Complete season 5 : rate those episodes

[major davis]

Ok, I just wanted to voice my opinion and let other people voice their opinion about season 5's episodes. On a rating of 1-10 ( including .5) I will rate all the episodes of season 5 and ask everybody that reads this to do it also. Thanks!!! here is what the numbers mean to me

10) outstanding 9) amazing 7-8) pretty awsome ( but all stargate is awsome) 5-6) fair, probably won't rewatch 2-4) not good but i wont turn it off 0-1) I will probobly want to blow up my TV

Now here is what I think

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Search and Rescue- 9
The Seed- 7
Broken ties- 9
Daedalus varitions- 9(love the new race)
Ghost in the Machine-8.5 (great way to tie up the story without tori)
The Shrine-9.5(they did really well with the emotional scenes)
Whispers-7(would make it 9 but vega died)
The Queen-8.5
Tracker-7
First Contact-9
The lost Tribe-8
Outsiders-8.5
Inquisition-6.5
The Prodigal-9.5(would be 10 but the body and the hybrid-baby scene prevented it)
Remanents-5.5(Lost all the impact when kolya was fake)
Brain Storm-6.5(Nothing against Keller and Rodney but it really stunk)
Infection-7(Cinemitography and stunts were cool but the VF shot at the end was poop)
Identity-1.5(one of the Worst eps of SGA ever)
Vegas-9.5(From the shots to the stunts to the action to the story, everything was near perfect)
Enemy at the Gate-7.5( the hype about it was overrated and several aspects were overrated, it felt rushed and earth didnt feel threatened to me, would probably would have liked it more if it was a season finale, not a series finale. Besides, it was only one hive, no scare for me).

Now what do you guys think

[Inquisitor]

The way I rate my episodes is by memorability, endurance (Ability to rewatch) and quality of story. (and average)

Search and Rescue- 5, 8, 8 (7)
The Seed- 8,6,4 (THEY WENT NO WHERE WITH IT AFTERWARD) (6)
Broken ties- 6, 6, 7 (6)
Daedalus variations- 10,10,9 (~10)
Ghost in the Machine- 10, 8, 9 (9)
The Shrine-10,10,10 (They left the place alone afterward though) (10)
Whispers-7,7,6 (~7)
The Queen-9,8,8 (~8)
Tracker-6,7,8 (7)
First Contact-9,9,9 (9)
The lost Tribe-9,9/10 (since 2parter),7 (8.5)
Outsiders-5,6,6 (~6)
Inquisition-8,5,7 (~6)
The Prodigal-10,10,9.5 (it seemed a bit weird michael didnt just leave) (~10)
Remanents-9,6,7 (seemed a bit of a copy off the Gadmeer) (~7.5)
Brain Storm-9,7,8 (i actually quite liked this episode) (8)
Infection-6,7,7 (~7)
Identity-8,3,5 (~5.5)
Vegas-10,9,9 (a bit predictable) (~9.5)
Enemy at the Gate-10,10 (lastep),8 (~9.5)
Enemy at the Gate deservers special recognition, because of the over the top sudden announcements, like one of Paul Jennings short stories. The ancient gene list, sudden introduction of Carson again, Todd able to get to a planet w/o hyperdrive, some guy with a big ship, ship has stargate, ship has zpm (i'm not surprised Todd had more though), Carter's makeup , Where's Landry? and lack of mention of the Antarctica treaty in Atlantis.

[Linda06]

Search and Rescue- 8
The Seed- 6
Broken ties- 7
Daedalus varitions- 7
Ghost in the Machine- 2
The Shrine- 1
Whispers- 2
The Queen- 7
Tracker- 6
First Contact- 7
The lost Tribe- 5
Outsiders- 6
Inquisition- 2
The Prodigal- 9
Remnants- Not seen it yet
Brain Storm-1
Infection- 7
Identity- 2
Vegas- 1
Enemy at the Gate- 6

And i'm too lazy to write what I liked and didn't like about the eps

[LizzieAnne]

Search and Rescue- 10
The Seed- 8
Broken ties- 9
Daedalus variations- 7
Ghost in the Machine- 2
The Shrine- 4
Whispers- 6
The Queen- 8
Tracker- 7
First Contact- 8
The Lost Tribe- 7
Outsiders- 7
Inquisition- 8
The Prodigal- 9
Remnants- 8
Brain Storm-7
Infection- 7
Identity- 5
Vegas- 10
Enemy at the Gate- 9

[Mitchell82]

Search and Rescue: 10 (Great season premiere)
The Seed: 8 (Good ep with just a few too convenient plot devices)
Broken Ties: 8.5 (Great ep just wish Tire hadn't died.)
The Deadalus Variations: 9.5 (only reason it didn't get a 10 is because of the too convenient ending)
Ghost in the Machine: 10 (Great conclusion to the Replicator/Weir arc)
The Shrine: 10 (The Best Rodney ep since Tao of Rodney)
Whispers: 7 (Cool idea poor execution but still decent)
The Queen: 10 (Excellent episode especially the Teyla as a Wraith part)
Tracker: 8.5 (Great Rodney/Keller ep. Really showed Rodney's good side.)
First Contact: 10 (Best Mid Season finale made even better with Daniel)
Lost Tribe: 10 (Great conclusion to a great mid season finale)
Outsiders: 8 (Interesting ep better than Whispers)
Inquisition: 7 ( Not bad clip ep)
The Prodigal: 9 (Great conclusion to the Michael/Teyla arc only downside is dead Mikey though the way it was done was very fitting)
Remnants: 9.5 ( Very unique and well done story great seeing Koyla again even if he wasn't real.)
Brainstorm: 8.5 ( Great episode marred by some not so good CG and a few cliched moments but overall a great ep.)
Infection: 8.5 ( Not bad. Could have been better but it was a very well done ep.)
Identity: 9.5 ( An excellent episode with many great plot twists)
Vegas: 9 ( Very different but very good ep)
Enemy at the Gate: 10 (Excellent series finale)

[CazzBlade]

Search and Rescue- 10
The Seed- 9
Broken ties- 6.5
Daedalus variations- 8
Ghost in the Machine- 7
The Shrine- 7
Whispers- 6
The Queen- 9
Tracker- 5
First Contact- 8
The Lost Tribe- 6.5
Outsiders- 7
Inquisition- 5
The Prodigal- 10
Remnants- 7.5
Brain Storm-0
Infection- 9
Identity- 4
Vegas- 9
Enemy at the Gate- 9

[Lythisrose]

Search and Rescue- 9.5
The Seed- 8
Broken ties- 7.5
Daedalus variations- 8.5
Ghost in the Machine- 7
The Shrine- 10
Whispers- 7.5
The Queen- 8
Tracker- 3
First Contact- 8
The Lost Tribe- 5
Outsiders- 8
Inquisition- 6
The Prodigal- 9.5
Remnants- 8.5
Brain Storm- -10, ok 0
Infection- 9
Identity- 4
Vegas- 10
Enemy at the Gate- 7.5 (ending scene 1)

[Briangate78]

Search and Rescue- 9 (Excellent season premiere, loved the opening sequence)
The Seed- 8.5 (Good return of Carson ep)
Broken ties- 8 (Nice B story, which was better than the main story)
Daedalus varitions- 9.5 (Amazing team episode with cool new enemy)
Ghost in the Machine- 9.5 (Very dramatic ep, leaving a taste of sadness)
The Shrine- 9 (Excellent character team ep)
Whispers- 6 (Poor use of Carson)
The Queen- 8.5 (Teyla and Todd were excellent in this episode)
Tracker- 8 (Not bad, could of been better)
First Contact- 10 (One of the best Mid-season finales since "The Storm")
The lost Tribe- 10 (Anything with Asgard Fraking rocks!!!!!)
Outsiders- 9 (Carson rocked!!)
Inquisition- 7 (Poor boring episode)
The Prodigal- 1000000000000000000000000000000 (Teyla and Michael, wow)
Remnants- 9 (Excellent episode exploring the characters more)
Brain Storm - 6 (Not a good ep)
Infection- 9 (Todd sold this episode to me)
Identity- 8 (Could of been better. I am not a Keller fan)
Vegas- 9 (Brilliant episode. Different and worked)
Enemy at the Gate- 9.5 (Excellent episode to finish the show, should of been longer, like 90mins or more)