I know this won't be a popular message but I did my best to write it politely so I would appreciate it if the message stays as-is.
I just think she was there because she had another episode to do in her contract since the beginning of season 5. She really didn't do anything other than "Sorry, the chair was destroyed"
IF anyone from SG-1 should have been in this episode, it should have been Mitchell, they could even had a Mitchell and Sheppard F-302's against the darts scene and that would have been much better than Sheppard with the random guy who got blown up!
And I really hate how Sam's character has been written since SG-1 ended, she went from team scientist to leader of this, that and the next thing.
Sam isn't leader material, her time on Atlantis was due to bad writing and the show kicking off Torri Higginson, as was her [Sam's] time leading SG-1, that is the REAL REASON they brought in Mitchell (let's be honest with ourselves, the REAL world reason they brought in Mitchell was because Sam wasn't leader material, NOT because Sam left to work in Area 51). I actually wish they just went with Woolsey back in season 4, at least if they did that, we could have had 2 seasons with Woosley because one isn't enough. I think that a new character needs at least 2 seasons to have enough like with Mitchell and Landry.
They have been promoting Sam too early for a couple of years now. I still wish that she was still Maj. Carter.
Now she's going to command a ship? As I said above, she's NOT leader material. I think this is too much. And worse is because that was written in an ATLANTIS episode, AT LEAST save this news for the SG-1 movie. I LOVE Atlantis but I don't think it's right to make SG-1 storyline changes in an Atlantis episode anymore than SG-1 writing changes to Atlantis in an SG-1 episode.
I KNOW they have BUDGET limitations but it's the last episode, couldn't they spend a little more to get Ben Browder to play Mitchell?
Vala,
I just think she was there because she had another episode to do in her contract since the beginning of season 5. She really didn't do anything other than "Sorry, the chair was destroyed"
IF anyone from SG-1 should have been in this episode, it should have been Mitchell, they could even had a Mitchell and Sheppard F-302's against the darts scene and that would have been much better than Sheppard with the random guy who got blown up!
And I really hate how Sam's character has been written since SG-1 ended, she went from team scientist to leader of this, that and the next thing.
Sam isn't leader material, her time on Atlantis was due to bad writing and the show kicking off Torri Higginson, as was her [Sam's] time leading SG-1, that is the REAL REASON they brought in Mitchell (let's be honest with ourselves, the REAL world reason they brought in Mitchell was because Sam wasn't leader material, NOT because Sam left to work in Area 51). I actually wish they just went with Woolsey back in season 4, at least if they did that, we could have had 2 seasons with Woosley because one isn't enough. I think that a new character needs at least 2 seasons to have enough like with Mitchell and Landry.
They have been promoting Sam too early for a couple of years now. I still wish that she was still Maj. Carter.
Now she's going to command a ship? As I said above, she's NOT leader material. I think this is too much. And worse is because that was written in an ATLANTIS episode, AT LEAST save this news for the SG-1 movie. I LOVE Atlantis but I don't think it's right to make SG-1 storyline changes in an Atlantis episode anymore than SG-1 writing changes to Atlantis in an SG-1 episode.
I KNOW they have BUDGET limitations but it's the last episode, couldn't they spend a little more to get Ben Browder to play Mitchell?
Vala,
Comment