'Earth' (107) General Discussion

[Radahldo]

I actually thought that scene was hilarious! Now we know the stones are prone to glitches, but imagine the timing!

I don't think I laughed that heartily all this year. That scene, man; my entire Winter is made.

[Lt.Colonel John Sheppard]

so the next time we see Telford will be in Life.

[jelgate]

makes me wonder if Telford had known Emily before.

or...is he visiting as himself, or Young?

My instincts say he is Telford masquerading as Young

[Orion Antreas]

OMG! I am still shocked over one scene! Let me collect myself here before I can post my thoughts. I am still 'O_O'.

[Coronach]

Very generally, I must say I really liked this episode. I enjoyed it more than "Water", and the primary "conflict" of the episode was really solid. Furthermore, I totally wasn't expecting that from Rush at the end...very cool idea, writers.

And I must say, when Chloe started kissing Eli in the car...my immediate thought was "Oh god...now I'll have to listen to whining about THAT for another week". So glad it was just Eli imagining.

This is definitely Stargate, and I'm very excited for next week's premise

[Pharaoh Atem]

My instincts say he is Telford masquerading as Young

as the world turns "dramatic music"

[Jeff-B]

The beginning of the episode, I thought Young was just fantasizing about TJ, but the conversation with his wife hints that maybe Young has had an affair with TJ in the past...

[joeynox]

Wonderful episode all around . The acting is getting better and better and young is officially my fav commanding officer is a very very long time.

This episode answered why they can't use a star to dial ho
e, they got the weapnons working, discovered dropping in and out of ftl messes with the stones and that young had an affair. the young Telford body jumping was CLASSIC.

What a great episode and I can't wait for next week

9/10

[Descended]

Wonder why Telford was at the door in the end, I am guessing one of two reasons.

1) He is going to pretend to be Young and have sex with the wife.

2) He has a sexually transmitted disease, i.e. HIV and needs to tell her.

If Telford pretended to be me and screwed my wife, next time I switched bodies with him I would go commit a crime (i.e. rob a bank and let him have fun with that)

[Coronach]

The beginning of the episode, I thought Young was just fantasizing about TJ, but the conversation with his wife hints that maybe Young has had an affair with TJ in the past...

Indeed. While that was definitely a dream of some sort, it was definitely hinted at that it was sparked by something that actually happened.

On the plus side, I'm really glad that it's something his wife already knows about. It's nice to not have that weird "he's keeping a secret that he cheated on her" thing weighing in the background.

[Pharaoh Atem]

The beginning of the episode, I thought Young was just fantasizing about TJ, but the conversation with his wife hints that maybe Young has had an affair with TJ in the past...

yes, that's why she's hiding young's medical condition from the ioa girl on the destiny

[Lt.Colonel John Sheppard]

ha ha that's what i would do.

[Radahldo]

2) He has a sexually transmitted disease, i.e. HIV and needs to tell her.

...Really?

[Pharaoh Atem]

...Really?

fan speculation nothing more.

[kymeric]

Wonder why Telford was at the door in the end, I am guessing one of two reasons.

1) He is going to pretend to be Young and have sex with the wife.

2) He has a sexually transmitted disease, i.e. HIV and needs to tell her.

If Telford pretended to be me and screwed my wife, next time I switched bodies with him I would go commit a crime (i.e. rob a bank and let him have fun with that)

Heh i thought of that during that scene, i was all... uhm u dont know where hes been!