Hey dont get me wrong i am a massive sci fi fan, star trek tos since i was a child SG1 since it was first aired, Same with BSG But i thought AOT was once of the worst SG events. Ive still seen it 3 times now and bought the DVD an all but was noone else confused by how replicatros could magically controll a human, the logic behind one of them even doing it? A replicator staying in a ackward human/terminator forum even though bugs ae far more efficient for movement.
I may over reacted giving it a 3 but most if not all SG episodes where better than that. For tieing up a story i think SG1's Full circle at the end of season 6 when there was a slight worry of cancellation was fantastic. This movie did not need the replicators.
SG has always had that cheeze element which i love but this movie didnt take it too far it just wasent cheese except for that scene where tel'c is doing his long walk to help rescue.
All in all its ok/good but i still struggle to understand how over 1/2 of all voters though this a 10/10 And if this is a 10/10 how do they rate other episodes of SG1 like Season 6's Abyss or Full Circle. Or the two parter about Sokar (Jolinars memories) Episodes that make Stargate Stargate!.
Do you all consider this movie to be on par with those episodes?
I may over reacted giving it a 3 but most if not all SG episodes where better than that. For tieing up a story i think SG1's Full circle at the end of season 6 when there was a slight worry of cancellation was fantastic. This movie did not need the replicators.
SG has always had that cheeze element which i love but this movie didnt take it too far it just wasent cheese except for that scene where tel'c is doing his long walk to help rescue.
All in all its ok/good but i still struggle to understand how over 1/2 of all voters though this a 10/10 And if this is a 10/10 how do they rate other episodes of SG1 like Season 6's Abyss or Full Circle. Or the two parter about Sokar (Jolinars memories) Episodes that make Stargate Stargate!.
Do you all consider this movie to be on par with those episodes?
Comment