PDA

View Full Version : The Rodney and Carson duo are back!



Briangate78
October 17th, 2008, 06:47 PM
So, after watching "Outsiders" the episode was great all around, imo. Had some great action, nice character drama, and some comic relief. However what really sold this episode was the Mckay and Carson chemistry. The whole Hive scenes and after were just some classic Carson and Mckay moments that truly brought the earlier years alive. The friendship bond was strong and the comic relief was excellent but not overdone. The episode still managed to keep a dark dramatic feel, but with a few Rodney Mckay jokes in there.

Some great lines...

Character/ Drama

Mckay: But why didn't you tell me?
Carson: Because you would of stopped me from going

Mckay: I understand You feel guilty, but this is not your fault
Carson: One of the first things they taught us in medical school was do no harm.

Mckay: You cannot solve all the galaxy's problem in one day.

Comic Relief:

Nobel: Is he the one?
Mckay: The one wha?
Nobel: The one about the funny stories
Carson: Right

Carson: Where's the key?
Mckay : It's not a volkswagon, Carson!

*There were many more lines I just chose a few* :)

dasNdanger
October 17th, 2008, 06:53 PM
The dart scene was the best - and the part where at least two sexy bugs got away. :D


das

Briangate78
October 17th, 2008, 06:55 PM
The dart scene was the best - and the part where at least two sexy bugs got away. :D


das

After Whispers, this episode was a breath of fresh air. It just brought Carson's character from 5 years of Atlantis alive. I think this is why people love this character because of his passion to try and save others. I also love the great amount of respect Rodney has for Carson. It truly showed in this episode.

Earthgate Ricky
October 17th, 2008, 06:57 PM
YEAH! They own this episode!




Kisses to Rodney and Carson!!!

dasNdanger
October 17th, 2008, 07:26 PM
After Whispers, this episode was a breath of fresh air. It just brought Carson's character from 5 years of Atlantis alive. I think this is why people love this character because of his passion to try and save others. I also love the great amount of respect Rodney has for Carson. It truly showed in this episode.


Thanks for the green - but you so will NOT like the other thread I started. Like I said, the dart scene was the best. I have lost much respect for our dear doctor.


das

the fifth man
October 17th, 2008, 07:50 PM
Yeah, Rodney and Carson's interactions in this episode were great. It was nice to see them stuck in a situation together.

haloplayer
October 18th, 2008, 12:00 AM
So, after watching "Outsiders" the episode was great all around, imo. Had some great action, nice character drama, and some comic relief. However what really sold this episode was the Mckay and Carson chemistry. The whole Hive scenes and after were just some classic Carson and Mckay moments that truly brought the earlier years alive. The friendship bond was strong and the comic relief was excellent but not overdone. The episode still managed to keep a dark dramatic feel, but with a few Rodney Mckay jokes in there.

Some great lines...

Character/ Drama

Mckay: But why didn't you tell me?
Carson: Because you would of stopped me from going

Mckay: I understand You feel guilty, but this is not your fault
Carson: One of the first things they taught us in medical school was do no harm.

Mckay: You cannot solve all the galaxy's problem in one day.

Comic Relief:

Nobel: Is he the one?
Mckay: The one wha?
Nobel: The one about the funny stories
Carson: Right

Carson: Where's the key?
Mckay : It's not a volkswagon, Carson!

*There were many more lines I just chose a few* :)

Its weird, this Carson never attended Medical School.

Classic
October 18th, 2008, 05:23 AM
He never attended med school, but doesn't he have all the memories of one who did? One of my problems was, I didn't know a clone could be fed upon. I mean, he is really human?
Anyway, imo, the best part was the interaction between Rodney and Beckett. THe rest of it was uh-kay.

The6thRace
October 18th, 2008, 05:45 AM
I never really saw Rodney and Carson as a couple (not like Daniel and Jack). Rodney works well in a duo with just about anyone when you think about it. Rodney and Teal'c would be golden. Rodney and Woolsey, supreme. Hell, Rodney has even been with Rodney. Yes sir, Rodney McKay is a character who pairs with anyone.

Popeston
October 18th, 2008, 07:43 AM
"I have another idea, it's a long shot but it might work... *Pause*...but you're going to have to get off me"

Just way he said it had me laughing.
But the entire dart scene was brilliant.

"I can't solve all the galaxy's problems in one day."
"Well I-"
"Shut it."

Lahela
October 18th, 2008, 11:42 AM
Some great lines...

Character/ Drama

Mckay: But why didn't you tell me?
Carson: Because you would of stopped me from going

Mckay: I understand You feel guilty, but this is not your fault
Carson: One of the first things they taught us in medical school was do no harm.

Mckay: You cannot solve all the galaxy's problem in one day.



That scene was the best in the whole episode, IMO. Both Carson and Rodney were wonderful, both trying to do their utmost in terrible circumstances. Carson has the heart of a thousand men, and Rodney showed what a loyal and supportive friend he is behind the snark. *loving both of them*

Briangate78
October 18th, 2008, 11:45 AM
That scene was the best in the whole episode, IMO. Both Carson and Rodney were wonderful, both trying to do their utmost in terrible circumstances. Carson has the heart of a thousand men, and Rodney showed what a loyal and supportive friend he is behind the snark. *loving both of them*

It seems this season has truly been for the characters and that is a good thing, imo. Of course a good story is important as well.

Lythisrose
October 18th, 2008, 11:50 AM
This episode reinforced how much I have missed Carson as the doc of the show... they were good together.

stclare
October 18th, 2008, 12:15 PM
That scene was the best in the whole episode, IMO. Both Carson and Rodney were wonderful, both trying to do their utmost in terrible circumstances. Carson has the heart of a thousand men, and Rodney showed what a loyal and supportive friend he is behind the snark. *loving both of them*

Yes, they bring out the good and the bad in each other especialy the good. Loved how this was played by both actors and this will be a re-watch one for me for the banter and for the team feel that threaded through the ep :)

Ripple in Space
October 18th, 2008, 02:15 PM
Rodney works well in a duo with just about anyone when you think about it. Rodney and Teal'c would be golden.

Rodney tried to kill Teal'c.

Coaster
October 18th, 2008, 05:57 PM
I loved their interactions! Especially the scene where Rodney's explaining why it's no big deal being in the cell on the hive ship; he's been there so many times, and Carson is asking him how they got out all those times, and Rodney gradually has an "oh no" moment as he explains. Oops. :D

Zamboni
October 18th, 2008, 08:15 PM
Some great lines...

Character/ Drama

Mckay: But why didn't you tell me?
Carson: Because you would of stopped me from goingWould HAVE! HAVE! Not "of"!!! If Shakespeare was a Wraith, he would cull your ass...

This episode reminds me of that episode when that guy from Red Green combined forces with that other guy with the crazy hair and broke out of a Goa'uld mothership, saving SG1.

Albeit this episode had a lot less lulz.

Briangate78
October 18th, 2008, 08:24 PM
Would HAVE! HAVE! Not "of"!!! If Shakespeare was a Wraith, he would cull your ass...






I am from New York. We don't give a sh*t about Shakespeare in NYC.

Gate-builder
October 18th, 2008, 10:00 PM
Would HAVE! HAVE! Not "of"!!! If Shakespeare was a Wraith, he would cull your ass...

'Would of' is a hell of a lot easier to figure out than anything Shakespeare ever wrote

jelgate
October 19th, 2008, 05:38 AM
I am from New York. We don't give a sh*t about Shakespeare in NYC.

That explains a lot:P

Briangate78
October 19th, 2008, 06:34 AM
'Would of' is a hell of a lot easier to figure out than anything Shakespeare ever wrote

To be or not to be is thy question, or is Thou not to be of spoken to thy oneself. Ok that was really bad. :p


That explains a lot:P

LOL, I love you too. ;)

Coaster
October 19th, 2008, 07:24 AM
To be or not to be is thy question, or is Thou not to be of spoken to thy oneself. Ok that was really bad. :p

Carson should quote that to his patients during field surgery, to distract them. :P

tombombadil
October 19th, 2008, 07:37 AM
i'd say trhey're very merry and pippin like...

Lewisco
October 19th, 2008, 02:34 PM
their character chemistry was great. even the more dramatic scenes were great to watch, they have such great interraction on screen.
and as everyone would agree, the dart scene was just great.

Mckay: "maybe theres a weight limit.."
Beckett: "whats that supposed to mean?!"
Mckay: "as in there's two of us!"
Beckett: "maybe it needs a key!"
Mckay: "its not a volkswagen!"

MIZA
October 22nd, 2008, 02:37 PM
they never were gone, they just took a breather for awhile!!

Earthgate Ricky
October 27th, 2008, 12:43 PM
I hope that bloopers of McBeckett will be in Season 5 DVD set.

McgillionFan
November 5th, 2008, 01:28 PM
I agree with everyone who that the dart scene was the best lol.

The volkswagon part cracked me up lol.It was great to have the two back together.

And at the end when Rodney asks Carson if he wants a to get a bite to eat and they walk out and Carson asks Rodney if there's anyone he likes. lol

Rodney says no and Carson replies something like "your not a very good lier Rodney." lol

Hope to see other episodes with the two of them getting into trouble on there adventures lol

The adventures of Mckay and Beckett !! :mckay::beckett: