Tokyo), actually pay attention to scaling details and etc.

                          IMO, it just doesn't makes sense. I know a lot about Cities and Skyscrappers. I live in friggin NEW YORK CITY.

                          3.1km.... Are you telling me that we lowly humans have constructed things that outclass the mighty Ancients??? Are the VFX guys aware that these are the Ancients they're dealing with?
                          http://www.myspace.com/peoples_general
                          http://www.brickshelf.com/cgi-bin/ga...PeoplesGeneral

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by Battera
                            Ok. If the Daedalus is only 78 meters longer than the Prometheus, then why does everyone say that the Daedalus is several times the size of the prometheus? The Wikipedia is likely incorrect. The most credible (perhaps only credible) source for the scales of the ships are the episodes themselves excep camelot which screwed up royally.
                            Wait, who says the Prommie is that much smaller than the Deady?

                            Originally posted by Peoples_General

                            3.1km.... Are you telling me that we lowly humans have constructed things that outclass the mighty Ancients??? Are the VFX guys aware that these are the Ancients they're dealing with?
                            We have?! Sweet, where is this huge flying city that we've contructed?

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by Battera
                              The most credible (perhaps only credible) source for the scales of the ships are the episodes themselves excep camelot which screwed up royally.
                              From what I can tell from the episodes I've watched(including Camelot) the only people who messed up royally were us fans. IMO most of us simply assume that all ships on screen are a similar distance from our point of view. other than that I really don't know how large the ships are by numbers. I only know that the Ori ships are about the same size as the O'niell class vessel that was there and that the Ha'taks are a little under half that size and the Oddysey(similar in size to the Prometheus) is slightly smaller than half the size of the Ha'taks.

                              But this is only what I believe based on what I've seen in Stargate episodes.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X