Interview with Fabrice Grover (Amelius)

[g.o.d]

http://www.stargate-sg1-planet.de/ar...r2008-eng.html

he scene we shot for the prologue of the film was longer than it appears in the final edit. I guess a long philosophical debate about the nature of truth does not make for an action packed beginning to a movie! But I enjoyed the original dialogue.

great! instead of that idiotic replicator part, they should have kept this original longer debate in the beginning. It would be much more interesting than shooting replicators aboard the Oddysey.

[PG15]

No thanks. I was happy for that whole scene to be over; if I want a philosophical debate, I'd read Plato.

Show, not tell please.

[jelgate]

No thanks. I was happy for that whole scene to be over; if I want a philosophical debate, I'd read Plato.

Show, not tell please.

No Aristole.

[g.o.d]

No thanks. I was happy for that whole scene to be over; if I want a philosophical debate, I'd read Plato.

Show, not tell please.

of course, why should we have deeper insight into Alteran society and the Ori? It's much better to spend hours with shooting replicators

I'm not expecting SG to be another Babylon 5, but it's still the same. Instead of having interesting debates and stories, we have brainless stories

[PG15]

That debate was about as interesting as a high school debate...as in not. I should know; I've been in plenty of those; especially about the nature of Truth.

Sorry, but I didn't see anything there that we didn't know already. Ancients value freewill, Ori gonna kill them, but they still are too good to use the Ark. Whatever stuff they cut, it would still end up in the same place. I don't see how much more "insightful" it'd get.

And no, I don't rather see more replicator fighting; I'd rather see LESS of a boring bit of dialogue badly acted out stretched even further.

[Platschu]

I didn't know why they couldn't put the extended version next to the "normal" version on the AoT DVD. This film was made for the fans, so every minute is a gift. An 100-120 minutes long movie could be even better. I would like to see the Area51 scene, where they destroyed the Ark at the end.

[morjana]

No thanks. I was happy for that whole scene to be over; if I want a philosophical debate, I'd read Plato.

Show, not tell please.

To be is to do...Plato

To do is to be...Aristotle

Do be do be do...Sinatra



Morjana

[Guest]

To be is to do...Plato

To do is to be...Aristotle

Do be do be do...Sinatra



Morjana

[Rosehawk]

To be is to do...Plato

To do is to be...Aristotle

Do be do be do...Sinatra



Morjana

And don't forget the one and only Scooby Dooby Doo!

[Rosehawk]

http://www.stargate-sg1-planet.de/ar...r2008-eng.html

Thanks g.o.d for the link to the article!

[g.o.d]

I didn't know why they couldn't put the extended version next to the "normal" version on the AoT DVD. This film was made for the fans, so every minute is a gift. An 100-120 minutes long movie could be even better. I would like to see the Area51 scene, where they destroyed the Ark at the end.

gift? Perhaps for you. For me, every minute was s despair

[Jedi_Master_Bra'tac]

g.o.d - you should really read GW's interview with Rob "Myth Maker parts 1 & 2"

[g.o.d]

g.o.d - you should really read GW's interview with Rob "Myth Maker parts 1 & 2"

I already did. Why?

[Platschu]

g.o.d. : Let yourself be entertained. This is only a light scifi TV show. You can't expect great drama scenes or long story arcs.

[Mitchell82]

No thanks. I was happy for that whole scene to be over; if I want a philosophical debate, I'd read Plato.

Show, not tell please.

The scene was a perfect length. Too long and it would be boring.