Keller - just no MD

[Othala08]

Just watched this ep again, and it struck me that when Keller is supposedly tending Sheppard in the infirmary on Daedalus, her medical approach to a severely wounded man is not in the same league as Drs Beckett or Frasier in SG1. Either of the latter would have got out the scissors and cut his uniform off him, and would have been assessing what is supposed to be a severe laceration, possibly through the ribs and into the liver! Instead we have him sitting there in his dirty uniform and Keller hovering over him with tweezers and a bit of lint! Surely somebody could coach JS to help her come across as more medically competent!

[jelgate]

Kind of hard when JF refuses to have a shirtless scene

[fumblesmcstupid]

Just because JF refuses to show his chest has NOTHING to do with how bad an actress comes across in her ability to make you believe she is a trained doctor.

in Doppellganger both Joe and David had their shirts rucked up enough to do the d-vib scene.

[TameFarrar]

since we already have an Anti Keller thread, A Complaints and Misgivings thread AND Episode threads where this topic has been discussed and can still be discussed I am closing the redundant thread.