Re: Who would you like to defend you : Teyla or Weir

[KayMan2k]

If this is a physical struggle, Teyla would surely win. She is a trained warrior. Wier wouldn't survive.

Option C - Teal'c

OFF TOPIC: When I posted this reply, it is shown as the first post in this thread. Is this true just for the poster of the message? Is this an 'upgrade'?

[John&Teylaalltheway]

As for me I'm like to kick ass myself but if I had to choose a partner I'd choose Teyla because I get the impression she would fight to the end to defend while Wier would simply try negotiating and pouting !!!!!

Pam

[MartoufMarty]

Well, that's unfair.

Dr. Weir is a negociator, and Teyla is a warrior (basically). They have their different talents. You can't just go and ask who you would like to defend you.

Personally, I would have to go for Weir.

[Erik Pasternak]

As Marty said, they both have different skills. Because of that, who I would pick would depend on the scenario.

[Madeleine]

This thread was started during the time-zone weirdness. Post #2 should have been first. The rest can be read in the order they are in without upsetting the sense of the thread.

[greytop]

As Marty said, they both have different skills. Because of that, who I would pick would depend on the scenario.

If it was a battle, I would pick Telya.
If it was a political situation, I would pick Weir.

[Gothann]

That's quite unfair to both characters. Teyla clearly has more combat-oriented skills, Weir has negociation skills.

But as for leading, I find Weir a better candidate. She has much more authority, if need be.

[Replicarter]

Well, when i go steal the last episodes of atlantis from where ever they keep them, id like Teyla to kick the Security gaurds ass, then id like Wier to be my Lawyer to get me outa trouble

[DownFallAngel]

Weir. I think she is just hotter, and more diplomatic.

[aschen]

Well if we're going to play the "Add a character" to it, I'd like to have an Ascended Ancient (one of the ones that do something other than watch people die that is) protect me.

Otherwise, Teyla.

[.:Lemon:.]

Teyla- her hair would scare people away J/K I think she'd do better in a physical fight, and her diplomatic skills aren't to bad either.

[NightGloom]

If it's a physical fight then Teyla, but if it's something I could talk myself out of then Weir.

[Happytree_8]

I would choose Teyla. She is a warrior, and if she is the leader of her people, she must have some type of nagotionation(spelling?) skills also.

[WraithWarrior]

Id like Teyla to defend me, she'd just kick a$$ and id remain safe

[Elthial]

You dont have to be good at negotiation to be a leader, a loud voice and a club will do as well.

For example, the goa'uld are not the greatest negotiators but they're fairly solidly in power.... kinda... (ignoring how their dropping like flys to the Tau'ri)